성 보수주의와 남성 성 자유주의를 넘어: 페미니스트는 포르노 문제에 어떻게 대응할 것인가 = Beyond Male Sexual Liberalism: How Should Feminists Deal with Pornography?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Pornography has been a heated issue for American feminists, dividing them into two opposite camps, whereas Korean feminists kept silent during the pornography debate in the 1990s when the event of Jang Jungil, a Korean male novelist who wrote a sexually explicit novel and got imprisoned for that, took place. In the Korean sexual debate male sexual liberals and radicals fought against legal authority whose ideological position was based on moral conservatism; they advocated the right of writing and enjoying pornography, and criticized feminists for colluding with sexual conservatives. During that period Korean feminists belatedly exposed the sexual violence in Korean progressive movements in the 80s and early 90s, arguing for women`s rights of sexual self-determination. This article attempts to map out the topography of sexual ideology in Korea since late 1990s, and examine how to tackle the issue of pornography. First, it critically examines several definitions of pornography, both Korean and American, and then attempts to explain the tempting power of pornography on men, borrowing Drucilla Cornell`s psychoanalytic interpretation, Pornography reflects men`s sexual fantasy where lie their desire for and dread of the phallic mother; once the fantasized mother/infant dyad is broken, the phallic mother remains, in its unconscious, powerful and threatening; she at once gives and takes back life. In order to compensate for her power, the infant attempts to penetrate and destroy her through the father`s imaginary penis. It is the biological penis, the simplistic conflation of the penis with the phallus, that is portrayed in pornography, This ever-erect prick is just a fantasy, yet it exerts a powerful influence on men, Pornography as a representation of this masculine fantasy, I argue, harms women`s imaginary domain, a term coined by Cornell for indicating psychic and moral space in which one imagines who one is and who one seeks to become. I argue for feminist`s response to pornography shifting from legal regulation to political intervention. Legal regulation on pornography limits not only men`s but also women`s freedom of sexual expression, pivotal for women`s exploration of their selves. However, pornograph`s curtailment of women`s equal right for imaginary domain should be countered in political and cultural dimension. In conclusion, I argue for the responsibility for our desire as well as the demand for its right in order to live together.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이재현, "포르노티즘과 에로그라피2-1" (11) : 113-122, 1997

2 김수기, "포르노에 대한 다른 시각, In 섹스 포르노 에로티즘: 쾌락의 악몽을 넘어서" 현실문화연구 115-140, 1994

3 서윤호, "포르노를 허하라? 포르노 규제 법리에 대한 고찰" 85-102, 2012

4 박종성, "포르노는 없다: 권력에 대한 복합적 반감의 표현" 인간사랑 2003

5 주유신, "포르노그래피와 여성의 성적 주체성-페미니스트 포르노 논쟁과 두 편의 텍스트를 중심으로-" 한국영화학회 (26) : 397-424, 2005

6 이나영, "포르노그래피, 억압과 해방의 이분법을 넘어, In 섹슈얼리티 강의, 두 번째" 동녘 277-311, 2006

7 오기 오가스, "포르노 보는 남자 로맨스 읽는 여자" 웅진지식하우스 2011

8 운동사회성폭력뿌리뽑기100인위원회, "쥐는 언제나 고양이를 물어서는 안된다?" (49) : 150-176, 2001

9 최성희, "자아로부터의 비상, 에로스, In 페미니즘: 차이와 사이" 문학동네 83-109, 2011

10 최수태, "욕망해도 괜찮아? ‘강부자’, ‘고소영’, ‘김재철’도?!"

11 김두식, "욕망해도 괜찮아" 창비 2012

12 김종갑, "실재를 향한 열정으로서 포르노" 57-73, 2012

13 황정미, "성폭력의 정치에서 젠더정치로" (49) : 177-199, 2001

14 신상숙, "성폭력의 의미구성과 ‘성적 자기결정권’의 딜렘마" (13) : 6-43, 2001

15 린 헌트, "서문: 외설성과 현대성의 기원, 1500-1800, In 포르노그라피의 발명" 책세상 9-54, 1996

16 유영소, "삐딱하게 보기" 시각과 언어 1995

17 에티엔 발리바르, "대중들의 공포" 도서출판b 2008

18 서동진, "누가 성정치학을 두려워하랴!, In 섹스 포르노 에로티즘: 쾌락의 악몽을 넘어서" 현실문화연구 9-53, 1994

19 Marcus, Steven, "The Other Victorians: A Study of Sexuality and Pornography in Mid-Nineteenth-Century England" Basic Books 1967

20 Butler, Judith, "The Force of Fantasy: Feminism, Mapplethorpe, and Discursive Excess, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford UP 487-508, 2000

21 Coward, Roth, "Sexual Violence and Sexuality, In Sexuality: A Reader" Virage 307-326, 1987

22 Russell, Diana E. H., "Pornography and Rape: A Causal Model, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford UP 48-93, 2000

23 Dworkin Andrea, "Pornography and Civil Rights: A New Day" Organizing Against Pornography 1988

24 Carter, Angela, "Polemical Preface: Pornography on the Service of Women, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford UP 527-539, 2000

25 MacKinnon, Catharine, "Only Words" Harvard UP 1993

26 MacKinnon, Catharine, "Not a Moral Issue, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford UP 169-197, 2000

27 MacKinnon, Catharine A, "Feminism Unmodified: Discourse on Life and Law" Harvard UP 1987

28 이재현, "Do the Right thing: 욕설의 진술을 통한 역설의 진술" (봄) : 82-96, 1997

29 Cornell, Drucilla, "Abortion, Pornography and Sexual Harassment" Routledge 1995

30 이노우에 세쓰코, "15조원의 육체산업: AV시장을 해부하다" 시네 21북스 2009