사형 처벌의 의미 = What The Ultimate Punishment Means

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The pro and con of capital punishment has been hotly controversial in the discussion of legal philosophy. It seems no use in the discussion that pacifists are going to deny death penalty in the name of world peace, human rights, and civilized culture. It`s too emotional. As punishment theorists, utilitarians, either abolitionists or retentionists, are fictitious and factitious both in that they may not be factual in the factual sense and in that they may not be natural in the psychological sense. As opposed to utilitarians, retributionists, being natural as well as factual, are superior in that sense, but in that sense only, to say the least. They are almost helpless against the challenge of what is called (utilitarian) hybrids with some force. Therefore classical retributionism needs to be newly holistically remedied. Holistically extended retributionism demands that punishment as fair retribution to each offender should necessitate punishment with social benefit on the basis of the intimate link between punishment and society. We note that while retribution without social outcome would be empty, utility without retributive justice would be blind. We also note, more importantly, that either case cannot be possible nor desirable. It is time holistic retributionism for death punishment prevails.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 장석일, "생명 존중 인권의 가치 충돌 - 신중한 접근 필요"

2 이규태, "사형폐지 연합"

3 이규태, "사형폐지 법안"

4 이호중, "사형집행 재개, 무엇을 위한 것인가"

5 고준승, "사형제에 대한 단상"

6 윤종행, "사형제도와 인간의 존엄성" 법학연구원 13 (13): 79-95, 2003

7 김지은, "사형제는 또 다른 형태의 살인 - 폐지 마땅"

8 이경재, "사형제, 운영의 묘를"

9 고은태, "사형제 합헌결정은 생명권에 대한 침해"

10 김희진, "사형제 폐지 대세 - 한국의 선택은?"

11 이창영, "사형은 살인이다"

12 선우정, "사형에 대한 일본의 관점"

13 김철웅, "사형수"

14 송호창, "사형 부추기는 정부"

15 "법률신문사설, “사형제도 폐지보다는 정비를”"

16 "법률신문사설, "법무부장관, 사형집행 조속히 해야""

17 황필홍, "되갚는 정의로서의 사형제" 철학연구회 (72) : 243-271, 2006

18 "경향신문사설, “사형제 합헌 결정, 그러나 대세는 폐지다”"

19 "경향신문사설, "사형 보호감호제 - 정부 여당 시계는 거꾸로 가나""

20 필립 티에보, "‘사형제 폐지’는 세계적 흐름"

21 Bright, Stephen B, "Why the United States Will Join the Rest of the World in Abandoning Capital Punishment, In Debating the Death Penalty" Oxford University Press 152-182, 2004

22 Pojman, Louis P, "Why the Death Penalty Is Morally Permissible, In Debating the Death Penalty" Oxford University Press 51-75, 2004

23 Russell, Bertrand, "What I Believe" Routledge 2010

24 Marquis, Joshua K, "Truth and Consequences: The Penalty of Death, In Debating the Death Penalty" Oxford University Press 117-151, 2004

25 Kozinski, Alex, "Tinkering with Death, In Debating the Death Penalty" Oxford University Press 1-14, 2004

26 Ezra, Ovadia, "The Withdrawal of Rights: Rights from a Different Perspective" Kluwer Academic Publishers 2002

27 Goldman, Alan H, "The Paradox of Punishment, In Punishment" Princeton University Press 30-46, 1995

28 Hampton, Jean, "The Moral Education Theory of Punishment, In Punishment" Princeton University Press 112-142, 1995

29 Feinberg, Joel, "The Expressive Function of Punishment, In Philosophy of Law" Wadsworth 761-771, 2004

30 Rachels, James, "The Elements of Moral Philosophy, 6th ed" The McGraw-Hill Companies 2010

31 Zimmerman, Paul R, "The Economics of Capital Punishment and Deterrence, In Handbook on the Economics of Crime" Edward Elgar 381-431, 2010

32 Hook, Sidney, "The Death Sentence: Limited Use, In Life and Death: A Reader in Moral Problems" Wadsworth 389-390, 1999

33 van den Haag, Ernest, "The Death Penalty: Pro and Con, In Life and Death: A Reader in Moral Problems" Wadsworth 391-394, 2000

34 Hart, H.L.A, "The Concept of Law" Oxford University Press 1961

35 Blattberg, Charles, "Taking Politics Seriously - but Not Too Seriously" 1-10, 2010

36 van den Haag, Ernest, "Refuting Reiman and Nathanson, In Punishment" Princeton University Press 324-335, 1995

37 황필홍, "Punishment as Equality" 한국아메리카학회 38 (38): 37-72, 2006

38 Fletcher, George P, "Punishment and Responsibility, In A Companion to Philosophy of Law and Legal Theory" Blackwell Publishing 514-523, 2003

39 Hart, H.L.A, "Punishment and Responsibility" Oxford University Press 1968

40 Ralws, J, "Political Liberalism" Columbia University Press 1993

41 Tebbit, Mark, "Philosophy of Law: An Introduction" Routledge 2002

42 Morris, Herbert, "Persons and Punishment, In The Social Organization of Law: Introductory Readings" Oxford University Press 472-479, 2010

43 Bienen, Leigh Buchanan, "Murder and Its Consequences: Essays on Capital Punishment in America" Northwestern University Press 2010

44 Ezra, Ovadia, "Moral Dilemmas in Real Life: Current Issues in Applied Ethics" Springer 2010

45 "Mill's Speech before the British Parliament on April 21, 1868 in opposition to a Bill banning Capital Punishment proposed by Mr. Gilpin"

46 Clark, Michael, "Mill on Capital Punishment - Retributive Overtones?" The Johns Hopkins University Press 42 (42): 327-332, 2004

47 Murphy, Jeffrie G, "Marxism and Retribution, In Punishment" Princeton University Press 3-29, 1995

48 Reiman, Jeffrey H, "Justice, Civilization, and the Death Penalty: Answering van den Haag, In Punishment" Princeton University Press 274-307, 1995

49 Glossop, Ronald J, "Is Hume a "Classical Utilitarian"?" 2 (2): 1-16, 1976

50 Salmon, Merrilee H, "Introduction to Logic and Critical Thinking, 2nd ed" Harcourt Brace Jovanovich 1989

51 Walton, Douglas, "Informal Logic: A Pragmatic Approach, 2nd ed" Cambridge University 2008

52 Cassell, Paul G, "In Defense of the Death Penalty, In Debating the Death Penalty" Oxford University Press 183-217, 2004

53 Ryan, George, "I Must Act, In Debating the Death Penalty" Oxford University Press 218-234, 2004

54 Taylor, Charles, "Human Agency and Language: Philosophical Papers 2" Cambridge University Press 1990

55 Taylor, Charles, "Human Agency and Language: Philosophical Papers 1" Cambridge University Press 1990

56 Dahnke, Michael D, "Film, Art, and Filmart: An Introduction to Aesthetics Through Film" University Press of America 2007

57 Kant, Immanuel, "Ethical Philosophy" Hackett Publishing Company 1988

58 Hart, H.L.A, "Essays in Jurisprudence and Philosophy" Oxford University Press 1983

59 Nathanson, Stephen, "Does It Matter if the Death Penalty Is Arbitrarily Administered?, In Punishment" Princeton University Press 308-323, 1995

60 Jones, Sandra J, "Coalition Building in the Anti-Death Penalty Movement: Privileged Morality, Race Realities" Lexington Books 2010

61 Stevenson, Bryan, "Close to Death: Reflections on Race and Capital Punishment in America, In Debating the Death Penalty" Oxford University Press 76-116, 2004

62 Bedau, Hugo Adam, "Capital Punishment, In The Oxford Handbook of Practical Ethics" Oxford University Press 705-733, 2003

63 Munson, Ronald, "Basics of Reasoning" Wadsworth 2001

64 Bedau, Hugo Adam, "An Abolitionist's Survey of the Death Penalty in America Today, In Debating the Death Penalty" Oxford University Press 15-50, 2004

65 Rawls, J, "A Theory of Justice" Oxford University Press 1971

66 Morris, Herbert, "A Retributive Theory of Punishment, In Social and Political Philosophy: Contemporary Readings" Harcourt Brace & Company 853-860, 1999