한국전쟁 전후 민간인학살과 20세기의 내전

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Why so many civilians were killed during the Korean War? In this paper, i want to examine and understand this phenomenon as process, features and results of civil war rather than see it through ‘transitional Justice’ perspective.
Nowadays, most of war is not inter-state war, but civil war. Civil war generalized during the 20th century, because the european modernity which limited war as inert-state war between two sovereign states, has collapsed by two World War. Especially, during the cold war period, civil wars, guerrilla wars and irregular wars were universalized and core states have intervened to peripheral state’s nation building process and their civil war. As western powers intervened to post colonial state, counter insurgency technique and state of exception was institutionalized to suppress revolutionary civil war. And 20th century’s war have becomes gradually a genocidal war in which targeted civilians.
Civilian massacres which occurred during around the Korean war can be categorized by several types which related each types of civil war.
First, there were already civil war situation in which several thousands of civilians killed by nation-building or counter insurgency operation between 1946 and 1948. In this time, illegal and unconstitutional martial law which has no ground and authority declared, and summary executions happened everywhere, and the korean constabulary was created to suppress mass riots.
Second, this situation continued at Jiri-mountain area for six years (1949-1955), as rebels and people who joined to them entered the mountain. Irregular warfare and counter partisan operation started and many civilians massacred by military and polices who considered people as collaborators.
Third, systemic mass killing of the national guidance alliance during early phase of the Korean war was caused by institutionalized civil war or ‘state of exception’. They were regarded as political prisoners and enemy who tergiversated by military intelligence agency and military police.
Lastly, mass killing of so called ‘collaborators’ at late 1950, was performed by mass and para-military youth organization which politically mobilized by government and legal system.
In western society, the history of civil war was history of revolution which created modern world, however, for us, civil war was remained as war which wasn’t authorized as interstate war, as nation-buinding which intervened by western powers, as suppressed social revolution and civillian masscres. Therefore, to understand civil war will be reflection about something supressed, boundaries which was created or collapsed by civil war.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 한국전쟁전후 민간인 학살 사건과 내전
• Ⅱ. 20세기 내전의 성격과 전쟁 양식의 변화
• Ⅲ. 한국전쟁 전후 민간인 학살 사건의 유형과 내전
• Ⅳ. 나가며 : 내전적 통치성과 도달가능한 정의의 경계
• 참고문헌
• abstracts

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Cummings, Bruce, "한국전쟁의 기원" 일월서각 1986

2 김동춘, "한국전쟁기 민간인 희생사건, 어떻게 해결되어야 하나" 성공회대민주주의연구소, 한국전쟁전후민간인학살진상규명범국민위원회 2010

3 김득중, "한국전쟁 전후 육군 방첩대(CIC)의 조직과 활동" 수선사학회 (36) : 21-62, 2010

4 서중석, "한국전쟁 전후 민간인집단학살의 연구 방향" 수선사학회 (36) : 1-20, 2010

5 Schmitt, Carl, "파르티잔 : 그 존재와 의미" 문학과 지성사 1998

6 이마이히로미찌, "특집: 긴급권국가로서의 『메이지(明治)국가』의 법구조 -동아시아의 관점에서-" 한국법사학회 (27) : 139-163, 2003

7 Janssen, Wilhelm, "코젤렉의 개념사 사전 4 : 전쟁Krieg" 푸른역사 2010

8 정호기, "진실규명의 제도화와 다층적 재조명" (6) : 2009

9 제주4･3사건진상조사보고서작성기획단, "제주4･3사건진상조사보고서" 제주4‧3사건진상규명및희생자명예회복위원회 2003

10 박원순, "전쟁부역자 5만여 명 어떻게 처리되었나" 172-198, 1990

11 정근식, "전쟁기 한국 군･경에 의한 희생사건 해결의 경과와 남은 과제 : 민간인 희생자에 대한 국가의 응답" 성공회대민주주의연구소, 한국전쟁전후민간인학살진상규명범국민위원회 2010

12 김동춘, "전쟁과 사회" 돌베개 2000

13 Arrighi, Giovanni, "장기 20세기 - 화폐, 권력, 그리고 우리시대의 기원" 그린비 2008

14 Balibar, Étienne, "우리, 유럽의 시민들? - 세계화와 민주주의의 재발명" 후마니타스 2010

15 Agamben, Giorgio, "예외상태" 새물결 2009

16 김학재, "여순사건과 예외상태 국가의 건설" (6) : 2009

17 Kaldor, Mary, "새로운 전쟁과 낡은 전쟁 : 세계화 시대의 조직화된 폭력" 그린비 2010

18 김득중, "빨갱이의 탄생" 선인 2009

19 김학재, "비상사태하범죄처벌특별조치령의 형성과 성격, in: 전쟁, 법, 민주주의 - 냉전의 극복과 전시법의 민주화를 위하여" 2009

20 Schmitt, Carl, "대지의 노모스 - 유럽 공법의 국제법" 민음사 1995

21 박원순, "국가보안법연구 2" 역사비평사 1989

22 김도창, "국가긴급권론" 청운사 1972

23 김학재, "국가권력의 모세혈관과 1950년대의 대중동원, in: 죽엄으로써 나라를 지키자 - 1950년대 반공, 동원, 감시의 시대" 선인 2007

24 Polanyi, Karl, "거대한 전환 - 우리시대의 정치적･경제적 기원" 길 2009

25 Shaw, Martin, "What is Genocide? A New Social Theory" Polity 2007

26 Shaw, Martin, "War and Genocide : Organized Killing in Modern Society" Polity 2003

27 Duffey, Tamara, "United Nations peacekeeping in the post-cold war world" 1 (1): 1-23, 1998

28 Birtle, Andrew J., "U.S. Army Counterinsurgency and Contingency Operations Doctrine, 1942-1976" Center of Military History United States Army 2006

29 Kritz, Neil J., "Transitional Justice: How Emerging Democracies Reckon with Former Regimes, Vol. Ⅰ-Ⅲ" United States Institute of Peace Press 1995

30 Lambourne, Wendy, "Transitional Justice and Peacebuilding after Mass Violence" 3 (3): 28-48, 2009

31 Newman, Edward, "The ‘New Wars’ Debate: A Historical Perspective is Needed" 35 (35): 173-189, 2004

32 Bliesemann de Guevara, Berit, "The State in Times of Statebuilding" 10 (10): 348-368, 2008

33 Kestnbaum, Meyer, "The Sociology of War and the Military" 35 (35): 235-254, 2009

34 Kalyvas, Stathis N., "The Logic of Violence in Civil War" Cambridge University Press 2006

35 Lockyer, Adam, "The Dynamics of Warfare in Civil War" 12 (12): 91-116, 2010

36 Badiou, Alain, "The Century" Polity Press 2007

37 Dobbins, James., "The Beginner’s Guide to Nation-Building" RAND Corporation 2007

38 Boulden, Jane, "Terrorism and Civil Wars" 11 (11): 5-21, 2009

39 Boswell, Terry, "Revolution in the World-System" Greenwood Press 1989

40 Small, Melvin, "Resort to Arms: International and Civil War, 1816-1980" Sage 1982

41 Mbembe, Achille, "Necropolitics" 15 (15): 11-40, 2003

42 Downes, Alexander B., "Introduction: Modern Insurgency and ounterinsurgency in Comparative Perspective" 9 (9): 313-323, 2007

43 Fearon, James D., David D. Laitin, "International Institutions and Civil War"

44 Sarkees, Meredith Reid., "Inter-state, Intra-State, and Extra-State Wars: A Comprehensive Look at Their Distribution over Time, 1816-1997" 47 (47): 49-70, 2003

45 Minehan, Philip B., "Civil War and World War in Europe : Spain, Yugoslavia and Greece, 1936-1949" Palgrave Macmillan 2006

46 Reardon, Mark J., "Chasing a Chameleon: The U.S. Army Counterinsurgency Experience in Korea, 1945-1952" Center of Military History United States Army 2008

47 Kennedy-Pipe, Caroline, "An introduction to civil wars" 1 (1): 1-15, 1998

48 임덕규, "6･25전쟁과 전시 국제법의 적용실태" 41 (41): 181-213, 2001

49 진실화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회, "2009년 하반기 조사보고서" 진실･화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회 2009

50 진실화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회, "2009년 하반기 조사보고서" 진실･화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회 2009

51 진실화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회, "2008년 하반기 조사보고서" 진실･화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회 2008

52 진실화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회, "2008년 상반기 조사보고서" 진실･화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회 2008

53 진실･화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회, "2007년 상반기 조사보고서" 진실･화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회 2007

54 진실화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회, "2007년 상반기 조사보고서" 진실·화해를 위한 과거사정리위원회 2007

55 노영기, "1945-50년 한국군의 형성과 성격" 성균관대학교 2008

56 정해구, "10월 인민항쟁 연구" 열음사 1988