보건의료 정책 의사결정과 시민참여 :『건강보험 보장성 시민위원회』의 사례 = Public Participation in Healthcare Decision Making: Experience of Citizen Council for Health Insurance

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Public participation in the decision making for scarce health resources is important because health policy requires trust based consensus, which can be achieved by public's understanding and involvement of related policies. In the past, opportunities for interaction between health policy decision makers and lay public were rare in Korea. As political impulses towards public participation in health policy have increased, a few of deliberation methods were attempted. However, there is little research, reporting such cases with a critical examination of relevant theories and previous studies. We first critically review the literature on public participation within theories of democracy, governance, and empowerment. Next, we report a case of a citizen council experiment, which was held to examine public’s preferences among different benefit options regarding new drugs and medical technologies. Specifically, in an one-day long citizen council with a total of 28 lay public, twelve questions of whether a drug or a technology should be included in the benefit package of health insurance were asked. Pre- and post-surveys investigated participants’perception of public engagement in health policy. Although it was experimental, the citizen council ensured that lay public could be careful enough to rationally compare the costs and benefits of different options and collectively make decisions. Further, results from pre- and post-survey showed a strong willingness of members to be involved in health care decision making. In the conclusion, we emphasize that better theories and methods need to be developed for more cases of citizen participation in health care policy and management.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이원진, "환경보건에서의 주민 참여" 한국환경보건학회 37 (37): 333-334, 2011

2 유명순, "주민참여형 공공병원 운영 혁신방안" 서울의료원 정책실 2012

3 모효정, "이종이식에 관한 시민 인식 연구" 한국생명윤리학회 13 (13): 51-66, 2012

4 이근찬, "의료기관의 조직책무성:분석을 위한 모형 개발" 한국보건행정학회 21 (21): 213-248, 2011

5 이원영, "영국 NICE 의료기술평가의 환자 및 시민참여 경험에 대한 고찰" 비판과대안을위한사회복지학회/비판과대안을위한건강정책학회 (34) : 47-75, 2012

6 주성수, "시민참여,자치권능,심의민주주의 제도-정책 갈등 해결방안의 탐색" 비판사회학회 (63) : 124-145, 2004

7 권순만, "시민위원회와 건강보험 보장성 의사결정 사례" 한국보건경제정책학회 18 (18): 103-119, 2012

8 김명진, "대중과 과학기술" 잉걸 2001

9 한재각, "과학기술 시민참여의 새로우 유형: 수행되지 않은 과학 하기" 9 (9): 1-31, 2009

10 권순만, "건강보험 보장성 수준 및 달성전략" 서울대학교 보건대학원 2007

11 권순만, "건강보험 보장성 강화의 정책결정과정" 5 (5): 7-16, 2011

12 안네 메테 키에르 (Anne Mette Kjær), "거버넌스" 도서출판 오름 2004

13 Pivik J. R., "practical strategies for facilitating meaningful citizen involvement in health planning" University of Ottawa 2002

14 Harrison S., "Which Champions, Which People? Public and User Involvement in Health Care as a Technology of Legitimation" 32 (32): 60-70, 1998

15 Emanuel EJ, "What is accountability in health care?" 124 (124): 229-239, 1996

16 Abelson J., "Towards More Meaningful, Informed, and Effective Public Consultation" Canadian Health Services Research Foundation 2004

17 Creighton J.L., "The Use of Values: Public participation in the planning process. from Public involvement Techniques: A Reader of Ten Years Experience at the Institute for Water Resources" IWR 1998

18 Habermas J, "The Theory of Communicative Action, Vol. One, Reason and the Rationalization of Society" Beacon Press 1984

19 Esfandiari S, "The Limited Role of Citizens in Shaping Healthcare Policies" 2 (2): 39-47, 2010

20 Boelen C,, "Social accountability and accreditation: a new frontier for educational institutions" 43 (43): 887-894, 2009

21 이재열, "Social Quality as a Measure for Social Progress" 사회발전연구소 40 (40): 153-172, 2011

22 Bucchi M., "Science and public participation, Cap. 19, In Handbook of Science and Technology Studies - Third Edition" MIT press 449-473, 2008

23 Giddens A, "Runaway world : how globalization is reshaping our lives" Routledge 2000

24 Zakus JD, "Revisiting community participation" 13 (13): 1-12, 1998

25 Redden CJ, "Rationing care in the community: engaging citizens in health care decision making" 24 (24): 1363-1389, 1999

26 Redden, CJ, "Rationing Care in the Community: Engaging citizens in health care decision making" 24 (24): 1364-1389, 1999

27 Rowe G., "Public participation methods: a framework for evaluation" 25 (25): 3-29, 2004

28 Mitton C, "Public participation in health care priority setting: A scoping review" 91 (91): 219-228, 2009

29 Newman, J., "Public participation and collaborative governance" 33 (33): 203-223, 2004

30 Mullen P.M, "Public involvement in health care priority setting: an overview of methods for eliciting values" 2 (2): 222-234, 1999

31 Grant J, "Public engagement and the changing face of health system planning" 21 (21): 22-26, 2008

32 Cook, F.L., "Public deliberation, discursive participation, and citizen engagement:: A reivew of the empirical literature" 2004

33 Ranson S., "Public accountability in the age of neoliberal governance" 18 (18): 459-480, 2003

34 Ham C., "Priority setting in health care: learning from international experience" 42 (42): 49-66, 1997

35 Kitzhaber J.A., "Prioritising health services in an era of limits: the Oregon experience" 307 (307): 373-377, 1993

36 Ahmad S., "People as partners: Facilitating people's participation in public–private partnerships for solid waste management" 30 (30): 781-796, 2006

37 Dedeu T., "Participation of the public in the governance of healthcare organisations" 2 (2): 2010

38 Coelho, V.S.P., "Participation and public policies in Brazil, In The deliberative democracy Handbook" Jossey Bass 2005

39 Pollitt, C., "Managerialism and the Public Service" Blackwell 1990

40 Charles C,, "Lay participation in health care decision making: a conceptual framework" 18 (18): 881-904, 1993

41 Chambers R., "Involving patients and the public-is it worth the effort?" 84 : 375-377, 2001

42 Weinstein M.C., "Foundations of cost-effectiveness analysis for health and medical practices" 296 (296): 716-721, 1977

43 Simces, Z., "Exploring the link between public involvement / citizen engagement and quality health care" Health Human Resources Strategies Division, Health Canada 2003

44 Abelson J,, "Effective strategies for interactive public engagement in the development of healthcare policies and programs" Canadian Health Services Research Foundation 2010

45 Boote J, "Consumer involvement in health research: a review and research agenda" 61 : 213-236, 2002

46 Singer P., "Community participation in health care decision making: is it feasible?" 3 (3): 421-424, 1997

47 Caddy, J., "Citizens As Partners: Information, Consultation and Public Participation in Policy-Making" OECD 2001

48 Church J, "Citizen participation in health decision-making: past experience and future prospects" 23 (23): 12-32, 2002

49 Elliott, J., "Characteristics of performative cultures: their central paradoxes and limitations as resources for educational reform, In The Performing School: managing, teaching and learning in a performance culture" RoutledgeFalmer 192-209, 2001

50 Dubnick M.J., "Accountable governance: Problems and promises" M.E. Sharpe 2011

51 Klein R., "Accountability society and health care, In The Changing Face of Health Systems" Gefen Publishing House 403-408, 2002

52 Rosen B, "Accountability And Responsibility In Health Care: Issues in Addressing an Emerging Global Challenge" 1 : 2012

53 Contandriopoulos D., "A sociological perspective on public participation in health care" 58 (58): 321-330, 2004

54 Chafe, R., "A framework for involving the public in health care coverage and resource allocation decisions" Canadian Health Services Research Foundation, Canadian Institutes of Health Research, Newfoundland and Labrador Centre for Applied Health Research, Nova Scotia Health Research, Foundation and Ontario Ministry of Health and Long Term Care 2007

55 O'Neill, O., "A Question of Trust: The BBC Reith Lectures" Cambridge University Press 2002