메이지일본과 ‘문명전쟁’의 정치학 * 청일 러일 전쟁기 아리가 나가오(有賀長雄)의 사상을 중심으로

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

It is the subject which has been researched in various fields that, during the Meiji period, Japan succeeded to emerge into full membership in the international society which was controlled by western powers at the time. This paper takes the approach of the study of the history of political thought to understand the rise of Japan during the Meiji period. In order to do that, this paper will focus on Ariga Nagao who was one of the pioneers of the study of international law and history of diplomacy. Ariga argued a war, even without a declaration, is a fully legitimate act, since it is the expression of the ‘free will’ of independent states. Ariga’s pro-war theory of international law was affected by Lorenzo von Stein who was a scholar of Staatswissenschaft which means the sciences of the state in German. In Ariga’s theory, military intervention by a powerful nation to a weaker one is justified with this magic word of the ‘free will’. At the same time, Ariga strongly states that, if Japan is to become one of the ‘civilized countries’, it is required to follow the diplomatic custom of them: And there was no exception during the war time. He rather considers the war as the most effective way to prove how ‘civilized’ Japan is. During the Sino-Japanese and Russo-Japanese wars, he accompanied a army for the purpose of proving that the Japanese army is conducting a war in accordance with the ‘civilized custom . In conclusion, Ariga shows two different seemingly contradictory arguments: One is the absolutization of national sovereignty, which even justifies ‘imperialism’, and the other is the observance of the ‘civilized custom’ of the international community. A ‘civilized empire’ would be an appropriate definition to describe Japan s diplomatic ideals of the time.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 들어가며 : 아리가 나가오 연구의 의의 Ⅱ. 아리가 나가오의 이력 Ⅲ. ‘자유의지’로서의 전쟁권 Ⅳ. 청일･러일 전쟁과 ‘문명국’ 일본이라는 꿈 Ⅴ. 맺으며 : ‘문명’과 ‘제국주의’의 잔혹한 결혼

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 히라이시 나오아키, "한국 보호국론의 제 양상(諸樣相)에 대하여" 2007

2 도시환, "을사늑약의 국제법적 문제점에 대한 재조명" 대한국제법학회 60 (60): 125-149, 2015

3 Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich, "법철학" 한길사 2008

4 함동주, "러일전쟁 후 일본의 한국식민론과 식민주의적 문명론" 동양사학회 (94) : 177-203, 2006

5 고쿠분 노리코, "두 시점의 개념사 : 현지성과 동시성으로 보는 동아시아근대" 푸른역사 2013

6 서영희, "대한제국정치사" 서울대학교출판부 2003

7 하영선, "근대한국의 사회과학 개념 형성사" 창비 2009

8 사카이 데쓰야, "근대일본의 국제질서론" 연암서가 2010

9 최덕수, "근대 계몽기 한국과 일본 지식인의 ‘보호국론’비교 연구" 동북아역사재단 (24) : 111-141, 2009

10 김현수, "국제법" 연경문화사 2015

11 松澤弘陽, "近代日本の形成と西洋経験" 岩波書店 1993

12 伊藤信哉, "近代日本の外交論壇と外交史學：戰前期『外交時報』と外交史教育" 日本經濟評論社 2011

13 苅部直, "福澤諭吉における「公徳」：『文明論之概略』第六章をめぐって" 38 : 2011

14 有賀長雄, "社會進化論(増補4版)" 牧野書房 1890

15 有賀長雄, "滿洲委任統治論 : 有賀博士陣中著述" 早稻田大學出版部 1905

16 有賀長雄, "東京専門學校政治経済科第1回1年級" 東京専門學校 1895

17 五百旗頭薫, "東アジア國際政治史" 名古屋大學出版會 2007

18 信夫淳平, "有賀長雄博士の十三回忌に際し" (685) : 1933

19 煙山専太郎, "有賀先生の思ひ出" 686 : 1933

20 有賀長雄, "最近三十年外交史(下)" 早稲田大學出版部 1910

21 有賀長雄, "時事雑感" 95 : 1905

22 西周譯, "明治文化研究會編『明治文化全集(第13巻：法律篇)" 日本評論社 1968

23 有賀長雄, "日露陸戰國際法論" 東京偕行社 1911

24 有賀長雄, "日清戰役國際法論" 陸軍大學校 1896

25 大久保建晴, "日本の外交(第3巻:外交思想)" 岩波書店 2013

26 有賀長雄, "文明戰爭法規" 金港堂書籍 1904

27 易平, "戰爭と平和の間 : 発足期日本國際法學における「正しい戰爭」の観念とその歸結" Torkel Opsahl Academic EPublisher 2013

28 南次郎, "我が陸軍と有賀博士" 685 : 1933

29 "官報"

30 有賀長雄, "國際道徳論" 39 : 1901

31 寺尾亨, "國際公法(戰時ノ部)" 日本法律學校 21-, 1901

32 有賀長雄, "國家學" 牧野書房 1889

33 有賀長雄, "保護國論" 早稲田大學出版部 1906

34 瀧井一博, "伊藤博文" 中央公論新社 2010

35 春名展生, "人口・資源・領土 : 近代日本の外交思想と國際政治學" 千倉書房 2015

36 黒澤文貴, "二つの「開國」と日本" 東京大學出版會 2013

37 丸山眞男, "丸山眞男集(第五巻)" 岩波書店 1995

38 山口靜一, "フェノロサ社會論集" 思文閣出版 2000

39 柴田隆行, "シュタインの社會と國家：ローレンツ・フォン・シュタインの思想形成過程" お茶の水書房 2006

40 苅部直, "「維新革命」への道：「文明」を求めた十九世紀日本" 新潮社 2017

41 Bell, Duncan, "The Cambirdge History of nineteenth-century political thought" Cambridge University Press 2011

42 Martens, Frédéric de, "Revue Générale de Droit International Public, 11" 1904

43 Ariga, Nagao, "La Guerre Russo-Japonaise : au point de vue continental et le droit international" Pedone 1908

44 Oppenheim, Lassa Francis Lawrence, "International Law : A Treatise, Volume II : War and Neutrality" Longmans, Green & Co 1912

45 Stein, Lorenz von, "Der Sozialismus und Kommunismus des heutigen Frankreich : Ein Beitrag zur Zeitgeschichte" Otto Wigand 1842

46 Phillimore, Robert, Sir, "Commentaries upon international law, Vol.3" Butterworths 1879