프로그램 논리모형을 적용한 자연기반 치유관광의 정책적 함의 - 지속가능한 치유관광을 위한 정책 프레임워크를 중심으로 - = Policy Implications of Nature-based Healing Tourism Using the Program Logic Model: Focusing on Policy Framework for Sustainable Healing Tourism

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The increase in domestic healing tourism has led associated governmental agencies to becoming involved in the development of healing tourism projects. The budget expense for associated agencies amounts to approximately 282.56 billion won and these projects are currently ongoing. The healing tourism project is expected to expand with the purpose of achieving increased public value and advancing the local economy. The purpose of this study was therefore to identify the policy implications of healing tourism projects so that associated governmental agencies and local governments can analyze their enormous budget. This was achieved by applying a program logical model and a policy framework throughout the research. The results of using both these research strategies showed that: 1) Nurture was provided by a healing specialist and a healing tourism specialist. 2) There is a professionalization of healing programs that occurs. 3) That maintenance of consistent, professional, and systemic management of projects is needed. This will be achieved by establishing a control tower in a central agency. These results suggest the need for the establishment of organized policies that adhere to the tenants of a program logical model and a policy framework. This will ensure the maximization of management performance in healing tourism projects that are currently ongoing.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

국내에서 치유관광이 크게 증가함에 따라 정부의 각 부처에서는 치유관광사업을 진행하고 있다. 각 부처에서 시행된 금액은 약 2,825억 6,400만원을 투입하였고, 사업은 지속적으로 진행 중이다. 치유관광사업은 공익적 가치와 지역경제 활성화라는 목적으로 향후 지속적으로 증가할 전망이다. 따라서 본 연구에서는 정부 각 부처와 지방자치단체에서 막대한 예산을 투입하고 있는 치유관광사업에 대한 정책적 함의를 제시하고자 한다. 본 연구는 프로그램 논리모형과 정책프레임워크 통해서 자연기반 치유관광을 위한 치유관광전문가 육성 및 치유관광의 핵심인 치유프로그램의 전문화가 필요한 것으로 나타났다. 또한, 각 부처에서 동일한 사업을 진행함에 따라 중앙부서에는 컨트롤타워를 마련하여 통일성, 전문성, 그리고 체계성 있는 관리가 필요한 것으로 나타났다. 아직은 시행 중인 치유관광사업에 대한 성과관리의 극대화를 위하여 정책프레임워크에 따라 관련 정책을 체계적으로 수립하고, 프로그램논리모형을 토대로 유도된 결과에 따라 전략을 집중할 필요가 있는 것 사료된다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "힐링명소 ‘대관령 치유의숲’ 4월부터 본격 운영" 연합뉴스

2 김진옥, "힐링관광 참여자의 주의회복과 치유프로그램에 대한 감정이 삶의 만족과 충성도에 미치는 영향" 한국호텔외식관광경영학회 24 (24): 161-178, 2015

3 홍수장, "힐링 트랜스포메이션 재화로서 산림치유 시설 선택요인 중요도 인식연구" 한국사진지리학회 23 (23): 97-106, 2013

4 "해수부, ‘해양치유’ 관광산업화추진... 3년간 35억 투자" 이투데이

5 김진옥, "한국형 치유관광의 개념모델 정립 및 치유효과 분석에 관한 연구: 자연기반 아웃도어레크리에이션 참여자를 중심으로" 한국관광연구학회 31 (31): 5-21, 2017

6 박소영, "한국의 교육 ODA 현황과 개선방안" 교육연구소 11 (11): 1-23, 2010

7 조광익, "한국 사회의 新관광 현상에 대한 이해 - ‘힐링관광’의 사회적 의미 -" 한국관광학회 40 (40): 11-31, 2016

8 이석민, "프로그램 논리모형(Logic Models)의 적용과 사용에 관한 연구 - “간접흡연제로! 서울 평가지표 개발연구” 사례를 중심으로 -" 한국거버넌스학회 18 (18): 211-242, 2011

9 김진옥, "포스트관광객의 리얼리티 프로그램 시선(gaze)이 아웃도어레크리에이션 의사결정과정에 미치는 구조적 관계분석 -날씨영향을 추가한 목표지향적 행동모델의 적용-" 한국관광학회 38 (38): 159-183, 2014

10 김진옥, "트레커의 웰니스 추구가 감정과 만족도 및 충성도에 미치는 영향 -북한산 국립공원의 트레커를 대상으로-" 한국사진지리학회 24 (24): 153-169, 2014

11 농촌진흥청, "치유형 농촌관광 활성화 연구" 2017

12 조록환, "치유관광의 서비스품질이 지각된 가치와 만족에 간의 구조적 관계: 농촌지역을 중심으로" 대한관광경영학회 31 (31): 237-258, 2016

13 김진옥, "치유관광에서 자연을 통한 감정조절과 지각된 회복환경이 의사결정과정에 미치는 영향: 숲 치유프로그램 참여자를 대상으로" 한국관광연구학회 30 (30): 47-60, 2016

14 "제천에 ‘국립 치유의 숲’2019년 개장" 문화일보

15 "전국 국립공원에 둘레길 조성한다" 한국경제

16 김진옥, "자연기반 아웃도어레크리에이션 환경이 치유관광객의 주의회복과 삶의 질에 미치는 영향: ‘치유의 숲’ 프로그램 참여자를 대상으로" 한양대학교 2015

17 "울창한 산림서 건강 챙기세요" 서울경제

18 "영주 국립산림치유원 ‘다스림’ 18일 개원" 경북일보

19 "안동 남부지방산림청, 울주군에 ‘치유의 숲’ 조성" 뉴시스

20 김진옥, "아웃도어레크리에이션의 자연매력성이 태도와 행동의도에 미치는 영향 : 인지적 태도와 정서적 태도를 중심으로" 관광연구소 27 (27): 75-97, 2015

21 이진의, "아웃도어레크리에이션 트레커의 참여동기, 웰니스, 만족도, 충성도 간의 구조적 관계 분석 - 북한산 국립공원 트레커를 중심으로 -" 한국관광학회 39 (39): 225-244, 2015

22 "서부산림청 ‘장성 치유의숲’ 28일 개장" 연합뉴스

23 "서귀포 치유의 숲 26일 개장" 제주일보

24 이양수, "새마을운동 공적개발원조(ODA) 사업의 논리모형 탐색" 한국국제농업개발학회 29 (29): 42-49, 2017

25 김혜숙, "방과후학교 프로그램 논리모형에 대한 탐색: 초등학교 특기적성교육을 중심으로" 한국수산해양교육학회 28 (28): 336-349, 2016

26 "문화재청 7조원 돌파... 문화융성을 생활 속으로" 정책브리핑

27 "대전 숲체원 등 산림복지시설 8곳 추가조성" 한국일보

28 최영출, "논리모형(Logic Model)의 성과관리 적용 가능성: 사회적 기업 정책을 중심으로" 한국정책분석평가학회 21 (21): 13-38, 2011

29 "남해 미조항 앞 조도(鳥島)ㆍ호도(虎島)에 휴양관광단지조성" 매일경제

30 김진옥, "기후변화 인식이 아웃도어레크리에이션 참여자의 행동에 미치는 영향" 한국관광학회 37 (37): 11-32, 2013

31 문종열, "금강산관광사업 논리모형과 특성 그리고 정책적 함의" 한국정부학회 19 (19): 405-428, 2007

32 박주혁, "국민안전처 이후 국내 테러 대응 정책방향에 관한 연구 : 프로그램논리모형(Program Logic Model)적용중심으로" 한국경찰학회 17 (17): 35-62, 2015

33 Ulrich, R, "Visual landscapes and psychological wellbeing" 4 (4): 17-23, 1979

34 Patton, M, "Utilization-focused evaluation" Sage publications 2008

35 Serowoky, M, "Using the program logic model to evaluate cuídate! : A sexual health program for Latino adolescents in a school‐based health center" 12 (12): 297-305, 2015

36 Armstrong, E, "Using an outcomes-logic-model approach to evaluate a faculty development program for medical educators" 81 (81): 483-488, 2006

37 Dwyer, J, "Using a program logic model that focuses on performance measurement to develop a program" 88 (88): 421-425, 1997

38 Clapham, K, "Using a logic model to evaluate the kids together early education inclusion program for children with disabilities and additional needs" 61 : 96-105, 2017

39 Tremblay, C, "Users’ involvement in mental health services : Programme logic model of an innovative initiative in integrated care" 11 (11): 9-16, 2017

40 Jiboye, A, "Urbanization challenges and housing delivery in Nigeria : The need for an effective policy framework for sustainable development" 2 (2): 176-185, 2011

41 Loorbach, D, "Transition management for sustainable development : A prescriptive, complexity‐based governance framework" 23 (23): 161-183, 2010

42 Doherty, S, "Tracking human activity and well-being in natural environments using wearable sensors and experience sampling" 106 : 83-92, 2014

43 Tyrväinen, L, "Towards sustainable growth in nature-based tourism destinations : Clients’ views of land use options in Finnish Lapland" 122 : 1-15, 2014

44 Myers, J, "The wheel of wellness counseling for wellness : A holistic model for treatment planning" 78 (78): 251-266, 2000

45 Cooksy, L, "The program logic model as an integrative framework for a multi-method evaluation" 24 (24): 119-128, 2001

46 Tyrväinen, L, "The influence of urban green environments on stress relief measures : A field experiment" 38 : 1-9, 2014

47 Bickman, L, "The functions of program theory" 33 : 5-18, 1987

48 Gervais, C, "The father friendly initiative within families : Using a logic model to develop program theory for a father support program" 52 : 133-141, 2015

49 Kaplan, R, "The experience of nature : A psychological perspective" Cambridge University 1989

50 Beard, J, "The World report on ageing and health : A policy framework for healthy ageing" 387 (387): 2145-2154, 2016

51 Miller, C, "Socio-energy systems design : A policy framework for energy transitions" 6 : 29-40, 2015

52 Woolcock, M, "Social capital and economic development : Toward a theoretical synthesis and policy framework" 27 (27): 151-208, 1998

53 Gugiu, P, "Semi-structured interview protocol for constructing logic models" 30 (30): 339-350, 2007

54 Lee, T, "Routledge Handbook of Health Tourism" Routledge 375-385, 2016

55 Blanchard, O, "Rethinking macroeconomic policy. Journal of Money" 42 (42): 199-215, 2010

56 Scarlat, N, "Renewable energy policy framework and bioenergy contribution in the European union–an overview from national renewable energy action plans and progress reports" 51 : 969-985, 2015

57 Chen, H, "Practical program evaluation" Sage 2014

58 Cho, K, "Perceived restorativeness of visits to cultural heritage sites" 21 (21): 1046-1069, 2016

59 Das, B, "Peer Reviewed : Development of a logic model for a physical activity–based employee wellness program for mass transit workers" 11 : 1-7, 2014

60 Kim, H, "Nature-based tourism : Motivation and subjective well-being" 32 (32): 76-96, 2015

61 Heintzman, P, "Nature-based recreation, spirituality and persons with disabilities" 18 (18): 97-116, 2014

62 Lee, T, "Nature Tourism" Routledge 33-45, 2017

63 Khan, M, "Medical tourism destination image formation process : A conceptual model" 9 (9): 134-143, 2016

64 Pocock, N, "Medical tourism and policy implications for health systems : A conceptual framework from a comparative study of Thailand, Singapore and Malaysia" 7 (7): 12-25, 2011

65 Taylor-Powell, E, "Logic models to enhance program performance" University of Wisconsin Cooperative Extension 2003

66 Rios, A, "Logic model of the Recreovía : A community program to promote physical activity in Bogota" 22 (22): 206-211, 2017

67 Joly, B, "Linking accreditation and public health outcomes : A logic model approach" 13 (13): 349-356, 2007

68 Conway, P, "Level of perceived stress among patients in primary care settings" 2014

69 Axelsson, R, "Integration and collaboration in public health : A conceptual framework" 21 (21): 75-88, 2006

70 Burstrom, B, "How equitable is vocational rehabilitation in Sweden? A review of evidence on the implementation of a national policy framework" 33 (33): 453-466, 2011

71 Vork, J, "Health tourism and hospitality: Spas, wellness and medical travel" Routledge 407-411, 2014

72 Smith, M, "Health tourism and hospitality : Spas, wellness and medical travel" Routledge 2014

73 Yang, J, "Health tourism : Needs for healing experience and intentions for transformation in wellness resorts in Korea" 27 (27): 1881-1904, 2015

74 Edlin, G, "Health and wellness" Jones & Bartlett 2014

75 Hall, C, "Health and medical tourism: A kill or cure for global public health?" 66 (66): 4-15, 2011

76 Korpela, K, "Favorite green, waterside and urban environments, restorative experiences and perceived health in Finland" 25 (25): 200-209, 2010

77 Duvall, J, "Enhancing the well-being of veterans using extended group-based nature recreation experiences" 51 (51): 685-696, 2014

78 Dickson, T, "Effect of ability and style of ascent on psychophysiological responses to difficult on-sight rock climbing" 47 : 368-372, 2015

79 Poncet, F, "Documenting a rehabilitation program using a logic model : An advantage to the assessment process" 29 (29): 7-19, 2017

80 Jaegers, L, "Development of a program logic model and evaluation plan for a participatory ergonomics intervention in construction" 57 (57): 351-361, 2014

81 De-Regil, L, "Development and use of the generic WHO/CDC logic model for vitamin and mineral interventions in public health programmes" 17 (17): 634-639, 2014

82 Becker, K, "Dance your heart out : A community's approach to addressing cardiovascular health by using a logic model" 40 (40): 212-220, 2017

83 Trochim, W, "Concept mapping : An introduction to structured conceptualization in health care" 17 (17): 187-191, 2005

84 Eriksson, N, "Blessed alienation the christian monastery as a caring and restorative environment" 24 (24): 172-182, 2014

85 Korpela, K, "Analyzing the mediators between nature-based outdoor recreation and emotional wellbeing" 37 : 1-7, 2014

86 Kim, J, "An influence of outdoor recreation participants’ perceived restorative environment on wellness effect, satisfaction and loyalty" 2014

87 Voigt, C, "An examination of the extent of collaboration between major wellness tourism stakeholders in Australia" 33 : 63-77, 2013

88 World Health Organization Maximizing Positive Synergies Collaborative Group., "An assessment of interactions between global health initiatives and country health systems" 373 (373): 2137-2169, 2009

89 Fernandez, P, "Addressing 2030 EU policy framework for energy and climate : Cost, risk and energy security issues" 115 : 1347-1360, 2016

90 Lunt, N, "A framework for exploring the policy implications of UK medical tourism and international patient flows" 47 (47): 1-25, 2013

91 Lafferty, C, "A framework for evaluating comprehensive community initiatives" 4 (4): 31-44, 2003

92 Heung, V, "A conceptual model of medical tourism : Implications for future research" 27 (27): 236-251, 2010

93 Handler, A, "A conceptual framework to measure performance of the public health system" 91 (91): 1235-1239, 2001

94 Dyehouse, M, "A comparison of linear and systems thinking approaches for program evaluation illustrated using the Indiana Interdisciplinary GK-12" 32 (32): 187-196, 2009