비정형유방증식에 대한 최근 중의 약물치료 동향에 대한 문헌연구 = A Literature Review on the Recent Tendency of the Treatment about Atypical Hyperplasia of Breast on the Chinese Herbal Medicine

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Objectives: We conducted a literature study on the treatment trends in China to find out the possibility of Oriental medicine treatment of atypical hyperplasia of breast (AHB).
Methods: RCTs (randomized controlled trial) on AHB were collected from CNKI (China National Knowledge Infrastructure). The search words were “乳腺增生”, “乳腺囊性增生”, “乳癖”, “中医”, “中药” and “中西医结合”. The search period was limited from July 2006 to May 2017. Finally, we selected 107 RCTs which were clinical studies to find out the effectiveness of Chinese herbal medicine in comparison with Western medicine. After reviewing, we investigated Chinese herbal medication guide, Chinese treatment method and prescriptions. And the correlation between the treatments and the medicinal herbs was investigated to be useful in the clinical practice.
Results: 1. The administration of herbal medicine was 58.9 percent in 63 cases, followed by menstrual cycles, and 41.1 percent in 44 cases, regardless of menstrual cycles.
2. In the basic frequency analysis between the treatment and the medicinal herb, the frequency of dissipate binds (散結) was the highest. Next, there was a high frequency of therapies such as activating blood-activating (活血), relieve pain (止痛), soothe the liver (疏肝), regulate qi (理氣), resolve phlegm (化痰), soften hardness (軟堅), resolve depression (解鬱), move qi (行氣) of frequency was high. In herbal medicine, bupleuri radix (柴胡), cyperi rhizoma (香附子), angelicae gigantis radix (當歸), fritillaria thunbergii bulb (貝母), paeoniae radix alba (白芍藥), prunellae spica (夏枯草), corydalis rhizoma (玄胡索) showed high frequency.
3. We finded out the correlation between the frequent treatment methods and the medicinal herbs using Text Mining.
Conclusions: These findings are thought to help implement Korean traditional medicine treatments for AHB.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Wang RM, "Xiaopi Decoction in the treatment of 60 cases of breast hyperplasia" 20 (20): 1465-, 2008

2 Liu Y, "Xiaojiean capsule and tamoxifen in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 41 (41): 86-88, 2013

3 Jian XC, "Wenshen liqi huayu Decoction in the treatment of 102 cases of breast hyperplasia" 30 (30): 22-23, 2007

4 Lin HM, "Treatment Ｒūpisanjie capsule combined with tamoxifen for breast hyperplasia" 31 (31): 783-784, 2015

5 Zheng JC, "Treatment of mammary gland hyperplasia with combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 17 (17): 5160-5161, 2008

6 Huang ZY, "Treatment of hyperplasia of mammary gland with Sanyu Huatan Decoction and tamoxifen" 36 (36): 267-268, 2015

7 Liang XL, "Treatment of breast hyperplasia with traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 25 (25): 75-79, 2016

8 Su C, "Treatment of 87 cases of perimenopausal mammary hyperplasia by Warming Yang and resolving phlegm" 45 (45): 69-71, 2011

9 Song CW, "Treating 60 Cases of CysticHyperplasia of Breast in the Integrative Medicine" 25 (25): 99-100, 2011

10 Ge JA, "Tiaorūda Tai Fang in the treatment of 60 cases of breast hyperplasia" 34 (34): 522-523, 2012

11 Li YZ, "Tianqing Ruxiao Fang Wujian granule and methyltestosterone tablet in the treatment of breast cystic hyperplasia" 10 (10): 193-194, 2016

12 Guo J, "Therapeutic effect of traditional Chinese and Western Medicine on hyperplasia of mammary gland" 12 (12): 13-15, 2012

13 Zhou Y, "Therapeutic Effect of Tamoxifen and Chinese Traditional Patent Medicine on Breast Hyperplasia" 10 (10): 138-139, 2007

14 Zhou LJM, "The treatment of lobular hyperplasia of the breast" 16 (16): 53-56, 2019

15 Li YY, "The effect of Ruhexiao in the treatment of 76 cases of breast hyperplasia" 18 (18): 14-15, 2012

16 Xie BL, "The clinical effect of Xiaopitongru Decoction on 130 cases of mammary hyperplasia" 9 (9): 296-, 2011

17 Yang HY, "The Combination of Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine in the Treatment of Mammary Glands Hyperplasia of Liver Depression and Hysteresis Type" 30 (30): 486-488, 2014

18 Yu YYM, "The Clinical Effect of Chinese and Western Medicine in the Treatment of Breast Hyperplasia" 7 (7): 83-84, 2013

19 Bae JG, "The Breast of Oriental Medicine" Jungdam 245-250, 2005

20 Park SH, "The Breast Cancer White Paper" Korea Breast Society 7-11, 2018

21 Vinaitheerthan Renganathan, "Text Mining in Biomedical Domain with Emphasis on Document Clustering" 대한의료정보학회 23 (23): 141-146, 2017

22 Ingo F, "Text Mining Infrastructure in R" 25 (25): 1-54, 2008

23 Deng YF, "Study on TCM-WM Therapy for Adenosis of Mammary" 24 (24): 1134-1135, 2008

24 Deng YF, "Study on TCM-WM Therapy for Adenosis of Mammary" 24 (24): 1134-1135, 2008

25 Qin H, "Sanjie Xiaopi formula combined with tamoxifen citrate tablets in the treatment of 50 cases of breast hyperplasia" 27 (27): 26-27, 2014

26 Yi CH, "Rūxiaokang in the treatment of 56 cases of breast hyperplasia" 10 (10): 29-30, 2013

27 Zhang HQ, "Rūpi Sanjie capsule and malt in the treatment of 60 cases of postpartum milk regression" 17 (17): 221-222, 2011

28 Xu JJ, "Rūkuaixiao granules in the treatment of hyperplasia of mammary gland" 22 (22): 696-697, 2015

29 Rao YL, "Rūkang Decoction in the treatment of 86 cases of breast hyperplasia" 18 (18): 53-54, 2008

30 Wang L, "Rūhe Sanjie tablet in the treatment of 65 cases of breast hyperplasia" 8 (8): 182-, 2010

31 Rao YL, "Rukang Decoction in the treatment of 86 cases of breast hyperplasia" 18 (18): 53-54, 2008

32 Zhang KR, "Observation on the therapeutic effect of Xuefu Zhuyu Decoction in the treatment of 40 cases of mammary hyperplasia" 1 (1): 117-118, 2016

33 Yang H, "Observation on the therapeutic effect of Xiaopi Sanjie No.1 and No.2combined therapy on mastia" 30 (30): 24-25, 2007

34 Li YS, "Observation on the therapeutic effect of Prunella vulgaris and Chaihu formula combined with anti estrogen drugs on breast hyperplasia" 48 (48): 160-161, 2016

35 Zhao RJ, "Observation on the therapeutic effect of Cigu Sanxian Sanjia Xiaopi Decoction on 45 cases of breast hyperplasia" 32 (32): 1311-1312, 2010

36 Luo XB, "Observation on the curative effect of the treatment of mammary hyperplasia with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 20 (20): 484-485, 2007

37 Luo XB, "Observation on the curative effect of mammary gland hyperplasia treated with the combination of traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 21 (21): 31-32, 2008

38 Zhao GH, "Observation on the curative effect of combined traditional Chinese and Western medicine in the treatment of mammary hyperplasia" 45 (45): 67-68, 2007

39 Guo JF, "Observation on the curative effect of combined traditional Chinese and Western Medicine on hyperplasia of mammary gland" 22 (22): 1504-1506, 2013

40 Wang WY, "Observation on the curative effect of breast hyperplasia treated by the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 3 (3): 37-38, 2015

41 Shi LJ, "Observation on the curative effect of Xiaoru Decoction in the treatment of mammary hyperplasia" 9 : 114-116, 2016

42 Bao QM, "Observation on the curative effect of Rutong pill in the treatment of hyperplasia of mammary gland with pain" 15 (15): 164-, 2015

43 Cui CL, "Observation on the curative effect of 68 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 7 (7): 23-, 2009

44 Li YF, "Observation on the curative effect of 40 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 23 (23): 59-60, 2015

45 Chen W, "Observation on the curative effect of 40 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated by the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 23 (23): 243-, 2016

46 Wen YJ, "Observation on 60cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with traditional Chinese Medicine" 31 (31): 379-380, 2015

47 Liu SM, "Observation on 60cases of breast hyperplasia treated by zhongguanchuanyijielian" 6 (6): 104-105, 2014

48 Liu B, "Observation of therapeutic effect of Xiaojin Pill on hyperplasia of mammary lobule" 24 (24): 1053-1054, 2011

49 Wu MY, "Meta analysis of the treatment of breast hyperplasia with the combination of Chinese and Western medicine" 28 (28): 1437-1439, 2013

50 Wang XJ, "Kangrū Sanjie Decoction for the treatment of 50 cases of breast hyperplasia" 31 (31): 273-274, 2010

51 Kang CW, "Introduction to big data analysis using R and RStudio" free Academy 2018

52 Heo MH, "Introduction to Social Network Analysis Using R" free Academy 2012

53 Yan HW, "Integrated Traditional Chinese Medicine and Western Medicine Treat Disease of CysticHyperplasia of Breast" 32 (32): 483-484, 2008

54 Wang GF, "Experience in the treatment of mammary hyperplasia with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 14 (14): 4619-4620, 2007

55 Zhang XG, "Effect of Traditional Chinese Medicine Treatment of 56 Hyperplasia of Mammary Glands" 7 (7): 131-132, 2016

56 Yan MD, "Effect of TCM Periodic Therapy in Improvement of Endocrine Hormones and Symptoms of Patients with Breast Hyperplasia and Breast Pain" 35 (35): 745-748, 2017

57 Heo MH, "Data Visualization" free Academy 2014

58 Liu JH, "Comparison of therapeutic effect between Xiaojiean capsule and tamoxifen in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 2 (2): 94-95, 2015

59 Liu JH, "Comparison of therapeutic effect between Xiaojiean capsule and tamoxifen in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 2 (2): 94-95, 2015

60 Liu JS, "Clinical study on the treatment of breast hyperplasia with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 24 (24): 2971-2972, 2011

61 Lan XD, "Clinical study on the periodic treatment of breast hyperplasia with traditional Chinese Medicine" 9 (9): 97-98, 2013

62 Jin ZX, "Clinical study on 60 cases of hyperplasia of breast treated by Xiaopi formula" 29 (29): 885-886, 2009

63 Li LL, "Clinical observation on treating cyclomastopathy with TCM medicine" 7 (7): 65-67, 2015

64 Chen CB, "Clinical observation on the treatment of mammary hyperplasia with the combination of traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 27 (27): 66-67, 2008

65 Chen CB, "Clinical observation on the treatment of mammary hyperplasia with the combination of traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 27 (27): 66-67, 2008

66 Lei QM, "Clinical observation on the treatment of mammary hyperplasia with rūtonghesan granule I" 32 (32): 42-, 2010

67 Liu HY, "Clinical observation on the treatment of mammary hyperplasia with Xiaoyao Bailu powder" 35 (35): 46-, 2013

68 Mo XQ, "Clinical observation on the treatment of mammary hyperplasia with Wenyang Xiaopi decoction" 33 (33): 11-12, 2010

69 Liu XM, "Clinical observation on the treatment of mammary gland hyperplasia with self-made traditional Chinese medicine" 35 (35): 26-27, 2015

70 Bian DX, "Clinical observation on the treatment of mammary gland hyperplasia with Sanjie Xiaopi Decoction and Western medicine" 48 (48): 123-124, 2016

71 Zhao SG, "Clinical observation on the treatment of mammary gland hyperplasia with Jianpi Xingqi Bushen recipe" 19 (19): 72-73, 2012

72 Guo Y, "Clinical observation on the treatment of breast hyperplasia with the combination of Chinese and Western medicine" (17) : 189-190, 2011

73 Zhang H, "Clinical observation on the treatment of 300 cases liver depression and phlegm coagulation type of mastoidosis with the combination of traditional Chinese and Western medicine" 20 (20): 143-144, 2007

74 Li H, "Clinical observation on 900 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 19 (19): 150-, 2010

75 Wang JY, "Clinical observation on 80 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with Rūjie powder" 34 (34): 1612-1614, 2013

76 Gu SQ, "Clinical observation on 66cases of mammary gland hyperplasia treated with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 23 (23): 71-, 2014

77 Pei WJ, "Clinical observation on 52 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated by the combination of Chinese and Western medicine" 29 (29): 31-, 2010

78 Zhao HJ, "Clinical observation on 50 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with tamoxifen and Kun runing granules" 32 (32): 549-550, 2010

79 Chen H, "Clinical observation on 48 cases of small breast cyst treated by Xiaoji decoction" 15 (15): 157-, 2009

80 Wang XX, "Clinical observation on 38cases of mammary hyperplasia treated by the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 9 (9): 176-, 2012

81 Zhang YQ, "Clinical observation on 389cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 23 (23): 34-, 2008

82 Li X, "Clinical observation on 198 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated by the combination of traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 23 (23): 37-38, 2008

83 Wang CH, "Clinical observation on 112 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with traditional Chinese Medicine" 32 (32): 1128-1129, 2012

84 Zhang JQ, "Clinical observation of tamoxifen citrate tablets combined with Rupixiao tablets in the treatment of 81 cases of breast hyperplasia" 35 (35): 1514-1515, 2013

85 Hu YY, "Clinical observation of mammary gland No.1 in the treatment of 68 cases of mammary hyperplasia" 49 (49): 589-, 2014

86 Cheng WH, "Clinical observation of litchi kernel granule in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 20 (20): 25-26, 2013

87 He JX, "Clinical observation of haizaoxiaoliu capsule in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 35 (35): 16-17, 2013

88 Liang SH, "Clinical observation of Ziyin Sanjie formula in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 40 (40): 281-282, 2013

89 Zhang LY, "Clinical observation of Xiaozeng Decoction in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 13 (13): 96-97, 2011

90 Zhuo R, "Clinical observation of Xiaopi formula in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 30 (30): 22-23, 2007

91 Lei QM, "Clinical observation of Rūtonghesan granule No.3 in the Treatment of Breast hyperplasia of Chong Ren disorder type" 26 (26): 13-15, 2010

92 Wang YM, "Clinical observation of Rūjiqing mixture in the treatment of breast cystic hyperplasia" 14 (14): 62-, 2007

93 Wang Y, "Clinical observation of Hongjin Xiaojie capsule in the treatment of 130 cases breast hyperplasia" 5 (5): 94-95, 2008

94 Gao ZY, "Clinical experience in the treatment of mammary gland hyperplasia with the combination of traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 9 (9): 176-, 2012

95 Feng JM, "Clinical effect of Danqin Xiaoyu mixture on hyperplasia of mammary gland" 31 (31): 5292-5294, 2016

96 Yang J, "Clinical analysis of 78 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated by self-made Xaopiyin" 10 (10): 226-227, 2012

97 Sun C, "Clinical analysis of 100cases of mammary hyperplasia treated by the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 3 (3): 9454-, 2016

98 Zhuo R, "Clinical Research on the Treatment of Fibrocystic Disease of Breast with TCM" 9 (9): 137-139, 2007

99 Shi XC, "Clinical Research on Mammary Hyperplasia Treated with Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine" 5 (5): 1061-1063, 2010

100 Du YZ, "Clinical Observation on Treatment of Hyperplasia of Mammary Glands with Comblined Chinese and Western Medicine" 6 (6): 455-456, 2008

101 Zhang L, "Clinical Effect of Tiao Chong San Jie Tang on Cyclomastopathy of Chong and Ren Channel Disharmon" 29 (29): 81-83, 2011

102 Chen YH, "Clinical Analysis of 48 cases of Breast Hyperplasia Treated with Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 24 (24): 1134-1135, 2008

103 Chen MY, "Application of Hongjin Xiaojie capsule in breast hyperplasia" 29 (29): 1126-1129, 2017

104 Qian HD, "Analysis of the curative effect of 50 cases of hyperplasia of mammary gland treated by the combination of traditional Chinese and Western medicine" 12 : 115-, 2014

105 Liu XiP, "Analysis of 30 cases of breast hyperplasia treated with Xiaoyao Loubei powder" 12 (12): 956-957, 2012

106 Ding SJ, "An analysis of 192 cases of cystic hyperplasia of breast treated with the combination of traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 23 (23): 1523-1524, 2007

107 Liao MJ, "A Meta analysis of randomized controlled trials of traditional Chinese medicine in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 17 (17): 17-20, 2010

108 Li R, "A Meta analysis OF Tamoxifen combined with Chinese patent medicine in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 10 (10): 143-145, 2013

109 Huang Q., "A Clinical study of Rūpixiao pill combined with tamoxifen in the treatment of breast hyperplasia" 10 (10): 145-146, 2016

110 Liu W, "800 cases of cystic hyperplasia of breast treated with Chinese and Western Medicine" 29 (29): 792-793, 2008

111 Lin X, "69 cases of Mammary Gland Hyperplasia treated by Rupi Sanjie Capsule" 28 (28): 1631-1632, 2007

112 Zhou YX, "64 cases of severe hyperplasia of mammary gland treated with combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 9 (9): 98-, 2015

113 Du Yanni, "62 cases of Mammary hyperplasia treated by Chinese and Western Medicine" 9 (9): 53-54, 2011

114 Liu ZH, "60 cases of chronic anal sinusitis treated with Kushen Diyu Huaijiao Decoction and Western Medicine" 8 (8): 55-, 2008

115 Wang CZ, "58 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with the combination of Chinese and Western Medicine" 29 (29): 20-22, 2016

116 Liu GX, "50 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated by the combination of traditional Chinese and Western Medicine" 17 (17): 207-, 2008

117 Zhang HL, "132 cases of mammary hyperplasia treated with traditional Chinese medicine" 41 (41): 49-, 2009

118 Chen MQ, "122 cases of breast hyperplasia treated by Gualou Xiebai Banxia Decoction and methyltestosterone" 46 (46): 175-, 2011

119 Li HW, "110 Cases of Cyclomastopathy with Combined Treatment of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Western Medicine" 5 (5): 146-147, 2007

120 Zhao XH, "100cases of hyperplasia of mammary gland treated by xiaosanrukuai capsule" 28 (28): 1486-1487, 2007