임상유전학에서 자기 결정권 = A Study on Rights of Self-Decision in the Clinical Genetics

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

HGP(Human Genome Project) in a sense declares that the jurisdiction of human life belongs to human himself, not anymore to God. At the same time such a view also makes us face up to new problems that we must make a decision ourselves about our living. That is problems of ``right to know`` and ``right not to know``. So we take some considerations about the nature of right to know and right not to know firstly. And then we dispute the value conflict that is resulted from the argument between the principle of disclose and the principle of confidentiality. Finally we try to find a solution to the problem of overcoming the value conflict that is resulted from a discord of normative ethical maxims on the basis of categorical relations of right, which is an essential concept of modern political philosophy. It will be moral justification of rights of self-decision.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Berlin I., "Two Concepts of Liberty" Clarendon Press 1969

2 Wilson J, "To Know or not to Know? Genetic Ignorance, Autonomy and Paternalism" 15 (15): 492-504, 2005

3 Mill J. S., "Three Essays: On Liberty, Representative Government and The Subjection of Women" Oxford University Press 1975

4 Harris J., "The Value of Life" Routledge 1985

5 Brandeis L., "The Right to Privacy" 4 : 193-221, 1890

6 Chadwick R., "The Philosophy of the Right to Know and the Right not to Know, In The Right to Know and the Right not to Know" Aldershot, Brookfield 1997

7 Raz J., "The Morality of Freedom" Oxford University Press 1986

8 Aristoteles, "The Metaphysics" Prometheus Books 1991

9 Pörn I., "The Meaning of ‘Rights’ in the Right to Know Debate, In The Right to Know and the Right not to Know" Aldershot, Brookfield 1997

10 Chadwick R., "The Human Genome Project, Predictive Testing and Insurance Contracts: Ethical and Legal Responses" 1 (1): 115-129, 1995

11 Stone D. H., "Screening and the New Genetics: A Public Health Perspective on the Ethical Debate" 18 (18): 3-5, 1996

12 Simmonds N. E., "Rights at the Cutting Edge, In A Debate over Rights-Philosophical Enquiries" Clarendon Press 1998

13 Kielstein R., "Right not to Know or Duty to Know? Prenatal Screening for Polycystic Renal Disease" 17 : 395-405, 1992

14 Thomson J, "Précis of the Realm of Rights" 53 (53): 159-162, 1993

15 Flaherty D., "Protecting Privacy in Surveillance Societies" University of North Carolina Press 1989

16 Macklin R., "Privacy and Control of Genetic Information, In Gene Mapping" Oxford University Press 1992

17 Beauchamp T. L., "Principles of Biomedical Ethics" Oxford University Press 1994

18 Dworkin R., "Life’s Dominion" Harper Collins Publishers 1993

19 Brock D., "Life and Death" Cambridge University Press 1993

20 Harris J., "Ignorance, Information and Autonomy" 22 (22): 415-436, 2001

21 Bell D., "Genetic Secrets and the Family" 9 : 130-161, 2001

22 Nuffield Council on Bioethics, "Genetic Screening-Ethical Issues" Nuffield Council on Bioethics 1993

23 Rhodes R, "Genetic Links, Family Ties and Social Bonds: Rights and Responsibilities in the Face of Genetic Knowledge" 23 : 15-28, 1998

24 Takala T, "Genetic Ignorance and Reasonable Paternalism" 22 (22): 485-491, 2001

25 Ngwena C., "Genetic Diagnostic Information and the Duty of Confidentiality: Ethics and Law" (1) : 73-95, 1993

26 Hohfeld W. N., "Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning" GreenWood Press Publishers 1978

27 Royal College of Physicians, "Ethical Issues in Clinical Genetics" Royal College of Physicians 1991

28 Husted J., "Autonomy and a Right not to Know, In The Right to Know and the Right not to Know" Aldershot, Brookfield 1997

29 Stoljar S., "An Analysis of Rights" MacMillan 1985