행정입법에 대한 국회의 통제 = Parliamentary Control of Administrative Rulemaking

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The non-delegation-doctrine (delgata potesta non potest delegari) has been almost abandoned in real practices of modem constitutional democracies, just because modem parliaments have got no choice but to delegate. There remains, however, a core problematique ever and still unresolved, how and to what extent the delegated legislation should be checked, controlled and sanctioned, together with those issues like judicial review of and political control of delegated legislation. It is one of the most pervasive precept that the parliament itself is the most legitimate and responsible instance for control of delegated legislation, which constitutes a cardinal problem area of the korean consitutional and administrative law and jurisprudence. This article deals with theoretical and practical features of the problematique, especially how, to what extent and how effectively the Parliament (National Assembly) can and should control the delegated legislation, and how to enhance and reform the parliamentary control of administrative rulemaking in the legal system of Korea, suggesting an enactment of an "Administrative Rulemaking Procedure Act" as a comprehensive solution package for the problematique.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 문제상황
• Ⅱ. 행정입법에 대한 의회통제의 필요성과 수단
• Ⅲ. 국회에 의한 행정입법 통제의 현황과 개선방안
• Ⅳ. 맺는 말

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "행정입법의 분석검토" 법제예산실 (17) : 1996

2 "행정입법의 분석검토" 법제예산실 (7) : 1999

3 "행정입법 분석사례 - 1999년도 제改正된 행정입법을 중심으로" 국회사무처 법제예산실 1999.

4 정하명, "미국연방법원에서의 위임의 한계" 30 (30): 2002

5 文光三, "미국대통령의 법률안거부권과 거부권의 새로운 경향" 1991.

6 김철용, "독일에 있어서의 연방의회의 법규명령 폐지내용존속에 대한 영향력행사"

7 오준근, "각종 規制改革基本法 制定方案에 대한 行政法的 考察" (12) :

8 이지민, "行政立法에 대한 國會의 統制方案에 관한 연구 - 直接的 統制를 중심으로 -" 서울대학교 행정대학원 2000.

9 金鐵容洪準亨宋石允, "委任立法의 限界에 관한 硏究" 憲法裁判所硏究第八卷 1996.

10 계희열, "國家機能으로서의 立法權" 13 : 2002.

11 in, "The New Separation and Delegation of Powers Doctrine Handbook of Regulation and Administrative Law" 1994.

12 Farber, "Statutory Interpretation and Legislative Supremacy" 1989

13 Cornelius M, "Handbook of Regulation and Administrative Law" 1994.

14 Ulrich M, "Gesetzgebung und Bestimmtheitsgrundsatz" 1996

15 Pnder, H, "Exekutive Normsetzung in den Vereinigten Staaten und der Bundesrepublik Deutschland" 1995

16 F, "Die bertragung rechtsetzender Gewalt nach deutschem Verfassungsrecht"

17 Hans-Jrgen, "Der Bestimmtheitsgrundsatz" 1989-,

18 Schwartz, "Bernhard" Administrative Law Cases During 1993 46administrativelawreview.

19 Aman, Jr, "Administrative Law," pWest, publishing 1993.

20 Craig, P.P, "Administrative Law" 2003.

21 Bernhard, "Administrative Law" oston-, 1991

22 Bernhard, "Administrative Law" oston-, 1991

23 Jr./Mayton, "A Theory of Legislative Delegation" 30-, 1982

24 K.C, "A New Approach to Delegation University of Chicago Law Review 36" 1969