노동-가치-가격의 양적 관계에 관한 논리적 정합성 연구 = A Study on the Logical Consistency of Quantitative Relations among Labour, Value and Price

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

According to the non-dualism approach, there was no logical inconsistency in the transformation of value into prices. But the value scheme is incomplete and it is necessary to complement the analysis on quantitative relations between labour time and prices in the aggregate. As we have seen in the dualism approach, the equalities of labour time and prices in the aggregate are no longer compatible with one another simultaneously. For example, the price (x) of total net products is generally different from total direct labour (Ｌ_(d)=1) under the numeraire: the price of total constant ccapital = the total indirect labour (i,e., C=c). This paper is focused on finding the law which makes the aggregate inequality. In this paper. this law is specified as follows. The first condition is (dx)/(dc)_(de=0) >0, and the second condition is (dx)/(dc)_(de=0) < (x)/(c), where ℓ is the rate of surplus value. The two conditions are necessary conditions for the profitability of total capital. These conditions are general properties in the input/output model. Especially, we can prove that these conditions are satisfied in the two product system. Under this law, price changes within the limit of predictable magnitude. Although masses weigh differently, it is hard to say that masses are not related to weight, We can think that value is to price as mass is to weight. Therefore, even though not ensuring equalities between labout time and prices in the aggregate, we can insist that prices are quantitatively regulated by labour. Under this law, we also don`t need to set up the concepts of value in a restrictive way. There is no reason why value is labour itself. We can variously set up value as an analytical tool to contemporary capitalism

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "직접노동과 간접노동의 전형과정 연구" 1995

2 "전형과정의 두가지 문제:불변자본의 재생산과 리카도적 편향을 제거하기 위하여" 1994

3 "이윤분배제도 도입에 따른 자본의 유기적 구성과 이윤율 간의 양적 관계의 변화" 13 : 1999

4 "생산가격에 의한 가치체계의 재생산" 51 (51): 2003

5 "사회적 총자본의 축적 가능성에 의한 가치와 생산가격의 총계불일치 해명" 10 : 1997

6 "맑스가치론의 이시적 단일체계 해석에 대한 비판적 검토" 48 (48): 2000

7 "가치와 생산가격 이론에 대한 연구" 1990

8 "ꡔ資本論の硏究ꡕ" 靑木書店 1986

9 "ꡔ經濟學のペラダイムチェインジꡕ" 創風社 1998

10 "Value, Price and the Neo-Ricardians: An Introductory Note" 1994

11 "Value, Exchange Value and Internal Consistency of Volume III of Capital:A Refutation of Refutations" 1998

12 "Value and Price in the Marxian System" (2) : 1952

13 "Value and Price in Marx’s Capiteal" (1) : 1975

14 "Value and Crisis" 비봉 1988

15 "Understanding the Marxian Notation of Exploitation : theso-called Transformation Problem between Marxian Value and Competitive Prices" 1988

16 "Theorie der Regulation" Wissenschaftszentrum Berlin fürSozialforchung 1989

17 "The ‘Transformation Problem’" 1976

18 "The so-called ‘Transformation Problem’ Revisited" 26 (26): 1982

19 "The Value of Money the Value of Labour Power and the Marxian TransformationProblem" 14 (14): 1982

20 "The Value of Marx: Political economy for contemporary Capitalism" London:Routledge 2002

21 "The Value Dimension" 1986

22 "The Transformation of Value into Prices ofProduction: a different Reading of Marx's Test" 1996

23 "The Transformation Problem solved?" 13 : 1989

24 "The Theory of Capitalist Development" Monthly Review Press 1942

25 "The Logic of Prices as Values" 1986

26 "The 'New Solution' to the Transformation Problem: A SympatheticCritque" 32 (32): 2000

27 "Some Notes on the ‘Transformation Problem’" 1988

28 "Regulation and Marx" 1995

29 "Regulation Theory" Routledge 1995

30 "Recent Developments in the Labour Theory of Value" 32 (32): 2000

31 "Profit and Surplus Value : Appearance and Reality in Capitalist Production" 1972

32 "Price, Value and Profit" Freeman & Carchedi 1996

33 "One System or Two? The Transformation of Value into Prices of Productionversus the Transformation Problem" 1996

34 "Marx’s Economics" Cambridge University Press 1973.

35 "Marxian Economics II: A Reappraisal --Essays on Volume III of Capital" London:Macmillan 1998

36 "Marx's theory of Value and the Transformation Problem" 1977

37 "Marx's logical Method and the Transformation Problem" 1993

38 "Marx's labour theory of value revisited" 17 (17): 1993

39 "Marx's Method in Capital: A Reexamination" Humanity Press 1993

40 "Marx's Logic in Capital and the ‘Transformation Problem’" 1998

41 "Marx and Non-Equilibrium Economics" Aldershot:EdwardElgar 1996

42 "Marx after Sraffa" New Left Books 1977

43 "La Violence de la Monnaie" 法政大學出版局 1991

44 "Karl Marx’s Economics : Critical Assessments IV" 1988

45 "History of Economic Thought: A Critical Perspective" Wadsworth Publishing Co 1979

46 "Embodied labour and competitive prices : a physical quantities approach" 21 (21): 1997

47 "Debates in Value Theory" St. Martin's Press 1994

48 "CapitalⅢ" 이론과 실천 1990

49 "CapitalI" Penguin 1976

50 "Beyond the Transformation Riddle: a Labor Theory of Value" 47 (47): 1983

51 "Absolute Value and Exchangeable Value" Cambridge Univ.Press 1970

52 "A Theory of Capitalist Regulation" New Left Books 1979

53 "A Temporal Single-System Interpretation of Marx's ValueTheory" (35) : 1998

54 "A Marxian Alternative to the Traditional" 16 (16): 1984