듀이의 실재 개념에 대한 형이상학적, 인식론적 분석 = A Metaphysical and Epistemological Analysis of Dewey’s Concept of Reality

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Dewey does not accept the argument of the conventional philosophy that reality lies beyond ordinary everyday experiences. For him, reality refers to the things revealed through ‘concrete’ experiences. The purpose of this study is to establish that experience is ontologically continuous with reality, and that human involvement in reality becomes a justification for the non-hierarchical relationship between teacher and student. To this end, this study proceeds as follows: First, based on Dewey’s analysis of the nature of experience and Hampe’s analysis of the concept of immediacy, Section 2 explains that reality is revealed ‘directly’ through experience. This leads to the clarification of the difference between existence and function as well as the ontological status of quality. Based on the metaphysical analysis of ‘the immediate existence of quality’, Section 3 demonstrates that reality is to be understood in terms of ‘particular’ properties. Through this, it is clearly shown that man and reality are ontologically connected by experience. Based on the epistemological analysis of ‘the immediate existence of quality’, Section 4 demonstrates that reality refers to the things revealed through ‘present’ experiences. Through this, it is clearly shown that the order of existence is not existential, but is an abstraction used for the interpretation of existential events. Section 5, the last section of this study, demonstrates that the relationship between teacher and student is to be understood as non-hierarchical based on the fact that all expressions made during a school lesson point at reality. A school lesson as a communication process, where teacher and student participate at the same level, leads to the reconceptualization of the curriculum contents.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

듀이는 실재가 일상적 경험의 저편에 있다는 기존 철학의 주장을 받아들이지 않는다. 그에게 있어서 실재는 ‘구체적인’ 경험을 통해서 드러나는 것이다. 본 연구의 목적은 경험이 실재와 존재론적으로 연속적인 관계에 놓여있다는 사실과 실재에 대한 인간적 관여가 비위계적 교사-학생 관계의 근거가 된다는 사실을 밝히는 것이다. 본 연구의 내용과 방법은 다음과 같다. 우선 2절에서는 경험의 본성에 대한 듀이의 분석과 직접성 개념에 대한 함페의 분석에 기초하여 실재가 경험을 통해서 ‘직접적으로’ 드러나는 것임을 설명한다. 이것은 존재와 기능의 차이 및 질성의 존재론적 지위를 명확히 하는 작업으로 발전한다. 3절에서는 ‘질성의 직접적 존재’에 대한 형이상학적 분석에 기초하여 실재가 ‘개별적’ 속성의 의미에서 파악되어야 함을 논증한다. 이를 통해서 인간과 실재가 경험을 매개로 하여 존재론적으로 서로 연결되어 있음이 밝혀진다. 4절에서는 ‘질성의 직접적 존재’에 대한 인식론적 분석에 기초하여 실재가 ‘현재의’ 경험을 통해서 드러나는 것임을 논증한다. 이를 통해서 존재의 질서(존재에 관한 개념)는 존재 자체가 아니라 존재(사건)의 해석을 위해 사용되는 추상임이 밝혀진다. 마지막 5절에서는 수업에서 생산되는 (또는 만들어지는) 모든 표현이 실재와 연결되어 있다는 사실에 기초하여 교사와 학생 사이의 관계가 비위계적으로 규정되어야 함을 논증한다. 표현의 협력적 생산 과정으로서의 수업은 교육내용의 재개념화를 동반한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Eames, S. M., "실용주의. 펴어스·제임스·듀이·미이드의 철학" 전남대학교 출판부 1999

2 김무길, "듀이의 실재관과 교육" 인문학연구원 (48) : 5-31, 2011

3 최훈, "듀이의 ‘학교 환경의 재설계’에 대한 철학적 고찰: 질성적 직접성과 외연 관계에 대한 개념적 분석" 한국교육철학학회 41 (41): 191-210, 2019

4 Regenbogen, A., "Wörterbuch der philosophischen Begriffe" Felix Meiner Verlag 2013

5 Garrett, B., "What is this Thing Called Metaphysics?" Routledge 2011

6 Merkens, H., "Unterricht: Eine Einführung" Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften 2010

7 Fraassen, B. C. v., "The Scientific Image" Clarendon Press 1980

8 Sleeper, R. W., "The Necessity of Pragmatism: John Dewey’s Conception of Philosophy" Yale University Press 1986

9 Dewey, J., "The Middle Works,1899-1924. Volume 10: 1916-1917" Southern Illinois University Press 64-66, 1980

10 Dewey, J., "The Middle Works, 1899-1924. Volume 6: 1910-1911" Southern Illinois University Press 103-122, 1978

11 Dewey, J., "The Middle Works, 1899-1924. Volume 3: 1903-1906" Southern Illinois University Press 158-167, 1977

12 Dewey, J., "The Middle Works, 1899-1924. Volume 15: 1923-1924" Southern Illinois University Press 27-41, 1983

13 Dewey, J., "The Middle Works, 1899-1924. Volume 13: 1921-1922" Southern Illinois University Press 40-60, 1983

14 Dewey, J., "The Middle Works, 1899-1924. Volume 10: 1916-1917" Southern Illinois University Press 320-365, 1980

15 Dewey, J., "The Later Works, 1925-1953. Volume 5: 1929-1930" Southern Illinois University Press 210-217, 1984

16 Dewey, J., "The Later Works, 1925-1953. Volume 5: 1929-1930" Southern Illinois University Press 243-262, 1984

17 Dewey, J., "The Later Works, 1925-1953. Volume 5: 1929-1930" Southern Illinois University Press 218-242, 1984

18 Dewey, J., "The Later Works, 1925-1953. Volume 4: 1929" Southern Illinois University Press 1984

19 Dewey, J., "The Later Works, 1925-1953. Volume 3: 1927-1928" Southern Illinois University Press 73-81, 1984

20 Dewey, J., "The Later Works, 1925-1953. Volume 1: 1925" Southern Illinois University Press 1981

21 Dewey, J., "The Later Works, 1925-1953. Volume 12: 1938" Southern Illinois University Press 1991

22 Dewey, J., "The Later Works, 1925-1953. Volume 10: 1934" Southern Illinois University Press 1987

23 Dewey, J., "The Early Works, 1882-1898. Volume 5: 1903-1906" Southern Illinois University Press 96-109, 1972

24 Kelly, A. V., "The Curriculum. Theory and Practice" SAGE 2009

25 Audi, R., "The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy" Cambridge University Press 2009

26 Bunnin, N., "The Blackwell Dictionary of Western Philosophy" Wiley-Blackwell 2009

27 Maxwell, G., "Scientific Explanation, Space, and Time: Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science" University of Minnesota Press 181-192, 1962

28 Sleeper, R. W., "Rorty’s Pragmatism: Afloat in Neurath’s Boat, but Why Adrift?" 21 (21): 9-20, 1985

29 Putnam, H., "Realism with a Human Face" Harvard University Press 1990

30 Boisvert, R. D., "Reading Dewey. Interpretations for a Postmodern Generation" Indiana University Press 149-165, 1998

31 Shusterman, R., "Philosophie der Demokratie. Beiträge zum Werk von John Dewey" Suhrkamp 81-115, 2000

32 Blackburn, S., "Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy" Oxford University Press 2008

33 Williams, D. C., "On the Elements of Beings: Ⅰ" 7 (7): 3-18, 1953

34 Choi, H., "Naturalistische Metaphysik und Pädagogik John Deweys. Bildungstheoretische Betrachtung über eine ontologische Kontinuität zwischen Erfahrung und Natur aus organisch-holistischer Perspektive" Janus 2019

35 Montague, W. P., "May a Realist be a Pragmatist?: Ⅲ. The Implications of Psychological Pragmatism" 6 (6): 543-548, 1909

36 Alexander, Th. M., "John Dewey’s Theory of Art, Experience, and Nature. The Horizons of feeling" State University of New York Press 1987

37 Bellmann, J., "John Deweys Naturalistische Pädagogik. Argumentationskontexte, Traditionslinien" Ferdinand Schöningh 2007

38 Bohnsack, F., "John Dewey. Ein pädagogisches Porträt" Beltz 2005

39 Granger, D. A., "John Dewey, Robert Pirsig, and the Art of Living. Revisioning Aesthetic Education" Palgrave Macmillan 2006

40 Jackson, P. W., "John Dewey and the Lessons of Art" Yale University Press 1998

41 Neubert, St, "Erkenntnis, Verhalten und Kommunikation. John Deweys Philosophie des experience in interaktionistisch-konstruktivistischer Interpretation" Waxmann 1998

42 Hampe, M., "Erkenntnis und Praxis. Zur Philosophie des Pragmatismus" Suhrkamp 2006

43 Phenix, P. H., "Education and Structure of Knowledge" Rand Mcnally 44-74, 1964

44 Harold, H. I., "Direct Realism, Indirect Realism, and Epistemology" 52 (52): 341-363, 1991

45 Godfrey-Smith, P., "Dewey’s Enduring Impact: Essays on America’s Philosopher" Prometheus Books 73-86, 2010

46 Shook, J. R., "Dewey’s Empirical Theory of Knowledge and Reality" Vanderbilt University Press 2000

47 Lovejoy, A. O., "Dewey and His Critics. Essays from the Journal of Philosophy" Lancaster Press 142-152, 1988

48 Woodbridge, F. J. E., "Dewey and His Critics. Essays from the Journal of Philosophy" Lancaster Press 52-59, 1988

49 Rorty, R., "Consequences of Pragmatism: Essays, 1972-1980" University of Minnesota Press 1982

50 Locke, J., "An Essay concerning Human Understanding" Clarendon Press 1975

51 Campbell, K., "Abstract Particulars" Basil Blackwell 1990

52 Hume, D., "A treatise of Human Nature" Clarendon Press 1987