Just for Kicks: Football as a Potential Harmoniser in the China–Pakistan Economic Corridor

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

When the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor began in 2015, many Pakistanis remain concerned about a possible Chinese overreach in the country’s economic and political spheres. In this paper, I suggest that China can placate these critics by utilizing soft power through football. Under Xi Jinping, China has encouraged and supported significant investments in the sport at home and abroad, especially in Europe. While Pakistan is a minnow in world football, the sport is extremely popular among many working-class groups in different regions of the country like Balochistan, Gilgit-Baltistan, and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. These regions, despite their contentious socio-political environments, are crucial for the success of CPEC’s myriad development projects. Using publicly available information, I explore recent Chinese movements in world football, building a theoretical case for why involvement in Pakistani football can bring benefits of goodwill towards harmonizing CPEC’s acceptance, diversifying Sino-Pak ties, building soft image for China through sports in Pakistani society, and facilitating service-oriented local empowerment through the Beautiful Game.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Chadwick, S, "Xi Jinping’s vision for Chinese football" The Asia Dialogue

2 The World Bank, "World Bank in China: Overview"

3 Cockayne, D., "Whose side are we on? Balancing economic interests with social concerns through a service-thinking approach" 1-19, 2019

4 Strenk, A., "What price victory? The world of international sports and politics" 445 (445): 128-140, 1979

5 Raheel, N., "Uneven playing fields: Women’s football is no joke" The Express Tribune

6 Samad, Y., "Understanding the insurgency in Balochistan" 52 (52): 293-320, 2014

7 Iqbal, S, "Trade gap with China rises to $9.7bn in FY18" Dawn

8 Shearer, D., "To play ball, not make war : Sports, diplomacy and soft power" 36 (36): 53-57, 2014

9 Waltz, K. N., "Theory of international politics" Addison-Wesley 1979

10 Wasim, U, "The wait is over: FIFA announces Normalisation Committee for PFF" Dawn

11 Yu, L., "The transition game : Toward a cultural economy of football in post-socialist China" 54 (54): 711-737, 2019

12 Safi, A. Z, "The rebirth of our football league" The News on Sunday

13 Hong, F., "The professionalisation and commercialisation of football in China(1993–2013)" 30 (30): 1637-1654, 2013

14 Clarke, M., "The belt and road initiative: China’s new grand strategy?" 24 (24): 71-79, 2017

15 FIFA.com, "The FIFA women’s world ranking"

16 FIFA.com, "The FIFA men’s world ranking"

17 Small, A., "The China-Pakistan axis: Asia’s new geopolitics" Oxford University Press 2015

18 Rafiq, A., "The China Pakistan economic corridor: Barriers and impact" United States Institute of Peace

19 "Sports ministry devolved under the 18th Amendment" Dawn

20 Bergin, T, "Special Report: How a soccer agent and Chinese tycoon planned to trade in players" Reuters

21 Nye, J., "Soft power: The means to success in world affairs" Public Affairs 2004

22 Chadwick, S., "Soft power sports sponsorship – A social network analysis of a new sponsorship form" 2020

23 Kalimuddin, M., "Soft power in China’s security strategy" 12 (12): 114-141, 2018

24 Nye, J., "Soft power : The origins and political progress of a concept" 3 (3): 17008-, 2017

25 Nye, J., "Soft power" 80 : 153-171, 1990

26 Dimeo, P., "Soccer in South Asia" Routledge 2001

27 Ghori, K. K., "Sixty years of Pakistan’s foreign policy" 60 (60): 9-24, 2007

28 Abbasi, K, "Senate chairman vows to work for promotion of football" Dawn

29 Gilboa, E., "Searching for a theory of public diplomacy" 616 (616): 55-77, 2008

30 APP, "Sanjrani calls for expediting mega projects under CPEC" The Express Tribune

31 Safi, A. Z., "Reforming sports: A tough task" The News on Sunday

32 Mearsheimer, J. J., "Reckless states and realism" 23 (23): 241-256, 2009

33 CPEC Authority, "Progress Update"

34 Yu, J., "Political economic analysis of China’s economic trends : Reasons and solutions for successive declined growth for 5 years" 8 (8): 450-479, 2017

35 Shahnawaz, M., "Policy: Not just cricket" Dawn

36 Odgaard, L., "Peaceful coexistence strategy and China’s diplomatic power" 6 (6): 233-272, 2013

37 Hyder, K., "Pakistan’s foreign policy" 9 (9): 19-24, 1967

38 Din, T., "Pakistan: Three years without any football - can national team recover?" BBC Sport

39 Jamal, U, "Pakistan reels with internal unease regarding CPEC implementation" The Diplomat Magazine

40 FootballPakistan.Com (FPDC) [@FootballPak], "Pakistan mein football kaun dekhta hai [THREAD] Bannu [Tweet]" Twitter

41 Najam, A, "Pakistan human development index report. United Nations Development Program"

42 Wasim, U, "Pakistan football in 2015: A horror show on and offthe pitch" Dawn

43 APP, "PM Khan orders speedy completion of CPEC projects" Dawn

44 "PFF unlikely to retain Chinese coach" Dawn

45 Prasso, S, "One of China’s most ambitious projects becomes a corridor to nowhere" Bloomberg

46 Atkin, D., "On the origins and development of Pakistan’s soccer-ball cluster" 30 (30): S34-S41, 2017

47 Sen, R., "Nation at play: A history of sport in India" Columbia University Press 2015

48 "KP XI stun Chinese Embassy in festival soccer" The News

49 Raheel, N., "Just want a chance to play, says Pakistan women’s football captain Hajra Khan" The Express Tribune

50 Lemus Delgado, D., "It is not a game : Soccer and China’s search for world hegemony" 21 (21): 225-238, 2020

51 "In-Depth: Pakistan Football" Dawn

52 Bizenjo, M. G. B., "In search of solutions: The autobiography of Mir Ghaus Buksh Bizenjo" Pakistan Labour Trust & University of Karachi 2009

53 Bandyopadhyay, K., "In search of an identity : The Muslims and football in colonial India" 10 (10): 843-865, 2009

54 Raheel, N, "In PPFL’s absence: Clubs, departments take to local tournaments" The Express Tribune

55 Dorsey, J. M, "Imran Khan CPEC Diplomacy: Remodelling Trade Politics between Pakistan, Iran, Saudi Arabia and China" AlJazeera Center for Studies

56 International Monetary Fund, "IMF reaches staff-level agreement with Pakistan on the first review under the extended fund facility"

57 Chadwick, S., "How China is fuelling the African Cup of Nations through stadium diplomacy" South China Morning Post

58 Abi-Habib, M, "How China got Sri Lanka to cough up a Port" The New York Times

59 Wilson, E. J., "Hard power, soft power, smart power" 616 (616): 110-124, 2008

60 Kiani, K, "Govt fires back at critics of CPEC debt" Dawn

61 Tan, T., "Globalization and Chinese sport policy : The case of Elite Football in the People’s Republic of China" 203 : 581-600, 2010

62 Connell, J., "Globalisation, soft power, and the rise of football in China" 56 (56): 5-15, 2018

63 Bose, S, "From cricket to online gaming, Indian sports dominated by Chinese – here’s a list" Outlook India

64 Shahnawaz, M, "Football: The song of Lyari" Dawn

65 Trade Development Authority of Pakistan, "Football diplomacy of Pakistan"

66 Jorgic, D, "Fearing debt trap, Pakistan rethinks Chinese ’Silk Road’ projects" Reuters

67 Ahsan, A, "Faisal Saleh Hayat: The Feudal Lord of Pakistani football [The Nation]" FootballPakistan.Com (FPDC)

68 Zhang, S., "FIFA scandal was China’s chance, says top sponsor" Reuters

69 Husain, K, "Exclusive: CPEC master plan revealed" Dawn

70 Shahnawaz, M, "Dreams of nothingness" Dawn

71 Labs, E. J., "Do weak states Bandwagon?" 1 (1): 383-416, 1992

72 Garver, J. W., "Diverging perceptions of China’s emergence as an Indian Ocean power" 22 (22): 56-60, 2016

73 Wasim, U, "Despite no role in PFF, Hayat set to become AFC VP" Dawn

74 Garlick, J., "Deconstructing the China–Pakistan Economic Corridor : Pipe dreams versus geopolitical realities" 27 (27): 519-533, 2018

75 King, C., "Could ‘belt and road’ be the last step in China’s Asian economic integration?" 27 (27): 811-830, 2018

76 Wasim, U., "Contentious PPFL season ends with controversially-promoted team denied title" Dawn

77 Viqar, S., "Constructing Lyari : Place, governance and identity in a Karachi neighbourhood" 5 (5): 365-383, 2014

78 Shahnawaz, M, "Comment: Good sports" Dawn

79 Wei, F., "Chinese state sports policy: Pre- and post-Beijing 2008" 27 (27): 2380-2402, 2008

80 Bland, B., "Chinese investors take route one out of European football" Financial Times

81 Ginesta, X., "Chinese investments in Spanish football : A case study of RCD espanyol new management trends after rastar purchase" 7 (7): 752-770, 2019

82 G€undo"gan, I., "Chinese football in the era of Xi Jinping : What do supporters think" 47 (47): 103-141, 2018

83 Lanxu, Z, "Chinese construction firm makes big global strides" ChinaDaily.com.cn

84 Ali, S, "Chinese Xiao named coach" Dawn

85 Will, R., "China’s stadium diplomacy" 29 (29): 36-43, 2012

86 Chatzky, A, "China’s massive belt and road initiative" Council on Foreign Relations

87 Brewster, D., "China’s maritime silk road initiative and South Asia: A political economic analysis of its purposes, perils, and promise" Palgrave 55-80, 2018

88 Garver, J. W, "China’s Maritime Silk Road initiative and South Asia: A political economic analysis of its purposes, perils, and promise" Palgrave 33-54, 2018

89 Kellison, T., "Case studies in sport diplomacy" FiT Publishing 121-137, 2017

90 Trunkos, J., "Case studies in sport diplomacy" FiT Publishing 1-17, 2017

91 Shah, B, "Can Soccer bring Equality to Pakistan?" The New York Times

92 Duerden, J., "Can European football clubs’ claims about Asian fanbases be believed?" The Guardian

93 Subohi, A, "CPEC: The ball is in Pakistan’s court" Dawn

94 Husain, K, "CPEC on the pivot" Dawn

95 CPEC Authority, "CPEC maps"

96 Basit, A., "Attacks on Chinese nationals and interests in Pakistan are likely to continue. Here’s why" South China Morning Post

97 Kanwal, S., "Assessment of residents’perceptions and support toward development projects : A study of the China–Pakistan Economic Corridor" 2020

98 Peng, Q., "An analysis of the Chinese Football Reform of 2015: Why then and not earlier?" 11 (11): 1-18, 2015

99 Szymanski, S., "About winning : The political economy of awarding the World Cup and the Olympic Games" 31 (31): 87-97, 2011

100 Rakisits, C., "A path to the Sea : China’s Pakistan plan" 178 (178): 67-74, 2015

101 Ahsan, A., "A history of football in Pakistan – Part III" Dawn

102 Ahsan, A., "A history of football in Pakistan – Part II" Dawn

103 Ahsan, A, "A history of football in Pakistan – Part I" Dawn

104 Wasim, U, "A football tournament in KP offers hope for the future" Dawn

105 Harvey, L, "5.6 Critical case study. In Critical social research" Unwin Hyman