Selection of appropriate biomatrices for studies of chronic stress in animals: a review

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Cortisol and corticosterone, hormones traditionally considered biomarkers of stress, can be measured in fluid biomatrices (e.g., blood, saliva) from live animals to evaluate conditions at sampling time, or in solid biomatrices (e.g., hair, feather) from live or dead animals to obtain information regarding long-term changes. Using these biomarkers to evaluate physiological stress responses in domestic animals may be challenging due to the diverse characteristics of biomatrices for potential measurement. Ideally, a single measurement from the biomatrix should be sufficient for evaluating chronic stress. The availability of appropriate and cost-effective immunoassay methods for detecting the biomarkers should also be considered. This review discusses the strengths and limitations of different biomatrices with regard to ensuring the highest possible reliability for chronic stress evaluation. Overall, solid biomatrices require less frequent sampling than other biomatrices, resulting in greater time- and cost-effectiveness, greater ease of use, and fewer errors. The multiplex immunoassay can be used to analyze interactions and correlations between cortisol and other stress biomarkers in the same biomatrix. In light of the lack of information regarding appropriate biomatrices for measuring chronic stress, this review may help investigators set experimental conditions or design biological research.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최인학 ; 박철 ; 곽상기 ; 정태호, "동물 복지 융합형 디지털 콘텐츠 제작을 위한 야외효력시험에서 이유 자돈의 혈중 Cortisol 분석" 한국환경과학회 29 (29): 575-578, 2020

2 Ghassemi Nejad J, "Wool cortisol is a better indicator of stress than blood cortisol in ewes exposed to heat stress and water restriction" 8 : 128-132, 2014

3 Gormally BMG, "What are you actually measuring? A review of techniques that integrate the stress response on distinct time-scales" 34 : 2030-2044, 2020

4 Bortolotti GR, "Tracking stress : localisation, deposition and stability of corticosterone in feathers" 212 : 1477-1482, 2009

5 Heimbürge S, "The use of hair cortisol for the assessment of stress in animals" 270 : 10-17, 2019

6 Meyer JS, "The international encyclopedia of primatology" Wiley Blackwell 597-598, 2017

7 Oster H, "The functional and clinical significance of the 24-hour rhythm of circulating glucocorticoids" 38 : 3-45, 2017

8 Fernandez-Novo A, "The effect of stress on reproduction and reproductive technologies in beef cattle—a review" 10 : 2096-, 2020

9 Bahnsen I, "The effect of different feeding systems on salivary cortisol levels during gestation in sows on herd level" 11 : 1074-, 2021

10 Mendoza SP, "The biology of animal stress: basic principles and implications for animal welfare" CABI 227-247, 2000

11 Moberg GP, "The biology of animal stress: basic principles and implications for animal welfare" CABI 1-21, 2000

12 Moberg GP, "The biology of animal stress: basic principles and implications for animal welfare" CABI 2000

13 Binz TM, "Systematic investigations of endogenous cortisol and cortisone in nails by LC-MS/MS and correlation to hair" 410 : 4895-4903, 2018

14 Fourie NH, "Sources of variation in hair cortisol in wild and captive non-human primates" 119 : 119-125, 2016

15 Trevisi E, "Some physiological and biochemical methods for acute and chronic stress evaluationin dairy cows" 8 : 265-286, 2009

16 Aerts J, "Scales tell a story on the stress history of fish" 10 : e0123411-, 2015

17 Weirup L, "Scale cortisol is positively correlated to fin injuries in rainbow trout(Oncorhynchus mykiss)reared in commercial flow through systems" 543 : 736924-, 2021

18 Kovács L, "Salivary cortisol as a non-invasive approach to assess stress in dystocic dairy calves" 11 : 6200-, 2021

19 Kretzschmar-McCluskey V, "Ross Technical Notes - a practical guide to managing feather cover in broiler breeder females"

20 Mohan NH, "Relationship between plasma, saliva, urinary and faecal cortisol levels in pigs" 90 : 768-772, 2020

21 Niu Z, "Recent advances in biological sample preparation methods coupled with chromatography, spectrometry and electrochemistry analysis techniques" 102 : 123-146, 2018

22 Freeman NE, "Quantifying corticosterone in feathers: validations for an emerging technique" 6 : coy051-, 2018

23 Choe SJ, "Psychological stress deteriorates skin barrier function by activating 11β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase 1 and the HPA axis" 8 : 6334-, 2018

24 Lennartsson AK, "Prolactin in response to acute psychosocial stress in healthy men and women" 36 : 1530-1539, 2011

25 Fernández-Peralbo MA, "Preparation of urine samples prior to targeted or untargeted metabolomics mass-spectrometry analysis" 41 : 75-85, 2012

26 Thau L, "Physiology, cortisol"

27 Romero LM, "Physiological stress in ecology : lessons from biomedical research" 19 : 249-255, 2004

28 Mohamed NA, "Physiological and ion changes of Nile tilapia(Oreochromis niloticus)under the effect of salinity stress" 19 : 100567-, 2021

29 Zannoni A, "Non-invasive assessment of fecal stress biomarkers in hunting dogs during exercise and at rest" 7 : 126-, 2020

30 Hughes HD, "Natural variations in the stress and acute phase responses of cattle" 20 : 888-896, 2014

31 Hosseindoust A, "Muscle antioxidant activity and meat quality are altered by supplementation of astaxanthin in broilers exposed to high temperature" 9 : 1032-, 2020

32 Elshal MF, "Multiplex bead array assays : performance evaluation and comparison of sensitivity to ELISA" 38 : 317-323, 2006

33 Palme R, "Monitoring stress hormone metabolites as a useful, non-invasive tool for welfare assessment in farm animals" 21 : 331-337, 2012

34 Chen Y, "Models and methods to investigate acute stress responses in cattle" 5 : 1268-1295, 2015

35 Meyer JS, "Minireview : Hair cortisol : a novel biomarker of hypothalamicpituitary-adrenocortical activity" 153 : 4120-4127, 2012

36 Higashi T, "Methods for determination of fingernail steroids by LC/MS/MS and differences in their contents between right and left hands" 109 : 60-65, 2016

37 박규현 ; GHASSEMINEJAD JALIL ; Mohammad Ataallahi, "Methodological validation of measuring Hanwoo hair cortisol concentration using bead beater and surgical scissors" 한국축산학회 61 (61): 41-46, 2019

38 SheriffMJ, "Measuring stress in wildlife : techniques for quantifying glucocorticoids" 166 : 869-887, 2011

39 Ghassemi Nejad J, "Measuring hair and blood cortisol in sheep and dairy cattle using RIA and ELISA assay : a comparison" 51 : 887-897, 2020

40 Palme R, "Measuring fecal steroids : guidelines for practical application" 1046 : 75-80, 2005

41 Herane-Vives A, "Measuring Earwax Cortisol Concentration using a non-stressful sampling method" 6 : e05124-, 2020

42 Inder WJ, "Measurement of salivary cortisol in 2012 – laboratory techniques and clinical indications" 77 : 645-651, 2012

43 Sauvé B, "Measurement of cortisol in human hair as a biomarker of systemic exposure" 30 : E183-91, 2007

44 Hudson JM, "Measurement of cortisol in blow samples collected from free-swimming beluga whales(Delphinapterus leucas)" 37 : 888-900, 2021

45 Ewert A, "Levels of nature and stress response" 8 : 49-, 2018

46 Pompa G, "Investigation of the origin of prednisolone in cow urine" 76 : 104-110, 2011

47 Gutiérrez J, "Investigating the role of prolactin as a potential biomarker of stress in castrated male domestic dogs" 9 : 676-, 2019

48 Cirimele V, "Identification of ten corticosteroids in human hair by liquid chromatography–ionspray mass spectrometry" 107 : 381-388, 2000

49 Phillips R, "Human nail cortisol as a retrospective biomarker of chronic stress : a systematic review" 123 : 104903-, 2021

50 Evans MR, "Heritability of corticosterone response and changes in life history traits during selection in the zebra finch" 19 : 343-352, 2006

51 Dubey DK, "Heat stress in dairy animals: causes, consequences and possible solutions"

52 Comin A, "Hair cortisol level as a retrospective marker of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis activity in horse foals" 194 : 131-132, 2012

53 Lutz CK, "Hair cortisol in captive corral-housed baboons" 302 : 113692-, 2021

54 Russell E, "Hair cortisol as a biological marker of chronic stress : current status, future directions and unanswered questions" 37 : 589-601, 2012

55 Burnard C, "Hair cortisol and its potential value as a physiological measure of stress response in human and non-human animals" 57 : 401-414, 2016

56 Erickson RL, "Hair corticosterone measurement in mouse models of type 1 and type 2 diabetes mellitus" 178 : 166-171, 2017

57 Fischer S, "Fingernail cortisol–state of research and future directions" 58 : 100855-, 2020

58 Ebinghaus A, "Fecal cortisol metabolites in dairy cows : a cross-sectional exploration of associations with animal, stockperson, and farm characteristics" 10 : 1787-, 2020

59 Carbajal A, "Feather corticosterone evaluated by ELISA in broilers : a potential tool to evaluate broiler welfare" 93 : 2884-2886, 2014

60 Meyer J, "Extraction and analysis of cortisol from human and monkey hair" 83 : e50882-, 2014

61 Burdett S., "Exploring the relationships between behavioural responses to stress and performance, carcass composition, energy expenditure and macronutrient oxidation in restrict fed female Yorkshire pigs" The University of Guelph 2019

62 Mormède P, "Exploration of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal function as a tool to evaluate animal welfare" 92 : 317-339, 2007

63 Nohara M, "Evaluation of response to restraint stress by salivary corticosterone levels in adult male mice" 78 : 775-780, 2016

64 Baier F, "Evaluation of hair characteristics and animal age on the impact of hair cortisol concentration in feedlot steers" 6 : 323-, 2019

65 Contreras ET, "Evaluation of hair and nail cortisol concentrations and associations with behavioral, physical, and environmental indicators of chronic stress in cats" 35 : 2662-2672, 2021

66 Allwin B, "Evaluation of endogenous faecal cortisol as a non invasive assessment of stress in free ranging wild pigs(Sus scrofa)" 44 : 89-92, 2015

67 ATAALLAHI MOHAMMAD ; 박근우 ; 김재철 ; 박규현, "Evaluation of Substitution of Meteorological Data from the Korea Meteorological Administration for Data from a Cattle Farm in Calculation of Temperature-Humidity Index" 한국기후변화학회 11 (11): 669-678, 2020

68 Won S, "Estimation of greenhouse gas emission from Hanwoo(Korean native cattle)manure management systems" 11 : 845-, 2020

69 Geun Woo Park ; Mohammad Ataallahi ; Seon Yong Ham ; Sejong OH ; 김기연 ; Kyu Hyun Park, "Estimating milk production losses by heat stress and its impacts on greenhouse gas emissions in Korean dairy farms" 한국축산학회 64 (64): 770-781, 2022

70 Herbut P, "Environmental parameters to assessing of heat stress in dairy cattle—a review" 62 : 2089-2097, 2018

71 Dhabhar FS, "Enhancing versus suppressive effects of stress on immune function : implications for immunoprotection and immunopathology" 16 : 300-317, 2009

72 Lattin CR, "Elevated corticosterone in feathers correlates with corticosterone-induced decreased feather quality : a validation study" 42 : 247-252, 2011

73 Trajchev M, "Efficiency of installed cooling systems in dairy barns during hot season" 71 : 38-45, 2017

74 Dong Gwon Yu ; Nyun Namgung ; 김종혁 ; Seung Yeon Won ; Won Jun Choi ; Dong Yong Kil, "Effects of stocking density and dietary vitamin C on performance, meat quality, intestinal permeability, and stress indicators in broiler chickens" 한국축산학회 63 (63): 815-826, 2021

75 West JW, "Effects of heat-stress on production in dairy cattle" 86 : 2131-2144, 2003

76 Victoria Sanz Fernandez M, "Effects of heat stress on carbohydrate and lipid metabolism in growing pigs" 3 : e12315-, 2015

77 Mohammad Ataallahi ; GHASSEMINEJAD JALIL ; Jun-Ik Song ; Jin-Soo Kim ; Kyu Hyun Park, "Effects of feather processing methods on quantity of extracted corticosterone in broiler chickens" 한국축산학회 62 (62): 884-892, 2020

78 Ataallahi M, "Effects of environmental changes during different seasons on hair cortisol concentration as a biomarker of chronic stress in Korean native cattle" 21 : 1166-1172, 2019

79 Byeonghyeon Kim ; Hye Ran Kim ; Ki Hyun Kim ; Sang Yun Ji ; Min Ji Kim ; Yoo Kyung Lee ; 이성대 ; Jin Young Jeong, "Effects of acute heat stress on salivary metabolites in growing pigs: an analysis using nuclear magnetic resonance-based metabolomics profiling" 한국축산학회 63 (63): 319-331, 2021

80 Fukasawa M, "Effect of lactation stage, season and parity on milk cortisol concentration in Holstein cows" 113 : 280-284, 2008

81 Hayashi H, "Effect of growth and parturition on hair cortisol in Holstein cattle" 92 : e13518-, 2021

82 Asano K, "Effect of climatic factors on urinary cortisol and peripheral blood leukocytes in lambs grazing on a semi-natural grassland in the Hokuriku district of Japan" 92 : e13536-, 2021

83 Shokry E, "Earwax metabolomics : an innovative pilot metabolic profiling study for assessing metabolic changes in ewes during periparturition period" 12 : e0183538-, 2017

84 Leng SX, "ELISA and multiplex technologies for cytokine measurement in inflammation and aging research" 63 : 879-884, 2008

85 Oh S, "Dietary fiber for gestating sows during heat stress: effects on reproductive performance and stress level"

86 Smrutirekha Mallick ; BS Bharath Kumar ; BS Prakash ; Anjali Aggrawal ; Sujata Pandita, "Development and validation of a simple, sensitive enzyme immunoassay for quantification of androstenedione in bull plasma" 한국축산학회 57 (57): 1-5, 2015

87 Smyth N., "Cortisol secretion in saliva and hair: methodological considerations and relationships with state and trait well-being" University of Westminster 2013

88 Gellrich K, "Cortisol levels in skimmed milk during the first 22 weeks of lactation and response to short-term metabolic stress and lameness in dairy cows" 6 : 31-, 2015

89 Carbajal Brossa A., "Cortisol in skin mucus and scales as a measure of fish stress and habitat quality" Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona 2018

90 Nedić S, "Cortisol concentrations in hair, blood and milk of Holstein and Busha cattle" 54 : 163-172, 2017

91 Braun U, "Cortisol concentration of regrown hair and hair from a previously unshorn area in dairy cows" 114 : 412-415, 2017

92 Bortolotti GR, "Corticosterone in feathers is a long-term, integrated measure of avian stress physiology" 22 : 494-500, 2008

93 Thaxton JP, "Corticosterone in commercial broilers" 14 : 745-749, 2005

94 Jenni-Eiermann S, "Corticosterone : effects on feather quality and deposition into feathers" 6 : 237-246, 2015

95 Weaver SJ, "Chronic elevation of plasma cortisol causes differential expression of predominating glucocorticoid in plasma, saliva, fecal, and wool matrices in sheep" 74 : 106503-, 2021

96 Trumble SJ, "Blue whale earplug reveals lifetime contaminant exposure and hormone profiles" 110 : 16922-16926, 2013

97 Dhama K, "Biomarkers in stress related diseases/disorders : diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic values" 6 : 91-, 2019

98 Hansen SH., "Bioanalysis of pharmaceuticals:sample preparation, separation techniques, and mass spectrometry" John Wiley & Sons 23-30, 2015

99 GHASSEMINEJAD JALIL ; 성경일, "Behavioral and physiological changes during heat stress in Corriedale ewes exposed to water deprivation" 한국축산학회 59 (59): 1-6, 2017

100 Lin TK, "Association between stress and the HPA axis in the atopic dermatitis" 18 : 2131-, 2017

101 García-Torres S, "Assessment of stress by serum biomarkers in calves and their relationship to ultimate pH as an indicator of meat quality" 11 : 2291-, 2021

102 Meyer JS, "Assessment of prenatal stress-related cortisol exposure : focus on cortisol accumulation in hair and nails" 63 : 409-436, 2021

103 Genther DJ, "Assessing systemic stress in otolaryngology : methodology and feasibility of hair and salivary cortisol testing" 1 : e152-, 2015

104 Davenport MD, "Analysis of endogenous cortisol concentrations in the hair of rhesus macaques" 147 : 255-261, 2006

105 Weimer SL, "An evaluation of methods for measuring stress in broiler chickens" 97 : 3381-3389, 2018

106 Takahashi A, "Aggression, social stress, and the immune system in humans and animal models" 12 : 56-, 2018

107 Azevedo A, "Age, sex and storage time influence hair cortisol levels in a wild mammal population" 14 : e0221124-, 2019

108 French D, "Advances in bioanalytical techniques to measure steroid hormones in serum" 8 : 1203-1219, 2016

109 Tothova C, "Acute phase proteins and their use in the diagnosis of diseases in ruminants : a review" 59 : 163-180, 2014

110 Koren L, "A novel method using hair for determining hormonal levels in wildlife" 63 : 403-406, 2002

111 Hirsch MS, "A comprehensive review of biomarker use in the gynecologic tract including differential diagnoses and diagnostic pitfalls" 27 : 164-192, 2020