Reconciling the WTO Effects on Trade at the Extensive and Intensive Margins

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Empirical studies examining the impact of World Trade Organization (WTO) membership have produced disparate results. These studies, however, have focused on total aggregate trade flows. In this paper, we utilize disaggregated product level data to examine the impact of WTO membership on the product level extensive and intensive margin of imports. Utilizing the Poisson Pseudo-Maximum Likelihood (PPML) estimation that allows for heteroskedasticity in trade data and accounting for several estimation issues, we do not find a positive impact on either margins between WTO member country-pairs. Once we examine asymmetries in trade flows across countries based on their level of development, we find that developing WTO members experience an increase in the extensive margin from industrial member countries. Additionally, the industrial WTO members also experience an increase in the extensive margin from developing WTO members. Results suggest that WTO facilitates the North–South trade relationship, which has been largely absent in trade literature.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Francois, J. F., "Trade policy transparency and investor confidence : Some implications for an effective trade policy review mechanism" 9 : 303-316, 2001

2 Eicher, T. S., "Trade creation and diversion revisited : accounting for model uncertainty and natural trading partner effects" 27 : 296-321, 2012

3 Eicher, T. S., "Trade creation and diversion revisited : accounting for model uncertainty and natural trading partner effects" 2010

4 Handley, K., "Trade and investment under policy uncertainty: Theory and firm evidence – citation" Mimeo 2010

5 Hummels, D., "The variety and quality of a nation’s exports" 95 : 704-723, 2005

6 Santos Silva, J., "The log of gravity" 88 : 641-658, 2006

7 Melitz, M. J., "The impact of trade on intra-industry reallocations and aggregate industry productivity" 71 : 1695-1725, 2003

8 Dutt, P., "The effect of WTO on the extensive and the intensive margins of trade" 91 : 204-219, 2013

9 Subramanian, A., "The WTO promotes trade, strongly but unevenly" 72 (72): 151-175, 2007

10 Subramanian, A., "The WTO promotes trade, strongly but unevenly" National Bureau of Economic Research 2003

11 Nitsch, V., "Scalpel, please! dissecting the euro’s effect on trade" 2008

12 Gourieroux, C., "Pseudo maximum likelihood methods : Applications to poisson models" 52 : 701-720, 1984

13 Santos Silva, J., "On the existence of the maximum likelihood estimates in poisson regression" 107 : 310-312, 2010

14 Felbermayr, G., "Modelling the extensive margin of world trade : New evidence on GATT and WTO membership" 33 : 1430-1469, 2010

15 Sala, D., "Market access through bound tariffs" 57 : 272-289, 2010

16 Henderson, D. J., "Is gravity linear?" 23 : 137-172, 2008

17 Mansfield, E. D., "International institutions and the volatility of international trade" 62 : 621-652, 2008

18 Eicher, T. S., "In search of wto trade effects : Preferential trade agreements promote trade strongly, but unevenly" 83 : 137-153, 2011

19 Anderson, J. E., "Gravity with gravitas : A solution to the border puzzle" 93 (93): 170-192, 2003

20 Broda, C., "Globalization and the gains from variety" 121 : 541-585, 2006

21 Liu, X., "GATT/WTO promotes trade strongly : Sample selection and model specification" 17 : 428-446, 2009

22 Bernard, A. B., "Firms in international trade" 21 : 105-130, 2007

23 Handley, K., "Exporting under trade policy uncertainty: Theory and evidence"

24 Flam, H., "Euro effects on the intensive and extensive margins of trade" Institute for International Economic Studies 2006

25 Helpman, E., "Estimating trade flows : Trading partners and trading volumes" 123 : 441-487, 2008

26 Cameron, A. C., "Essentials of count data regression" Blackwell Publishing 331-348, 2007

27 Winkelmann, R., "Econometric analysis of count data" Springer 2008

28 Rose, A. K., "Do we really know that the WTO increases trade?" 94 (94): 98-114, 2004

29 Francois, J., "Commercial policy variability, bindings, and market access" 48 : 665-679, 2004

30 Bchir, M. H., "Binding overhang and tariff-cutting formulas" 142 : 207-232, 2006

31 Staiger, R. W., "An Entry for the New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics Online" Palgrave Macmillan 2008

32 Staiger, R. W., "An Entry for the New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics" 2006

33 Flowerdew, R., "A method of fitting the gravity model based on the poisson distribution" 22 : 191-202, 1982