The way to sustainability: education for sustainable development in China

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study explores what China’s central government has done in relation to education for sustainable development (ESD) and what Chinese higher education institutions (HEIs) have achieved in terms of ESD in response to SDG4. This is a qualitative case study focusing on China’s central government and Beijing Normal University (BNU). The main form of data analyzed was documents. In total, we collected 48 policy documents, six speech transcripts and work statements, and 167 news releases. The results show that ESD has not been implemented holistically in China. Educational sectors promoted ESD because sustainable development has been emphasized in the national political strategy. However, the specific meaning of sustainable development in the educational sector is unclear, and the implementation has not been systematic. Overall, more attention has been paid to the natural dimension of ESD than to the social dimension. At BNU, ESD activities are conducted through three mechanisms: a coercive mechanism, a professional mechanism, and a cultural mechanism. Health, culture, and environmental protection have received more attention than social equity.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Kuzich, S., "When policy and infrastructure provisions are exemplary but still insufficient: Paradoxes affecting education for sustainability (EfS) in a custom-designed sustainability school" 9 (9): 179-195, 2015

2 Ferreira, J, "Unsettling orthodoxies: Education for the environment/ for sustainability" 15 (15): 607-620, 2009

3 UNESCO, "UNESCO roadmap for implementing the global action programme on education for sustainable development" UNESCO 2014

4 United Nations, "Transforming our world: The 2030 agenda for sustainable development"

5 Li, C., "The sustainable development education and Chinese experiences" 55 (55): 73-82, 2018

6 Nicolaides, A., "The implementation of environmental management towards sustainable universities and education for sustainable development as an ethical imperative" 7 (7): 414-424, 2006

7 Qi, T, "The impact and transformation of education policy in China" Emerald Group Publishing 19-41, 2011

8 Nomura, K, "The education for sustainable development movement in Japan: A political perspective" 15 (15): 483-496, 2009

9 Stables, A, "The Quest for Holism in Education for Sustainable Development" 8 (8): 53-60, 2002

10 Hopkinson, P, "Sustainable graduates: Linking formal, informal and campus curricula to embed education for sustainable development in the student learning experience" 14 (14): 435-454, 2008

11 Abad-Segura, E., "Sustainable economic development in higher education institutions: A global analysis within the SDGs framework" 294 : 126133-, 2021

12 Cotton, D. R. E, "Sustainable development, higher education and pedagogy: A study of lecturers’ beliefs and attitudes" 13 (13): 579-597, 2007

13 Wang, J, "Sustainable Development at higher education in China: A comparative study of students’ perception in public and private universities" 12 (12): 2158-, 2020

14 Baughan, P., "Sustainability policy and sustainability in higher education curricula: The educational developer perspective" 20 (20): 319-332, 2015

15 "Strategy for invigorating China through science and education" China Keywords

16 Edin, M, "State capacity and local agent control in China: CCP cadre management from a township perspective" 173 : 35-52, 2003

17 Rauch, F, "School development through education for sustainable development in Austria" 12 (12): 115-127, 2006

18 Ball, S. J, "Politics and policy making in education: Explorations in sociology" Routledge 2012

19 Fowler, F. C, "Policy studies for educational leaders: An introduction" Merrill

20 Katayama, J, "Policy into practice on sustainable development related teaching in higher education in Turkey" 24 (24): 1017-1030, 2018

21 Cibulka, J. G., "Policy analysis and the study of the politics of education" 9 (9): 105-125, 1994

22 Li, P, "Outline of the ninth five-year plan (1996–2000) for National economic and social development and the long-range objectives to the year 2010"

23 CMOE, "Notice on the issuance of the guidelines for the implementation of environmental education in primary and secondary schools"

24 Asif, T, "Moral education for sustainable development: Comparison of university teachers’ perceptions in China and Pakistan" 12 (12): 3014-, 2020

25 Tilbury, D., "Monitoring and evaluation during the UN decade of education for sustainable development" 1 (1): 239-254, 2007

26 Alexander, L., "Issues and trends in Education for Sustainable Development" UNESCO Publishing 2018

27 Argento, D., "Integrating sustainability in higher education: A Swedish case" 21 (21): 1131-1150, 2020

28 Hayles, C. S., "INSPIRE sustainability internships: Promoting campus greening initiatives through student participation" 20 (20): 452-469, 2019

29 Yao, C., "How a blended learning environment in adult education promotes sustainable development in China" 58 (58): 480-502, 2018

30 Franco, I, "Higher education for sustainable development: Actioning the global goals in policy, curriculum and practice" 14 (14): 1621-1642, 2019

31 Sterling, S, "Higher education and ESD in England: A critical commentary on recent initiatives" 14 (14): 386-398, 2008

32 Bengtsson, S. L., "Hegemony and the politics of policy making for education for sustainable development: A case study of Vietnam" 47 (47): 77-90, 2016

33 Chan, B., "Harmony as the basis for education for sustainable development: A case example of Yew Chung International Schools" 41 (41): 35-48, 2009

34 Barth, M., "Handbook of Higher Education for Sustainable Development" Routledge 100-113, 2016

35 CMOE, "Guidelines for the education of excellent traditional Chinese culture"

36 Corbin, J., "Grounded theory research: Procedures, canons, and evaluative criteria" 13 (13): 3-21, 1990

37 Paletta, A., "Governing the university in the perspective of the United Nations 2030 Agenda: The case of the University of Bologna" 20 (20): 500-514, 2019

38 Weiss, M., "Global research landscape of sustainability curricula implementation in higher education" 20 (20): 570-589, 2019

39 UNESCO, "Global education monitoring report 2020: Inclusion and education‐All means all" UNESCO 2020

40 Savelyeva, T., "Global consciousness and pillars of sustainable development: A study on self-perceptions of the first-year university students" 18 (18): 218-241, 2017

41 Zhang, T, "From environment to sustainable development: China’s strategies for ESD in basic education" 56 (56): 329-341, 2010

42 Fiselier, E. S., "Exploring the current position of ESD in UK higher education institutions" 19 (19): 393-412, 2018

43 Zhou, D, "Explore the notion of education for sustainable development in early childhood education in China" 15 (15): 77-90, 2021

44 Qian, J., "Establishing transdisciplinary minor programme as a way to embed sustainable development into higher education system: Case by Tongji University, China" 20 (20): 157-169, 2019

45 Orr, D, "Environmental literacy: Education as if the earth mattered" Human Scale Education 1994

46 Læss⊘e, J, "Education for sustainable development, participation and socio-cultural change" 16 (16): 39-57, 2010

47 Blewitt, J., "Education for sustainable development, governmentality and learning to last" 11 (11): 173-185, 2005

48 McKeown, R., "Education for sustainable development toolkit environment and resources center" University of Tennessee Knoxville 2002

49 Summers, M, "Education for sustainable development in initial teacher training: Issues for interdisciplinary collaboration" 11 (11): 623-647, 2005

50 Saqib, Z. A., "Education for sustainable development in Pakistani higher education institutions: An exploratory study of students’ and teachers’ perceptions" 21 (21): 1249-1267, 2020

51 Luo, J. M., "Education for sustainable development in Hong Kong: A review of UNESCO Hong Kong’s experimental schools" 8-, 2018

52 Scott, W., "Education for sustainable development (ESD): A critical review of concept, potential and risk" Schooling for Sustainable Development in Europe 47-70, 2015

53 Hopkins, C., "Education and sustainability: Responding to the global challenge Vol. 4" ROSSEELS 2003

54 UNESCO, "Education 2030 framework for action" UNESCO 2015

55 Kovaleva, T. N., "Ecohumanistic education in Russia and China as a factor of sustainable development of modern civilization" 6 : 1-23, 2019

56 González-Gaudiano, E. J., "ESD: Power, politics, and policy: “Tragic optimism” from Latin America" 47 (47): 118-127, 2016

57 Martin, S, "Divergent evolution in education for sustainable development policy in the United Kingdom: Current status, best practice, and opportunities for the future" 5 (5): 1522-1544, 2013

58 Lozano, R., "Diffusion of sustainable development in universities’ curricula: An empirical example from CardiffUniversity" 18 (18): 637-644, 2010

59 Tan, H., "Development of green campus in China" 64 : 646-653, 2014

60 Yang, G., "Developing an instrument for identifying secondary teachers’ beliefs about education for sustainable development in China" 41 (41): 195-207, 2010

61 Mcmillin, J., "Developing a whole-of-university approach to educating for sustainability: Linking curriculum, research and sustainable campus operations" 3 (3): 55-64, 2009

62 CMOE, "Declaration for building sustainable development campus"

63 Ceulemans, G., "Challenges and benefits of student sustainability research projects in view of education for sustainability" 20 (20): 482-499, 2019

64 Cho, M., "Campus sustainability: An integrated model of college students’ recycling behavior on campus" 20 (20): 1042-1060, 2019

65 Yao, C., "An investigation of adult learners’ viewpoints to a blended learning environment in promoting sustainable development in China" 220 : 134-143, 2019

66 CMOE, "A speech at the Sustainable Development Campus Seminar"

67 Lozano, R., "A review of commitment and implementation of sustainable development in higher education: Results from a worldwide survey" 108 : 1-18, 2015

68 Yuan, X., "A critical assessment of the higher education for sustainable development from students’ perspectives – a Chinese study" 48 : 108-115, 2013

69 Lu, S., "A comparative study of education for sustainable development in one British university and one Chinese university" 15 (15): 48-62, 2013

70 Bamber, P, "A comparative review of policy and practice for education for sustainable development/education for global citizenship (ESD/ GC) in teacher education across the four nations of the UK" 30 (30): 112-120, 2016

71 "2019 Statistical Bulletin of the Communist Party of China" XINHUANET