수학전쟁의 기원과 우리나라 수학교육과정 개정 -‘중등수학교육의 문제점’과 ‘1923 Report’- = Mathematics Curriculum Revising Processes & Directions from the Standpoints of the Comtemporary Two Reports in the 1920’s as the Origin of Math Wars

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study was designed to gain insights into contemporary secondary mathematics curriculum revision in Korea. The two secondary mathematics curriculum reports submitted in the 1920s, the Kilpatrick Reports and 1923 Reports were compared and contrasted as the origin of recent math wars, and their backgrounds, committee members, viewpoints of math and math education and contents were analyzed to understand the perspectives of the two extreeme parts. Kilpatrick Reports was selected at that time, but nevertheless 1923 Report had taken a role of guiding secondary mathematics in US until the New Math era.
The direction and process of mathematics curriculum revision were suggested based on the analysis of reports’ short- and long-term influences. A close examination of the curriculum revision process in US and in Korea and the implications from the results are also included in the suggestion.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 우리나라 수학교육과정의 개정 방향과 과정에 시사점을 얻기 위하여 설계되었다. 최근 수학교육과정 개정에 나타나는 전통과 개혁, 내용과 방법 사이의 갈등을 일컫는 ‘수학전쟁’의 본질을 이해하기 위하여 이 연구는 수학전쟁의 기원이라 할 수 있는 1920년대 중등 수학교육과정에 관한 두 보고서, 일명 Kilpatrick 보고서와 1923 보고서에 주목하고, 보고서의 배경과 저자, 수학과 수학교육에 대한 관점과 보고서 내용, 그 파급 효과 등을 상세히 비교․대조하여 거시적 안목에서 교육과정 개정의 쟁점을 정리하였다. 또 Standards 중심의 개혁에 대한 최근 미국 수학전쟁의 양상, 해외 수학교육의 동향, 우리나라와 미국 수학 교육 개정 과정의 특징을 분석하였으며, 그 결과를 토대로 현재 우리나라 수학교육과정 연구와 개발에 중요하게 고려해야 할 사항과 현안 과제를 제안하였다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 위인숙, "한국 수학․과학교육의 현황과 제언" 44-47, 2008

2 박성선, "수학전쟁" 교우사 2008

3 백석윤, "수학과 교육과정 개정방식 개선을 위한 연구" 대한수학교육학회 14 (14): 157-170, 2004

4 조향숙, "수학․과학교육 경쟁력 강화를 위한 수학․과학 교육 내실화 방안 연구 (2008.교육과학기술부 정책연구과제 최종보고서)" 한국과학창의재단 2008

5 The ScienceTimes, "벼랑 끝에 선 수학과학교육’이 살 길은?"

6 장혜원, "미국의 수학교육과정 규준 CCSSM의 수학적 실천에 대한 고찰" 대한수학교육학회 22 (22): 557-580, 2012

7 차성헌, "미국의 수학 공통 핵심 교육과정 및 우리나라 수학교육 개선을 위한 시사점" 한국교육개발원 36-, 2012

8 소경희, "미국의 교과교육에 있어서 국가공통 기준 도입 운동의 역사적 맥락과 주요 쟁점" 한국교육과정학회 31 (31): 55-77, 2013

9 머니투데이, "문이과 구분 폐지에 과학계 폭발…“통합하고 과학교육 축소?"

10 Mathematically Correct, "What is Changing in Math Education?"

11 National Education Association. Commission on the Reorganization of Secondary Education, "The problem of mathematics in secondary education. A report of the commission on the reorganization of secondary education, appointed by the National Education Association. Department of the Interior Bureau of Education, Bulletin, 1920, No.1" Government Printing Office 1920

12 Riley, Richard W., "The State of Mathematics Education: Building a Strong Foundation for the 21st Century"

13 Butler, C. H., "The Reorganization Report of 1923" 44 (44): 90-92, 1951

14 U.S. Department of Education, "The Final Report of the National Mathematics Advisory Panel"

15 Howe, R., "The AMS and Mathematics Education: The Revision of the “NCTM Standards.”" 243-247, 1998

16 Mathematical Sciences Education Board, National Research Council, "Reshaping School Mathematics: A Philosophy and Framework for Curriculum" National Academy Press 1990

17 Hiebert, J., "Relationships between research and the NCTM Standards" 30 : 3-19, 1999

18 Van de Walle, J. A., "Reform Mathematics vs. The Basics: Understanding the Conflict and Dealing with It" 1999

19 Mathematical Association of America, "Readings in the history of mathematics education" NCTM 329-460, 1970

20 Bidwell, James K., "Readings in the History of Mathematics Education" NCTM 1970

21 NCTM, "Professional Standards for School Mathematics" NCTM 1991

22 Ferrini-Mundy, J., "Principles and standards for school mathematics: A guide for mathematicians" 868-876, 2000

23 NCTM, "Principles and Standards for School Mathematics" NCTM 2000

24 Burrill, G., "President's Report: Changes in Your Classroom: From the Past to the Present to the Future" 29 (29): 583-594, 1998

25 National Mathematics Advisory Panel, "Preliminary Report" National Mathematics Advisory Panel 2007

26 O’Brien, T. C., "Parrot math" 80 : 434-443, 1999

27 이미경, "PISA 2006 결과분석 연구 - 과학적 소양, 읽기 소양, 수학적소양 수준 및 배경 변인 분석-" 한국교육과정평가원 2007

28 Steen, L., "Mathematics Education at Risk. Issues in Science and Technology"

29 English, L. D., "Mathematics Education" LEA 1995

30 Schoen, H. L., "Issues and options in the math wars" 80 : 444-453, 1999

31 National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, "History of Math Education in US and Canada: 32nd Yearbook"

32 Mathematical Sciences Education Board and the Board on Mathematical Sciences, National Research Council, "Everybody Counts: A Report to the Nation on the Future of Mathematics Education" National Academy Press 1989

33 NCTM, "Curriculum and Evaluation Standards for School Mathematics" NCTM 1989

34 NCTM, "Curriculum Focal Points for Prekindergarten through Grade 8 Mathematics : A Quest for Coherence" NCTM 2006

35 Von Glassersfeld, E., "Constructivism in education" Erlbaum 3-15, 1995

36 Jeffrey,M., "Common Ground in the U.S. Math Wars" 312 : 988-990, 2006

37 Common Core State Standards Initiative, "Common Core State Standards for Mathematics (CCSSM)"

38 NCTM, "Assessment Standards for School Mathematics" NCTM 1995

39 NCTM, "An Agenda for Action: Recommendations for School Mathematics of the 1980s" NCTM 1980

40 Gardner, D. P., "A nation at risk" The National Commission on Excellence in Education, US Department of Education 1983

41 Klein, D., "A Brief History of American K-12 Mathematics Education in the 20th Century" Mathematical Cognition, Information Age Publishing 2003