인체 부분들의 존재론적 특성에 대한 철학적 고찰 = Philosophical Inquiry on Ontological Characters of Human Body Parts

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

It is uncontroversial that human body parts, including human material, are physical beings. However, they seem to be treated not just as physical objects but as those of a special kind. There seems to be some ontological characters of human body parts that explain why we tend to feel uncomfortable or unpleasant when those parts are treated in certain ways that will be introduced in this paper. This paper explores the ontological characters of human body parts by means of comparison with other physical beings that also cannot be explained by reductive materialism-that is, human beings and works of art. For this goal, I examine Dworkin’s discussion of the sanctity of human life-based on the concept of ‘creative investment’- and Margolis’ analysis of the ontology of artworks-based on the concept of ‘cultural emergence’. The insight that each of these can offer as well as the applicability of these to human body parts will be discussed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박재현, "인체표본 전시회와 시신활용의 윤리" 한국의료윤리학회 10 (10): 165-174, 2007

2 서원주, "예술 작품의 존재론적 특성과 예술 정의의 문제에 관한 고찰 : J. Margolis의 비환원적 유물론에 근거한 구현 논제를 중심으로" 서울大學校 大學院 1995

3 로널드 드워킨, "생명의 지배영역" 이화여자대학교 생명의료법연구소 226-228, 2008

4 권복규, "사체조직이식의 윤리적 문제점" 5 (5): 27-37, 2004

5 Jones G, "The human cadaver: an assessment of the value we place on the dead body. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith 1995"

6 Margolis J., "Philosophy of Psychology. Philosophy of Psychology" Prentice-Hall 58-, 1984

7 Margolis J, "Persons and minds : the prospects of nonreductive materialism" D. Reidel Pub. Co. 235-237, 1978

8 Allen AL, "No dignity in body worlds: a silent minority speaks" 7 (7): 24-25, 2007

9 Goodman N, "Languages of Art" Hackett 99-125, 1976

10 Campbell A, "Grant Gillet and Gareth Jones. Practical Medical Ethics" Oxford University Press 1992

11 Bunge M, "Emergence and the Mind" 2 (2): 501-509, 1977

12 Dewey J, "Art as Experience" Capricorn Books 169-222, 1934

13 Margolis J., "Art and Philosophy" Humanities Press 48-, 1978