세계유산 관점에서의 대순진리회 도장의 가치 = The Value of Daesoon Jinrihoe’s Temple Complexes from the Perspective of UNESCO World Heritage

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In the past, holy sites were mainly designated on a basis of archaeological norms and endowed with a specific fixed identity according to historical, religious, and contextual interpretations. However, approaches to these sites are more flexible in recent times. These locations transcend the boundaries of space and time to enable the experience of diverse transformation and reveal multiple religious identities which are embedded in the complex interaction between power and authority. In this regard, the dynamic meanings of the religious symbology of Daesoon Jinrihoe’s temple complexes, imagery, and the spatial structures enable us to grant them a new identity by re-establishing these structures as World Heritage sites. Temple complexes (dojang) correspond to the outstanding universal values identified by UNESCO in that the spiritual activities conducted at these holy sites draw the same attention as would be drawn by historical value. In this context, this study aims to explore the potential for Daesoon Jinrihoe’s temple complexes to be designated UNESCO world heritage sites. To carry out this study, existing religious heritage sites such as Mount Athos Monasteries in Greece and Lumbini in Nepal are examined as case studies, and the operational plan, conservation, protection of relics, and interaction with its neighboring community and tourists are likewise closely examined in this study.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

과거에 성지는 주로 고고학적 규범에 근거하여 호명되면서 종종 단일의 고정된 정체성을 부여받았으나 최근의 추세는 좀 더 포괄적으로 역사적, 맥락적 해석과 연동하여 유연하게 접근하고 있다. 성지는 시공간을 초월하여 다양한 변화를 경험해왔으며 권력과 권위의 복잡한 상호작용을 내재한 다층적인 종교정체성을 드러낸다. 이런 관점에서 대순진리회 도장의 종교적 상징과 이미지, 그리고 공간구조에 내포되어 있는 다층적인 의미는 세계유산이라는 새로운 정체성의 재정립을 가능하게 한다. 이 연구는 성지의 역사적 가치만큼이나 순례와 같은 영적 추구 행위가 동등하게 주목받고 있는 가운데, 유네스코 세계유산위원회가 지향하는 탁월한 인류의 보편적 가치를 통해 도장의 세계유산등재 가능성을 탐색한다. 이를 위해, 기존 종교유산의 사례로 그리스 아토스수도원공동체와 네팔 룸비니를 소개하고 종교유산이 어떤 방식으로 운영되고 있는지 고찰하며, 최종적으로는 도장의 문화유산으로서의 가치성을 실증적으로 검증한다.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 머리말
• Ⅱ. 세계유산 인증제도
• Ⅲ. 해외 종교문화유산 사례
• Ⅳ. 세계유산으로서 대순진리회 도장의 가능성
• Ⅴ. 맺음말 및 제언

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김진영, "증산 순례길 제언" 대순사상학술원 31 : 131-163, 2018

2 김문식, "왕실의 천지제사" 돌베개 2011

3 진정애, "대순진리회의 치성의례와 그 상징성에 대한 연구" 91 : 2009

4 대순종교문화연구소, "대순진리회의 성지 바로보기"

5 송하명, "대순진리회 창설과정" 200 : 2017

6 Mechtild Rossler, "World Heritage and Gender" 78 : 2016

7 Neil Siberman, "What is Heritage?" 2019

8 Stephen Bigger, "Victor Turner, liminality, and cultural performance" Informa UK Limited 30 (30): 209-212, 2009

9 Rene Gothoni, "Unity and Universe : Understanding Pilgrimage to Mount Athos"

10 Ishwari Khatri, "Tourism Destination Marketing: A Case Study of Lumbini Nepal" Nepal Journals Online (JOL) 9 : 69-82, 2018

11 D.F.M. Strauss, "The uniqueness of cultures, universality and normativity – with special reference to the normative meaning of differentiation" Koers Bulletin for Christian Scholarship 67 (67): 2002

12 R.A.E. Coningham, "The earliest Buddhist shrine: excavating the birthplace of the Buddha, Lumbini (Nepal)" Cambridge University Press (CUP) 87 (87): 1104-1123, 2013

13 T.N. Mishra, "The archaeological activities in Lumbini during 1984-85" Department of Archaeology 139 : 1996

14 Yahaya Ahmad, "The Scope and Definitions of Heritage : From Tangible to Intangible" 12 : 2006

15 Kai Weise, "The Sacred Garden of Lumbini-Perceptions of Buddha’s Birthplace" UNESCO 2013

16 H.W. Schumann, "The Historical Buddha-The Times, Life and Teachings of the Founder of Buddhism" Motilal Banarsidass Publishers Private Limited 2004

17 Robert Hewison, "The Heritage Industry : Britain in a Climate of Decline" Methuen Publishing Ltd 1987

18 David Brett, "The Construction of Heritage" Cork University Press 1996

19 Louis Luzbetak, "The Church and Cultures : New Perspectives in Missiological Antropology" Orbis Books 1988

20 "The Changing Global Religious Landscape" Pew Research Center

21 Raymond W.K. Lau, "Revisiting authenticity" Elsevier BV 37 (37): 478-498, 2010

22 Mihir Bhonsale, "Religious Tourism as Soft Power: Strengthening India’s Outreach to Southeast Asia" ORF 2019

23 Stuart Hall, "Re-imagining the Post-nation, in Cultural Heritage: Critical Concepts in Media and Cultural Studies 2" Routledge 1999

24 Peter Lang, "Pilgrims and Travellers in Search of the Holy" International Academic Publishers 2010

25 "Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention"

26 "Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention"

27 J. Kryzysztof Lenartowicz, "On Authenticity in Architecture in Terms of Posing Questions"

28 "Nepal Tourism Statistics"

29 "Nepal Tourism Board"

30 Thymio Papayannis, "Natural Heritage: At the Interface of Nature and Culture" Routledge 2007

31 Filareti Kotsi, "Mount Athos: development policies for short-term religious tourism" Inderscience Publishers 2 (2): 149-, 2012

32 "Mount Athos Greece"

33 Bernard M. Feilden, "Management Guidelines for World Cultural Heritage Sites"

34 Him Lal Ghimire, "Lumbini: A Touristic Overview, Lumbini: Present Status and Future Challenges" UNESCO 2006

35 Georgios Alexopoulos, "Living Religious Heritage and Challenges to Museum Ethics: Reflections from the Monastic Community of Mount Athos" Ubiquity Press, Ltd. 11 (11): 4-, 2013

36 Georgios Alexopoulos, "Living Religious Heritage and Challenges to Museum Ethics: Reflections from the Monastic Community of Mount Athos" Ubiquity Press, Ltd. 11 (11): 4-, 2013

37 M. D. Stringer, "Liturgy and Anthropology : The History of Relationship" 63 : 1989

38 Nataliya S. Semenova, "Legal Status of Mount Athos and Modern Challenges" 2019

39 David Ways, "Is Overtourism a Problem in Nepal?"

40 Jessica C. Lai, "International Trade in Indigenous Cultural Heritage: Legal and Policy Issues" Edward Elgar Publishing Limited 2012

41 Gary Edson, "Heritage: Pride or passion, product or service?" Informa UK Limited 10 (10): 333-348, 2004

42 David Lowenthal, "Heritage-Conservation, Interpretation and Enterprise" Donhead Publishing Ltd 1993

43 Konstantinos Andriotis, "Genres of heritage authenticity" Elsevier BV 38 (38): 1613-1633, 2011

44 L.V. Kapilevich, "Gender-based Restrictions in Tourism: An Example of the Phenomenon of Avaton in the Modern Socio-cultural Expanse" Elsevier BV 166 : 7-11, 2015

45 Georgios Alexopoulos, "Gender exclusion and local values versus universal cultural heritage significance : the Avaton debate on the monastic community of Mount Athos" 6 : 2016

46 "Gender Equality, Heritage and Creativity" UNESCO

47 Stephen Greenblatt, "Exhibiting Cultures: The Poetics and Politics of Museum Display" The Smithsonian Institution 1991

48 Robin Cunningham, "Cultural Heritage Protection and Community Engagement in South Asia" Springer Nature 2019

49 Gheorghe Zaman, "Cultural Heritage Entrepreneurship-Challenges and Difficulties" 188 : 2015

50 International Council on Monuments and Sites, "Conservation of Intangible Heritage"

51 Peter Caban, "A place where no woman has ever entered. The Unique Spiritual Heritage of the Athos Peninsula in the Context of History and Present Time" Pontifical University of John Paul II in Krakow 213 (213): 2017

52 Dileep Kumar S., "A Study on Ashoka’s Inscriptions with the Special Focus on Maski Rock Edict" 4 (4): 2015