과학 탐구 기반의 통합적 STEM 교육 모형 개발 및 적용 = Development and Application of Integrative STEM, Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics, Education Model Based on Scientific Inquiry

국문 초록 (Abstract)

통합적 STEM 교육은 과학, 기술, 공학, 수학의 내용과 과정을 체계적이고 의도적으로 통합하려는 공학적 설계기반 학습을 말하며, 다른 교과와 통합을 통해 더욱 발달할 수 있다. 이 연구는 과학 탐구 기반의 통합적 STEM 교육 프로그램의 개발과 효과 검증을 위한 기초연구이며, STEM 교육 관련 문헌 연구를 통해 STEM 교육의 가치와 핵심 요소를 분석하고 과학 탐구 기반의 통합적 STEM 교육 모형의 개발 및 모형을 적용하여 개발한 대표적인 예시 프로그램을 제시하는 것이다. 모형에 포함될 요소를 확정하기 위해 문헌 분석을 실시하였고, 선행 연구에 포함된 내용과 탐구 과정을 분석하여 통합적 STEM 교육 모형을 구성하였다. 전문가의 내용 타당도 분석 결과 CVR 값의 평균은 0.78로 구성된 모형은 내용 타당도가 있는 것으로 판단되었다. 이 STEM 교육 모형은 내용과 탐구 과정의 두 가지 측면으로 나누어진다. 내용의 측면은 실생활 문제에서 경험할 수 있는 과학, 기술, 공학, 수학 그리고 인문사회와 예술적 소재까지 포괄할 수 있으며, 탐구 과정은 설계와 제작을 기반으로 한 문제해결 과정이다. 탐구 과정은 과학 탐구를 기반으로 하여 기술·공학적 문제해결 과정을 적용할 수 있도록 구성하였다. 학생들은 실생활 문제를 분석하고, 설계하고 제작하는 과정에서 STEM 교과에 대한 흥미를 향상시킬 수 있고 문제에 포함된 지식과 탐구의 방법과 기능을 체계적으로 학습할 수 있다. 개발된 프로그램은 학교 현장에서 활용되어, STEM 교과에 대한 이해도 증진과 과학, 수학에 대한 흥미를 높이고, 과학기술 기반의 융합적 소양과 설계 기반의 문제해결력을 배양하는 데 기여할 수 있을 것이다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Integrative STEM education is an engineering design-based learning approach that purposefully integrates the content and process of STEM disciplines and can extend its concept to integration with other school subjects. This study was part of fundamental research to develop an integrative STEM education program based on the science inquiry process. The specific objectives of this study were to review relevant literature related to STEM education, analyze the key elements and value of STEM education, develop an integrative STEM education model based on the science inquiry process, and suggest an exemplary program. This study conducted a systematic literature review to confirm key elements for integrative STEM education and finally constructed the integrative STEM education model through analyzing key inquiry processes extracted from prior studies. This model turned out to be valid because the average CVR value obtained from expert group was 0.78. The integrative STEM education model based on the science inquiry process consisted of two perspectives of the content and inquiry process. The content can contain science, technology, engineering, and liberal arts/artistic topics that students can learn in a real world context/problem. Also, the inquiry process is a problem-solving process that contains design and construction and is based on the science inquiry. It could integrate the technological/engineering problem solving process and/or mathematical problem solving process. Students can improve their interest in STEM subjects by analyzing real world problems, designing possible solutions, and implementing the best design as well as acquire knowledge, inquiry methods, and skills systematically. In addition, the developed programs could be utilized in schools to enhance students` understanding of STEM disciplines and interest in mathematics and science. The programs could be used as a basis for fostering convergence literacy and cultivating integrated and design-based problemㆍsolving ability.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 조재주, "화학영역의 통합적 STEM 발명교육 프로그램 모형 개발" 한국실과교육연구학회 17 (17): 165-188, 2011

2 배선아, "중학교 전기전자기술 영역의 활동 중심 STEM 교육프로그램 개발 및 적용" 대한공업교육학회 36 (36): 1-22, 2011

3 김성원, "융합인재교육(STEAM)을 위한 이론적 모형의 제안" 한국과학교육학회 32 (32): 388-401, 2012

4 김부윤, "우리나라에서의 수학적 문제해결연구" 한국수학교육학회 42 (42): 6-158, 2003

5 최봉섭, "아동의 만들기 체험활동을 위한 TSM 통합교육 프로그램 개발-모형 배 만들기 중심으로-" 한국실과교육학회 17 (17): 191-205, 2004

6 김진수, "기술교육의 새로운 통합교육 방법인 STEM 교육의 탐색" 한국기술교육학회 7 (7): 1-29, 2007

7 이효녕, "공학적 설계와 과학 탐구 과정 기반의 STEM 교육 프로그램 개발 및 적용" 교육연구원 29 (29): 301-326, 2013

8 배선아, "공업계열 전문계 고등학교 활동 중심 STEM 교육프로그램 개발 모형" 한국실과교육연구학회 15 (15): 345-368, 2009

9 배선아, "공업계열 전문계 고등학교 화공 분야의 STEM 교육에 대한 화공교사의 인식과 요구" 대한공업교육학회 35 (35): 44-67, 2010

10 Bisogno, J., "Virtual bridge design" Science Scope 26-33, 2008

11 Wiggins, G., "Understanding by design" Association of Supervision and Curriculum Development 1998

12 Choi, K., "Understanding and application of STS education" Kyohak Publishing Company 1996

13 Puntambekar, S., "Toward implementing distributed scaffolding : Helping students learn science from design" 42 (42): 185-217, 2005

14 Vygotsky, L. S., "Thought and Language" M.I.T. Press 1962

15 Mcdermott, R., "Thinking practices" Lawence Erlbaum Association 321-340, 1998

16 Norton, S. J., "The use of design practice to teach mathematics and science" 18 (18): 19-44, 2006

17 Lee, H., "The understanding and application of science inquiry and design-based STEM/STEAM education" Bookshill Publishing Company 2012

18 Cho, H., "The theory of science and science education" Kyoyookbook Publishing Company 1995

19 International Technology and Engineering Educators Association[ITEEA]., "The overlooked STEM imperatives: Technology and engineering" International Technology and Engineering Educators Association[ITEEA] 2009

20 Lee, D., "The need for STEM Education, awareness and demand for technology teachers" Chungnam National University 2011

21 Department for Education, "The national curriculum in England Framework document"

22 Ministry of Education[MOE]., "The introduction and policy direction of STEAM education" Ministry of Education[MOE] 2013

23 Venville, G., "The integration of science, mathematics, and technology in a discipline-based culture" 98 (98): 294-302, 1998

24 National Academy of Engineering[NAE], "The engineer of 2020:Visions of engineering in the new century" National Academies Press 2004

25 Hong, J., "The effects of decision-making centered - STS(Science -Technology -Society) classes on the students’ attitudes towards science and perceptions about STS" 21 (21): 422-432, 2001

26 Yang, J., "The effect of 3D CAD based STEM education on spatial visualization ability of elementary school's students" Chongju National University 2009

27 Bae, S., "The development of activity-centered STEM education program of electricity, electronics, and communication area in industrial technical high school" Korea National University of Education 2009

28 Park, H., "The development of activity-centered MST program through making solar cell car for fifth and sixth grade elementary school" Korea National University of Education 2003

29 Jang, K. Y., "The changes of teacher perceptions on professional development program about multi-subject integration-based invention" Seoul National University 2009

30 Wang, S., "The application of social cognitive theory to web-based learning through NetPorts" 38 (38): 600-612, 2007

31 Yager, R. E., "The Science/technology/society movement in the United States : Its origin, evolution, and rationale" 54 (54): 198-201, 1990

32 Florida, R., "The Rise of Creative Class" Basic Books 2002

33 Lou, S-J., "The Impact of Problem-Based Learning Strategies on STEM Knowledge Integration and Attitudes : An Exploratory Study among Female Taiwanese Senior High School Students" 21 (21): 195-215, 2011

34 Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST], "The 2nd national plan for fostering science-technology human resources" Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST] 2011

35 Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST]., "The 2012policy report of MEST" Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST] 2012

36 Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST], "The 2011policy report of MEST" Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST] 2010

37 Sinn, J., "Technology-based math and science applications" 55 (55): 16-24, 1995

38 LaPorte, J. E., "Technology science mathematics:Connection activities binder. Vol. 52" Glencoe/McGraw-Hill 1996

39 Hacker, M., "Technology education: Learning by design" Prentice-Hall 2004

40 Sanders, M., "Technology education in the middle level school : Its role and purpose" 83 (83): 34-44, 1999

41 National Research Council[NRC], "Technically speaking: Why all Americans need to know more about technology" National Academies Press 2002

42 Pearson, F., "Technically speaking: Why all Americans need to know more about technology" National Academy Press 2002

43 Racow, S. J., "Teaching science as inquiry" Phi Delta Kappa Educational Foundation 1986

44 Smith, K. L., "Teaching engineering at the K-12level : Two perspectives" 66 (66): 20-24, 2007

45 Ziman, J., "Teaching and learning about science and society" Cambridge University 1980

46 Bybee, R. W., "Teaching about science-technology-society(STS) : View of science education in the United State" 87 (87): 274-285, 1987

47 Korea Foundation for the Advancement of Science & Creativity[KOFAC]., "Teacher training program for STEAM education"

48 National Research Council[NRC], "Successful K-12 STEM Education:Identifying Effective Approaches in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics. Committee on Highly Successful Science Programs for K-12 Science Education. Board on Science Education and Board on Testing and Assessment, Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education" The National Academies Press 2011

49 National Center for Education Statistics[NCES], "Students who study science, technology, engineering and mathematics(STEM) in postsecondary education" U.S. Department of Education 2009

50 International Technology Education Association[ITEA], "Standards for technological literacy: Content for the study of technology" International Technology Education Association[ITEA] 2007

51 Bandura, A., "Social foundations of thought and action" Prentice-Hall 1986

52 Bandura, A., "Social cognitive theory: An agentic perspective" 52 : 1-26, 2001

53 Bandura, A., "Social cognitive theory of self-regulation" 50 : 248-287, 1991

54 Bandura, A., "Self-efficacy: The exercise of control" W. H. Freeman and Company 1997

55 Cho, H., "Science-Technology-Society and science education" Kyoyookbook Publishing Company 1994

56 Chiappetta, E. L., "Science instruction in the middle and secondary schools" Merrill 2002

57 Kwon, Y., "Science education:From thinking to learning" Bookshill Publishing Company 2013

58 Rogers, M. A., "Science and mathematics: A natural connection" 60-61, 2007

59 Yakman, G., "STΣ@M Education: an overview of creating a model of integrative education" 2008

60 Sanders, M., "STEM, STEM education, STEM mania" 68 (68): 20-26, 2009

61 문대영, "STEM 통합 접근의 사전 공학교육 프로그램 모형 개발" 한국공학교육학회 11 (11): 90-101, 2008

62 최유현, "STEM 기반 발명영재교육 프로그램 개발과 적용 효과" 한국기술교육학회 8 (8): 143-164, 2008

63 이소이, "STEM 교육을 위한 기술 수업 설계 모형" 한국기술교육학회 11 (11): 1-20, 2011

64 Merill, C., "STEM education and leadership: A mathematics and science partnership approach" 21 (21): 21-34, 2010

65 김진수, "STEAM 교육을 위한 큐빅 모형" 한국기술교육학회 11 (11): 124-139, 2011

66 Freudenthal, H., "Revisiting mathematics education" Kluwer Academic Publisher 1991

67 권혁수, "Research Trends on the Integrative Efforts in Technology Education: Reviews of the Relevant Journals" 사범대학부속중등교육연구소 57 (57): 245-274, 2009

68 Wender, I., "Relation of technology, science, self-concept, interest, and gender" 30 (30): 43-51, 2004

69 Department for Education, "Reform of the national curriculum in England"

70 Kim, J., "Recent trends of education in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) in the U.S" Korea Institute of Science & Technology Evaluation and Planning 2011

71 U.S. Department of Education, "Race to the top program executive summary" Government Printing Office 2009

72 National Council of Teachers of Mathematics[NCTM], "Professional standards for teaching mathematics"

73 Kwon, J. S., "Problems of discipline centered science education and a method of the utilization of everyday materials in science education" 11 (11): 117-126, 1991

74 Torp, L. T., "Problems as possibilities: Problem-based learning for K-16 education" Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development 2002

75 Roth, W-M, "Problem-centered learning for the integration of mathematics and science in a constructivist laboratory : A case study" 93 (93): 13-122, 1993

76 Kolodner, J. L., "Problem-based learning meets case-based reasoning in the middle school science classroom : putting learning by design into practice" 12 (12): 495-547, 2003

77 New York State Department of Education[NYSDE], "Principles of engineering: A MST approach to technology education" New York State Department of Education[NYSDE] 1995

78 National Council of Teachers of Mathematics[NCTM], "Principles and Standard for School mathematics"

79 Harms, H. R., "Pre-Engineering" McGraw Hill 2012

80 McGinnis, J., "Perceptions of making connections between science and mathematics in a science methods course" 18 (18): 13-30, 2006

81 Minogue, J., "Paper tower: Building students’understanding of technological design" 18-20, 2006

82 OECD, "PISA 2006 Science Competencies for tomorrow's world. Volume 1: Analysis" OECD 2007

83 Scarborough, S. R., "PHYS-MA-TECH : An integrated partnership" 5 (5): 31-39, 1994

84 National Research Council[NRC], "Next generation science standards" The National Academies Press 2013

85 National Research Council[NRC], "National science education standards" National Academy Press 1996

86 Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST]., "National middle school curriculum(III): Mathematics, Science, Technology · Home Economics"

87 Ministry of Education and Human Resources Development[MOEHRD]., "National middle school curriculum"

88 Ministry of Education and Human Resources Development[MOEHRD]., "National high school curriculum"

89 Ko, J., "National assessment of educational achievement in 2005: The result analysis of the mathematics achievement test" Korea Institute for Curriculum and Evaluation 2007

90 Bybee, R. W., "NSTA yearbook: science/technology/society" National Science Teachers Association 1985

91 Frazier, W., "Motor mania: Revving up for technological design" 5-12, 2008

92 권혁수, "Motivation Issues in the Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) Education: A Meta-Analytic Approach" 사범대학부속중등교육연구소 56 (56): 125-147, 2008

93 Vygotsky, L. S., "Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes" Harvard University Press 1978

94 Roth, W-M., "Learning to talk engineering design: Results from an interpretive study in a grade 4/5 classroom" 6 (6): 107-135, 1996

95 Roth, W-M., "Learning science through technological design" 38 (38): 768-790, 2001

96 Roth, W-M, "Learning Science through technological design" 38 (38): 768-790, 1991

97 Murray, J., "Inventors in the making" 40-44, 2005

98 Petroski, H., "Invention by design: How engineers get from thought to thing" Harvard University Press 1996

99 Korea Foundation for the Advancement of Science & Creativity[KOFAC]., "Introduction of STEAM education policy"

100 Farrior, D., "Interdisciplinary lively application projects in calculus courses" 8 (8): 50-61, 2007

101 Sanders, M., "Integrative STEM Education definition"

102 LaPorte, J. E., "Integrating technology, science, and mathematics in the middle school" 52 (52): 17-21, 1993

103 Berlin, D. F., "Integrating science and mathematics education : Historical analysis" 105 (105): 15-24, 2005

104 Everett, L. J., "Integrated curricula : Purpose and design" 89 (89): 167-175, 2000

105 Center for Mathematics, Science, and Technology, "Integrated Mathematics, Science, and Technology (IMaST) Modules"

106 National Research Council[NRC], "Inquiry and the national science education standards: A guide for teaching and learning" National Academies Press 2000

107 Burghardt, M. D., "Informed design : A contemporary approach to design pedagogy as the core process in technology" 64 (64): 6-8, 2004

108 Brooks, J. G., "In search of understanding: The case for constructivist classrooms" Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development 1999

109 Hughes, B., "How to start a STEM team" 69 (69): 27-29, 2009

110 Polya, G., "How to solve it" Doubleday Co. Inc 1957

111 Lou, S-J., "How to Promote Knowledge Transfer through a Problem-Based Learning Internet Platform for Vocational High School Students" 35 (35): 539-551, 2010

112 Austin. C. Y., "Factors influencing African American high school students in career decision-making self efficacy and engineering related goal intentions" University of Minnesota 2009

113 Lomask, M., "Extended performance tasks for Mathematics, Science & Technology"

114 Daugherty, J. L., "Engineering professional development design for secondary school teachers : A multiple case study" 21 (21): 5-19, 2009

115 Karsnitz, J. R., "Engineering design:An instruction" Delmar 2009

116 권혁수, "Engineering Design: A Facilitator for Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics [STEM] Education" 과학교육연구소 33 (33): 207-219, 2009

117 National Academy of Engineering[NAE], "Educating the engineer of 2020: Adapting engineering education to the new century" National Academies Press 2005

118 Jensen, R., "Dream society" Glencoe/McGraw-Hill 2001

119 National Academy of Engineering[NAE], "Diversity in engineering:Managing the workforce of the future" National Academies Press 2002

120 Hofstein, A., "Discussions over STS at the fourth IOSTE symposium" 10 (10): 357-366, 1988

121 Byeon, S. H., "Development and application of invention educational program for students' creativity" Seoul National University 2010

122 Fortus, D., "Design-Based Science and Student Learning" 41 (41): 1081-1110, 2004

123 De Romero, N., "Design challenges "ELL-elementary"" 34-37, 2006

124 Lewis, T., "Design and inquiry: Bases for an accommodation between science and technology education in the curriculum?" 43 (43): 255-281, 2006

125 Venville, G., "Decision making and sources of knowledge: How students tackle integrated tasks in science, technology, and mathematics" 34 : 115-125, 2004

126 National Council of Teachers of Mathematics[NCTM], "Curriculum and evaluation standards for school mathematics"

127 Jang, S., "Creative invention problem solving based on STEM" Korean Intellectual Property Office(KIPO) 2008

128 Hutchinson, P., "Children designing & engineering : Contextual learning units in primary design and technology" 39 (39): 122-145, 2002

129 Rowell, P. W., "Characterization of technology within an elementary science program" 9 (9): 37-56, 1999

130 Kim, K., "Characteristics of achievement trend in Korea's middle and high school students from International Achievement Assessment(TIMSS/PISA)" Korea Institute for Curriculum and Evaluation 2008

131 Fitzgerald, M., "Cereal box design: An interdisciplinary graphics activity" 22-25, 2004

132 Apedoe, X. S., "Bringing engineering design into high school science classrooms : The heating/cooling unit" 17 (17): 454-465, 2008

133 Carroll, D. R., "Bridge engineering for the elementary grades" 86 (86): 221-226, 1997

134 Project the Lead Way[PTLW], "Biomedical sciences"

135 Roth, W-M., "Authentic school science : knowing and learning in open-inquiry school laboratories" Kluwer Academic Publisher 1995

136 National Council of Teachers of Mathematics[NCTM], "Assessment standards for school mathematics"

137 Burney, V. H., "Applications of social cognitive theory to gifted education" 30 : 130-139, 2008

138 Sanders, M., "An introduction to integrative STEM education" 2011

139 Choi, K., "An analysis of STS material and activity in the middle school science textbooks published by the sixth curriculum" 17 (17): 425-433, 1997

140 Congress of the United States of America[CUSA], "American recovery and reinvestment act of 2009" Congress of the United States of America[CUSA] 2009

141 International Technology Education Association[ITEA], "Advancing excellence in technological literacy: Students assessment, professional development, program standards" International Technology Education Association[ITEA] 2003

142 Bybee, R. W., "Advancing STEM education : A 2020 Vision" 70 (70): 30-35, 2010

143 Bybee, R. W., "Achieving technological literacy : A national imperative" 60 (60): 23-28, 2000

144 Poster, A. L., "A systems model of innovation processes in university STEM education" 95 (95): 13-24, 2006

145 Kim, Y., "A social cognitive framework for designing pedagogical agents as learning companions" 54 (54): 569-596, 2006

146 Sanders, M., "A rationale for new approaches to STEM education and STEM education graduate programs" 2006

147 Lawshe, C. H., "A quantitative approach to content validity" 28 (28): 563-575, 1975

148 Song, J. B., "A Study on the development of classroom-friendly robot-education model and program for the STEM integration education" Korea National University of Education 2010

149 Jung, Y., "A Study on Freudenthal's mathematising instruction theory" Seoul National University 1997

150 Yager, R. E., "A STS approach to human biology instruction affects, achievement and attitude of elementary science majors" 54 (54): 349-355, 1992

151 National Research Council[NRC], "A Framework for K-12 science education: Practices, crosscutting concepts, and core Ideas" The National Academies Press 2012

152 Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST]., "2009 Revised national high school curriculum"

153 Ministry of Education and Science Technology[MEST], "2007 Revised national science curriculum"