A Quality Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials about Erectile Dysfunction

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: A low quality clinical trial could produce errors, and these errors could, in turn, distort the results of the clinical trial. To avoid applying distorted results of trials clinically, a quality analysis of clinical trials is needed. Materials and Methods: We selected randomized controlled trials (RCTs) about erectile dysfunction (ED) conducted in Korea using Medline and KoreaMed. Quality assessment of selected RCTs was performed using three assessment tools (Jadad scales, van Tulder scale, Cochrane Collaboration Risk of Bias Tool [CCRBT]).Results: The first RCT about ED conducted in Korea was published in 2002. Since 2002, a total of 20 RCTs have been published in medical journals. Among the 20 articles, only 1 article was found to have a low risk of bias according to the CCRBT. On the Jadad scale, there were 17 high quality articles, while 19 articles were assessed as high quality by the VTS. Only 2 RCTs described the randomization method adequately. Only 1 RCT presented allocation concealment.Conclusions: A low quality clinical trial could produce errors, and these errors could, in turn, distort the results of the clinical trial. To avoid applying distorted results of trials clinically, a quality analysis of clinical trials is needed. The quality of RCTs was found to be high because almost all of the selected RCTs were double blinded studies. However, the quality of RCTs was inadequate with regard to the lack of randomization and absence of allocation concealment. Therefore, performing adequate randomization and adding a description of the appropriate concealment of allocation may improve the quality of RCTs.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 정우빈, "대한가정의학회지에 실린 무작위대조시험논문의 질 평가" 대한가정의학회 30 (30): 626-631, 2009

2 임선미, "근거수준별 문헌의 질 평가 도구" 대한의사협회 54 (54): 419-429, 2011

3 Brant WO, "Treatment options for erectile dysfunction" 36 : 465-479, 2007

4 McKinlay JB, "The worldwide prevalence and epidemiology of erectile dysfunction" 12 (12): S6-S11, 2000

5 Jackson JL, "The validity of peer review in a general medicine journal" 6 : e22475-, 2011

6 Konstantinopoulos A, "The impact of daily sildenafil on levels of soluble molecular markers of endothelial function in plasma in patients with erectile dysfunction" 10 : 155-160, 2009

7 Uetani K, "Quality of reports on randomized controlled trials conducted in Japan: evaluation of adherence to the CONSORT statement" 48 : 307-313, 2009

8 이주용, "Quality Assessment of Randomized Controlled Trials Published in the Korean Journal of Urology Over the Past 20 Years" 대한비뇨기과학회 52 (52): 642-646, 2011

9 Carrier S, "Pathophysiology of erectile dysfunction" 42 : 468-481, 1993

10 Johannes CB, "Incidence of erectile dysfunction in men 40 to 69 years old: longitudinal results from the Massachusetts male aging study" 163 : 460-463, 2000

11 Begg C, "Improving the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials. The CONSORT statement" 276 : 637-639, 1996

12 Lue TF, "Erectile dysfunction" 342 : 1802-1813, 2000

13 Shamloul R, "Erectile dysfunction" 381 : 153-165, 2013

14 van Tulder M, "Editorial Board of the Cochrane Collaboration Back Review Group. Updated method guidelines for systematic reviews in the cochrane collaboration back review group" 28 : 1290-1299, 2003

15 "Consensus development conference statement. NationalInstitutes of Health. Impotence. December 7-9, 1992" 5 : 181-284, 1993

16 Jadad AR, "Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary?" 17 : 1-12, 1996

17 Moher D, "Assessing the quality of reports of randomised trials: implications for the conduct of meta-analyses" 3 (3): 1-98, 1999

18 정재훈, "Assessing the Quality of Randomized Controlled Trials Published in the Journal of Korean Medical Science from 1986 to 2011" 대한의학회 27 (27): 973-980, 2012

19 Schulz KF, "Allocation concealment in randomised trials: defending against deciphering" 359 : 614-618, 2002

20 Hewitt C, "Adequacy and reporting of allocation concealment: review of recent trials published in four general medical journals" 330 : 1057-1058, 2005

21 Liberati A, "A quality assessment of randomized control trials of primary treatment of breast cancer" 4 : 942-951, 1986