의학 비전문직업성, 탈전문화와 덕 윤리 = Medical Unprofessionalism, De-professionalization, and Virtue Ethics

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Medical unprofessionalism and the deprofessionalization of medicine have of late become serious concerns to physicians, medical educators, and the public. Medical professionalism, which signifies a set of values, behaviors, and a relationship that underpins the trust the public places in physicians, is a core feature of medical practice. Commercialism and consumerism in medicine are among the main factors currently contributing to medical unprofessionalism and the deprofessionalization of medical practice.
The unprofessionalism and deprofessionalization of physicians produce negative images of physicians.
In this article we argue for a virtue-ethics approach to solving the problems of medical unprofessionalism and deprofessionalization. We argue for the promotion of certain virtues among physicians and the need for virtuous role models. Furthermore, we claim that since physicians are also members of society,the nurturing of virtue within the medical profession both promotes and requires the nurturing of virtue within society at large.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Medical unprofessionalism and the deprofessionalization of medicine have of late become serious concerns to physicians, medical educators, and the public. Medical professionalism, which signifies a set of values, behaviors, and a relationship that underpins the trust the public places in physicians, is a core feature of medical practice. Commercialism and consumerism in medicine are among the main factors currently contributing to medical unprofessionalism and the deprofessionalization of medical practice.
The unprofessionalism and deprofessionalization of physicians produce negative images of physicians.
In this article we argue for a virtue-ethics approach to solving the problems of medical unprofessionalism and deprofessionalization. We argue for the promotion of certain virtues among physicians and the need for virtuous role models. Furthermore, we claim that since physicians are also members of society,the nurturing of virtue within the medical profession both promotes and requires the nurturing of virtue within society at large.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 맹광호, "한국에서의 ‘의학전문직업성’ 교육: 과제와 전망" 한국의학교육학회 20 (20): 3-10, 2008

2 박호진, "한국 의사의 탈전문화에 관한 연구" 청주대학교 대학원 2008

3 베른하르트 헤링, "의료윤리" 가톨릭출판사 22-, 2006

4 Cockerham WC, "의료사회학" 아카넷 386-, 2005

5 김수정, "아리스토텔레스의 덕 윤리와 생명윤리에의 적용" 생명의료법연구소 3 (3): 135-153, 2009

6 이재향, "아리스토텔레스 윤리학에서 덕의 개념" 경북대학교 동서사상연구소 445-, 2007

7 알라스디어 매킨타이어, "덕의 상실(After Virtue)" 문예출판사 269-, 1997

8 아리스토텔레스, "니코마코스 윤리학" 서광사 36-37, 1984

9 "www.plato.stanford.edu/entries/ethics-virtue"

10 Coulehan J, "You say self-interest, I say altruism, in Professionalism in Medicine-Critical Perspective" Springer Science+Business Media LLC 113-, 2006

11 Sullivan W, "Work and Integrity. The Crisis and Promise of Professionalism in North America" Happer Collins 2-, 1995

12 Lipner RS, "Who is maintaining certification and why? A national survey 10 years initial certification" 144 : 23-26, 2006

13 Hafferty F, "Viewpoint: the elephant in medical professionalism's kitchen" 81 (81): 906-914, 2006

14 University of Calgary, "University of Calgary Medical School Student Code of Conduct: Descriptors of Unprofessionalism"

15 Swick HM, "Toward a normative definition of medical professionalism" 75 (75): 612-616, 2000

16 Coulehan J, "Today's professionalism: engaging the mind but not the heart" 80 (80): 895-, 2005

17 Jansen LA, "The virtues in their place: virtue ethics in medicine" 21 (21): 261-275, 2000

18 Reed RR, "The deprofessionalization of medicine. causes, effects, and responses" 258 : 3279-3282, 1987

19 Starr P, "The Social Transformation of American Medicine" Basic Books 15-, 1982

20 Barnes J, "The Nichomachean Ethics. The revised Oxford Translation, in In The Complete Works of Aristotle" Princeton University Press 1729-1867, 1984

21 Cruess RL, "Teaching medicine as a profession in the service of healing" 72 : 941-951, 1997

22 Cruess RL, "Teaching Medical Professionalism" Cambridge University Press 2009

23 Inui TS, "Supporting Teaching and Learning of Professionalism-Changing the Educational Environment and Students' Navigational Skills, in Teaching Medical Professionalism" Cambridge University Press 109-110, 2009

24 Barilan YM, "Responsibility and meta-virtue: truth-telling and deliberation and wisdom in medical professionalism" 35 : 153-158, 2009

25 Ritzer G, "Rationalization and deprofessionalizaton of physician" 67 : 1-22, 2004

26 Gruen RL, "Public roles of us physicians: community participation, political involvement, and collective advocacy" 296 : 2467-2475, 2006

27 Hilton SR, "Proto-professionalism: How professionalisation occurs across the continuum of medical education" 39 : 58-65, 2005

28 Pellegrino ED, "Professionalism, profession and the virtues of the good physician" 69 (69): 378-379, 2002

29 Freidson E, "Professional Dominance: The Social Structure of Medical Care" Aladine xvii-, 1970

30 Cruess SR, "Profession: a working definition for medical educators" 16 (16): 74-76, 2004

31 Bryden Pier, "Professing professionalism: are we our own worst enemy? Faculty members’ experiences of teaching and evaluating professionalism in medical education at one school" 85 (85): 1025-1034, 2010

32 Bryden P, "Professing professionalism : are we our own worst enemy? faculty members’experiences of teaching and evaluating professionalism in medical education at one school" 85 (85): 1025-1034, 2010

33 Hilton SR, "Pellegrino E"

34 Pellegrino ED, "Medical professionalism: can it, should it survive?" 13 (13): 1-, 2000

35 Whitcomb M, "Medical professionalism: can it be taught" 80 (80): 883-, 2005

36 Wynia MK, "Medical professionalism in society" 341 (341): 1612-1616, 1999

37 Kinghorn WA, "Medical education as moral formation: an aristotelian account of medical professionalism" 53 (53): 87-105, 2010

38 Stern DT, "Measuring Medical Professionalism" Oxford University Press 15-, 2005

39 Egan EA, "Living Professionalism: Reflections on the Practice of Medicine" Rowman & Littlefield Publishers 1-99, 2006

40 Cohen JJ, "Linking professionalism to humanism: what it means, why it matters" 82 : 1029-1032, 2007

41 Sox HS, "Learning (internal) medicine" 144 : 57-58, 2006

42 Parsi K, "Healing as Vocation-A Medical Professionalism Primer" Rowman & Littlefield Publishers 2006

43 Salkever S, "Finding the Mean" Princeton University Press 108-, 1990

44 Association of American Medical Colleges and the National Board of Medical Examiners, "Embedding Professionalism in Medical Education"

45 Royal College of Physicians of London, "Doctors in Society : Medical Professionalism in a Changing World, Report of a Working Party by the Royal College of Physicians of London" 8-, 2005

46 Hafferty FW, "Definitions of professionalism: a search for meaning and identity" 449 : 193-204, 2006

47 American Medical Association, "Code of Medical Ethics: Current Opinions with Annotations"

48 AMA (American Medical Association), "Code of Medical Ethics. 2001 : Adopted June 1957; revised June 1980; revised June 2001"

49 Pellegrino E, "Character Formation and the Making of Good Physician : Lost Virtue : Professional Character and Medical Education, Advances in Bioethics" Elservier Press 2-14, 2007

50 Canadian Medical Association, "CMA Policy: Medical Professionalism" 3 : 2005

51 Canadian Medical Association, "CMA Policy : Medical Professionalism. 2005 : American College of Physicians Foundation, American Board of Internal Medicine, European Federation of Internal Medicine, Medical Professionalism in the New Millennium : A Physician Charter" 1 : 2002

52 Shirly JL, "An analysis of the discourse of professionalism, in Professionalism in Medicine-Critical Perspectives" Springer 38-, 2006

53 American College of Physicians Foundation, "American Board of Internal Medicine, European Federation of Internal Medicine. Medical professionalism in the new millennium: a physician charter" 136 (136): 243-, 2002

54 Inui TM, "A flag in the Wind:Educating for Professionalism in Medicine" Association of American Medical Colleges 2003

55 Inui T, "A Flag in the Wind : Educating for Professionalism in Medicine" AAMC (Association of American Medical Colleges) 14-, 2003