중의 변증 설문도구의 신뢰도 및 타당도 고찰 -China National Knowledge Infrastructure를 이용하여- = Review on Reliability and Validity of Questionnaire of Pattern Identification in Traditional Chinese Medicine -Using China National Knowledge Infrastructure-

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to investigate the reliability and validity of the questionnaire of pattern identification (PI) in traditional chinese medicine (TCM), through the systematic review of china national knowledge infrastructure (CNKI) database. We searched the articles related with reliability and validity of the questionnaire of PI and published from January 1994 to December 2013. Seventeen questionnaires were analyzed in this study. The twelve (70.6%) questionnaires were developed on the base of specific disease, and five (29.4%) ones were developed on the base of non-specific disease. Three of PI questionnaires showed low inter-item consistency reliability. Exploratory factor analysis of construct validity, content validity, and criterion validity analysis were commonly used on the assessment of validity, but none of them was analysed at the same study. There was only one questionnaire of the ischemic stroke that examined the sensitivity and specificity of both training and test groups in spite of the absence of a gold standard.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김국기, "화병 변증도구의 신뢰도, 타당도 평가와 활용 가이드라인 연구" 대한한방신경정신과학회 24 (24): 331-342, 2013

2 차용준, "허리통증 환자의 한국판 일상동작 공포설문지의 신뢰도와 타당도" 한국콘텐츠학회 11 (11): 224-232, 2011

3 이인선, "한방진단설문지 DSOM (r) S.1.1의 Upgrade를 위한 신뢰도 연구" 한의병리학회 26 (26): 88-97, 2012

4 이경희, "한국의 도구개발 간호연구에서의 타당도에 대한 고찰" 한국간호과학회 43 (43): 697-703, 2013

5 김규곤, "판별분석모형을 이용한 사상체질분류함수의 개발에 관한 연구 (I) - 크론박 알파 계수에 의한 변수선택 -" 한국자료분석학회 6 (6): 493-504, 2004

6 강현철, "구성타당도 평가에 있어서 요인분석의 활용" 한국간호과학회 43 (43): 587-594, 2013

7 이상재, "陰虛證 측정도구의 개발 및 신뢰도 타당도 검정" 한의병리학회 18 (18): 376-380, 2004

8 구병수, "加味歸脾湯의 우울증 투약지침 개발을 위한 기초연구 - 우울증 변증 설문지의 신뢰도 타당도 평가 -" 대한한방신경정신과학회 20 (20): 1-13, 2009

9 Hu, S. Y., "Thinking on the Assessment of Clinical Therapeutic Effectiveness of TCM" 25 (25): 72-75, 2005

10 Beattie P., "The Role of Functional Status Questionnaires for Low Back Pain" 43 (43): 29-38, 1997

11 Jang, W. W., "The Development of Korean Health Related Quality of Life Scale(KQUOLS)-Testing Reliability and Validity-" 21 (21): 382-394, 2000

12 Huang, C., "Study on Questionnaire and Scale of Pattern Identification in Traditional Chinese Medicine" 29 (29): 889-891, 2011

13 Wang, J., "Study of the Scale Based on Clinical Epidemiology for Blood Stasis Pattern" 49 (49): 270-272, 2008

14 Yang, K. S., "Standardization and Unification of the Terms and Conditions Used for Diagnosis in Oriental Medicine Ⅱ" 2 (2): 381-401, 1996

15 Gu, Z. H., "Review and Outlook on Standardization Study of Pattern in Traditional Chinese Medicine" 48 (48): 751-754, 2007

16 Hwang, I.H., "Research Methods of Questionaries" 15 (15): 30-35, 1994

17 Wang, X. F., "Reliability and Validity Study on the Scale of Differentiation of Symptoms and Specification of Traditional Chinese Medicine in Children Pneumonia by Data Excavation Technique" 5 (5): 15-24, 2010

18 Lu, M., "Reliability and Validity Study on the Scale of Deficiency of Kidney-Yang in Traditional Chinese Medicine" 33 (33): 1220-1222, 2006

19 Tian F., "Reliability and Validity Analysis on Risk Factor and Syndrome Questionnaire of Postmenopausal Osteoporosis in 40~65 Years’ Old Women" 18 (18): 609-611, 2012

20 Zhang, F. R., "Process in Scale Research of Traditional Chinese Medicine" 23 (23): 1812-1815, 2005

21 Wang, Z., "Preliminary Development of the Concision Depression Symptoms Rating Scale of Traditional Chinese Medicine" 14 (14): 945-947, 2005

22 Guo, Q., "Preliminary Development and Evaluation of the Scale for Primary Hypertension with Excessive Rise of Liver-yang" 10 (10): 20-23, 2006

23 Chen, Z. Q., "Preliminary Development and Evaluation of Scales for the Four Mainly Syndromes in Liver Disease of Traditional Chinese Medicine" 15 (15): 660-664, 2007

24 Guo, Q., "Preliminary Development and Evaluation of Scale for Chronic Hepatitis B with Type of Damp-Heat in Liver and Gallbladder" 14 (14): 9-12, 2007

25 Tang, B. Q., "Preliminary Construction of TCM Syndrome Measuring Scale Based on Patient Reported Outcome Instrument for Post-infectious Cough" 40 (40): 1103-1105, 2013

26 Bae, N. S., "Preceding Studies for Questionnaires on Han-Yol Patternization" 9 (9): 98-111, 2005

27 Haywood, K. L., "Patient Reported OutcomeⅠ:Measuring What Matters in Musculoskeletal Care" 4 (4): 187-203, 2006

28 Hair, J.F. Jr., "Multivariate Data Analysis" Prentice Hall 1995

29 Gao, Y., "Methodological Study and Establishment of the Diagnostic Scale for TCM Syndromes of Ischemic Stroke" 52 (52): 2097-2101, 2011

30 China Association of Chinese Medicine, "Guidelines for Diagnosis and Treatment of Common Internal Diseases of Modem Medicine" China Press of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2012

31 China Association of Chinese Medicine, "Guidelines for Diagnosis and Treatment of Common Internal Diseases in Chinese Medicine Symptoms in Chinese Medicine" China Press of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2012

32 Yu, W. Y., "Exploration on Syndrome Differentiation Standardization of Chinese Medicine Diagnosis and Treatment Technologies" 31 (31): 1419-1421, 2011

33 Tang, B. Q., "Establishment of TCM Syndrome Measuring Scale Based on Patient Reported Outcome of Refractory Post-infectious Cough" 46 (46): 13-15, 2012

34 Le, M., "Establishment of Measurement Scale for Spleen Deficiency Syndrome in Chronic Hepatitis B" 42 (42): 6-9, 2008

35 Liu, G. P., "Development and Evaluation of an Inquiry Scale for Diagnosis of Heart System Syndromes in Traditional Chinese Medicine" 7 (7): 20-24, 2009

36 Zhou, J. W., "Development and Evaluation of Validity of the Disease and Pattern Combined Scale on Nerve-root Cervical Spondylosis" 27 (27): 777-779, 2006

37 Zhang, T. S., "Development and Evaluation of TCM Syndrome Measuring Scale Based on Patient Reported Outcome Instrument for Chronic Cough with Unknown Causes" 12 (12): 113-115, 2010

38 Zhou, J. W., "Development and Evaluation of Reliability of the Disease and Pattern Combined Scale on Nerve-root Cervical Spondylosis" 24 (24): 31-33, 2006

39 Gao, Y., "Clinical Validation of the Diagnostic Scale for TCM Syndromes of Ischemic Stroke" 51 (51): 23-25, 2012

40 Lu, M., "Analysis on Reliability and Validity of Deficiency-Cold Questionnaire." 11 (11): 53-55, 2009

41 Dai, X., "Analysis of Reliability and Validity of Deficiency of Kidney “QI” Identification Scale for Elderly Hypertention" 21 (21): 2324-2326, 2010

42 Park, Y. J., "A Study on Standardization of Bian Zheng by Some Statistical Methods." 5 (5): 306-330, 2001

43 Song, N. K., "A Study for the Objective Diagnosis by Statistical Analysis to the Bian Zheng Questionnaire" 11 (11): 127-138, 2005