특허권 남용에 대한 시장지배적 지위남용행위로서 규제 가능성 검토 = A Study on the Misuse of Patents from the Perspective of Abuse of Market Dominant Power

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

A patentee has the exclusive right, and a use of the right will become the object of protection in the Patent Act. But if the use of patents belongs to the misuse, Patent Act will not protect the use of patents and will be applied the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trad Act(hereafter MRFTA) will be applied to the use of patents. At the process of the application it is decisive to review the legitimacy of the use of patents, and the review is legally based on the clause 59 in MRFTA, which stipulates that “The provisions of this Act does not apply to a legitimate exercise of rights under the Copyright Act, the Patent Act, the Utility Models Act, the Design Act, or the Trademark Act.” The review of the legitimacy of use of patents will be made by the two criterions, patent policy and competition policy. If the conduct of a patentee is decided as the misuse of patents, MRFTA will be applied to the conduct, and it should be considered whether the conduct corresponds to the breach of the regulations of the abuse of market dominant power. As the abuse of the market dominant power is considered from the two perspective, exploitative abuse and exclusive abuse, the decision on the abuse of patents shall be based on the two criterions. The standard essential patent must be specially considered in two types of review.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 계승균, "표준특허의 법적 성격과 명암" 11 : 2012

2 홍동표, "표준특허의 FRAND 실시료 산정 사례 분석: 미국 Microsoft 판결 및Innovatio 판결을 중심으로" (183) : 2015

3 홍명수, "표준특허 관련 행위에 대한 공정거래법상 규제 가능성 검토" 법학연구소 36 (36): 805-827, 2012

4 박희섭, "특허법원론" 세창출판사 2006

5 윤선희, "특허법" 법문사 2003

6 임　호, "특허법" 법문사 2003

7 김병일, "지식재산권의 부당한 권리 행사와 남용적 행사 방지에 관한 고찰" (180) : 2015

8 권남훈, "지식재산권에 대한 실시료의 수준과 경쟁법의 역할" 한국정보법학회 15 (15): 91-140, 2011

9 손영화, "지식재산권에 대한 독점규제법의 적용" (361) : 2000

10 윤신승, "유럽사법재판소의 Huawei v. ZTE 사건 판결" (182) : 2015

11 공정위, "보도참고자료"

12 곽윤직, "민법총칙" 박영사 2014

13 권오승, "독점규제법 : 이론과 실무" 법문사 2016

14 이상주, "대한민국에 특허괴물 몰려온다 : 독점금지법 위반으로 대응하라" 나남 2010

15 정상조, "공정거래와 법치" 법문사 2004

16 홍명수, "공정거래법 제19조 제1항의 해석과 수평적․수직적 공동행위의 규제 법리 고찰" 법학연구소 (61) : 435-456, 2013

17 이기수, "경제법(제9판)" 세창출판사 2012

18 정호열, "경제법 제4판" 박영사 2012

19 신현윤, "경제법" 법문사 2014

20 권오승, "경제법" 법문사 2014

21 白石忠志, "獨禁法講義" 有斐閣 2009

22 金井貴嗣, "獨占禁止法" 弘文堂 2010

23 Sullivan, T., "Understanding Antitrust and Its Economic Implications" LexisNexis 2003

24 Scott-Morton, F. M., "The Role of Standards in the Current Patent Wars"

25 Hoerner, R. J., "The Decline(and Fall?) of the Patent Misuse Doctrine in the Federal Circuit" 69 : 2001

26 Jonesday.com, "Standards-Essential Patents and Injunctive Relief"

27 Schellingerhout, R., "Standard-setting from a competition law perspective"

28 FTC, "Response to IEEE"

29 Mes, P., "Patentgesetz/Gebrauchsmustergesetz Kommentar" C. H. Beck 2011

30 Mueller, J. M., "Patent Law" Wolters Kluwer 2013

31 Bessen, J., "Patent Failure" Princeton Univ. Press 2008

32 Rebmann, K., "Münchener Kommentar zum Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch Band 1**" C. H. Beck 2001

33 Layne-Farrar, A., "Moving Past The SEP RAND Obsession: Some Thoughts on The Economic Implications of Unilateral Commitments and The Complexities of Patent Licensing"

34 Almunia, J., "Intellectual property and Competition policy"

35 Czapracka, K., "Intellectual Property and the Limits of Antitrust" Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd 2009

36 Lange, K. W., "Handbuch zum Deutschen und Europäischen Kartellrecht" Verlag Recht und Wirtschaft GmbH 2006

37 Witting, J., "German Federal Supreme Court decides in landmark case on competition law defence"

38 Hovenkamp, H., "Federal Antitrust Policly: The Law of Competition and Its Practice" Thomson/West 2005

39 Rittner, F., "Europäisches und deutsches Wirtschaftsrecht" C. F. Müller 2008

40 Goyder, J., "EC Competition Law" Oxford Univ. Press 2009

41 Furse, M., "Competition Law of the EC and UK" Oxford Univ. Press 2004

42 Whish, R., "Competition Law" Oxford Univ. Press 2012

43 Whish, R., "Competition Law" Oxford Univ. Press 2005

44 European Commission, "Antitrust: Commission confirms sending a Statement of Objections to Rambus"

45 Tom, W. K., "Antitrust and Intellectual Property: From Separate Spheres to Unified Field" 66 (66): 1997

46 ABA(Section of Antitrust Law), "Antitrust Law Developments vol. 1" ABA Publishing 2007

47 Brox, H., "Allgemeiner Teil des BGB" Carl Heymanns Verlag 1999