Ethics of the Golden Rule and the Commandment of Love

국문 초록 (Abstract)

황금률의 윤리에 관한 기존의 연구들은 주로 황금률과 상호주의 그리고 사랑의 법간의 관계를 다루어왔다. 황금률에 관한 기존의 이러한 연구들은 중대한 한계를 노정하고 있다. 이러한 연구들은 무엇보다도, 황금률이 제시되는 텍스트를 선택적으로 취함으로써, 황금률의 특징에 대한 혼동을 초래할 뿐만 아니라, 동일한 텍스트에 나타나는 다양한 도덕규범들에 대해 일관적인 설명을 결여하고 있다. 이러한 한계들로 인하여 기존의 연구들은 황금률의 윤리가 가지는 독특성을 보여주지 못하고 있는데, 그 독특성은 이 논문에서 제시하는 간접적 삼자관계의 논리로 표현될 수 있는 것이다. 간접적 삼자관계는 텍스트 내에 혼재한 다양한 도덕규범들의 관계를 일관적으로 설명하고 황금률의 성격을 해명하는 한 가지 방법을 제시한다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Previous studies on ethics of the golden rule have primarily discussed the relation between the golden rule, reciprocity and the commandment of love. They have been exposing some limitations. By selectively choosing the verses of text, they led to confusion in relation to the character of the golden rule and cannot consistently explain various norms. Finally, they do not show a unique aspect of ethics of the golden rule because they do not appropriately deal with a relational logic of the indirect third-party. Indirect third-party relation can present a way to explain the relation of norms consistently and the characteristics of the golden rule.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Abstract
• 1. Introduction
• 2. Mixture of Norms
• 3. Typical Discussions of Previous studies for the Golden Rule
• 4. Logical Relations of the Golden Rule and Norms
• 5. Conclusion: Particularity of the Golden Rule
• References
• 국문초록

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Kirk, Alan, "love your Enemies, the Golden Rule, and Ancient Reciprocity (Luke 6:27-35)" 122 (122): 667-686, 2003

2 Anna, Wierzbicka, "What did Jesus mean? : explaining the Sermon on the Mount and the parables in simple and universal human concepts" Oxford University Press 2001

3 Tullberg, Jan, "The golden Rule of Benevolence versus the Silver Rule of Reciprocity" 3 (3): 2014

4 Topel, John, "The Tarnished Golden Rule(Luke 6:31): The Inescapable Radicalness of Christian Ethics" 59 : 475-485, 1998

5 Allison, Dale, "The Structure of the Sermon on the Mount" 106 (106): 423-445, 1987

6 Betz, Hans, "The Sermon on the Mount: Its Literary Genre and Function" 59 (59): 285-297, 1979

7 Luther, Martin, "The Sermon on the Mount and the Magnificat" Concordia 1956

8 Ricoeur, Paul, "The Golden Rule: Exegetical and Theological Perplexities" 36 : 392-397, 1990

9 Blackstone, W. T., "The Golden Rule: A Defense" (Winter) : 172-177, 1965

10 Reinikainen, Jouni, "The Golden Rule and the Requirement of Universalizability" 39 : 155-168, 2005

11 Gewirth, Alan, "The Golden Rule Rationalized" John Wiley & Sons. Inc. 521-535, 2013

12 Wattles, Jeffrey, "The Golden Rule" Oxford University Press 1996

13 Singer, Marcus, "The Golden Rule" 38 : 293-314, 1963

14 Chilton, Bruce, "The Golden Rule" Continuum 76-87, 2008

15 Neusner, Jacob, "The Golden Rule" Continuum 2008

16 Apresian, R.G., "Talion and the Golden Rule" 41 (41): 46-64, 2002

17 Hennessey, J. W., "Moral Rules and Moral Ideals" 4 : 105-115, 1985

18 Wattles, Jeffrey, "Levels of meaning in the Golden Rule" 15 : 106-129, 1987

19 "Holy Bible, RSV"

20 Bultmann, Rudolf, "History of the Synoptic Tradition" Blackwell 1963

21 John Wiley & Sons, "Ethical Theory: An Anthology" Inc. 2013

22 Dihle, Albrecht, "Die goldene Regel" Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht 1962