토마스 모어의『유토피아』와 소설의 기원 담론: "허구성"을 중심으로 = Fictionality in Thomas More`s Utopia in the Context of "the Rise of the Novel"

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Thomas More`s Utopia, which was written in the sixteenth century and has long been regarded as the first utopian literature, surprisingly matches with Michael McKeon`s now classical account of the origins of the novel. As if anticipating the dialectical development of the novel that McKeon explains, Utopia presents Morus, a character and a portrait of the public self of More the author, as a figure that believes in the traditional truth and virtue in the beginning of Book 1 (“romance idealism” “aristocratic ideology”). On the other hand, Hythlodaeus, a fictional character who asserts the supremacy of Utopia and also the narrator of Book 2, represents “naive empiricism” and “progressive ideology,” the anthesis in McKeon`s scheme; he believes in his own experiences of Utopia as the ultimate authority of truth while claiming for the inconsistency of status. Lastly, Morus takes a synthetical position of being skeptical of Hythlodaeus`s Utopia and contemporary England at once (“extreme skepticism,” “conservative ideology”). Morus` ultimate take of “extreme skepticism,” which reflects the overall epistemology of Utopia, assumes the blurring of truth (or fact) and fiction (or lie) as McKeon explains. Indeed fictionality is a key concept in Utopia and the novel genre at once. As Louis Marin argues, fictionality in Utopia is the core of utopian representation and also utopian practice since it is fictionality itself which enables the political message like the abolition of private property to be represented. According to Marin, the irreconcilable contradiction of reality, the starting point of utopian literature, can be negotiated and neutralized only in the space of fiction. Yet the fictionality of Utopia is a peculiar kind of fictionality in which a certain opposition or contradiction in reality is negotiated and neutralized, and which excludes a fantastic or escapist imagination as we see in e.g. romance. And this kind of fictionality is exactly what the genre of the novel pursues and embodies in the form of “realism” in its emerging period. Just as Utopia addresses the political through a peculiar kind of fictionality, the novel could be the leading genre of modernity with its specific kind of fictionality, i.e. realism. That said, we should remember the meaningful difference in the way of representation in utopian literature and the novel. While the novel takes “verisimilitude”, a similar rendition of reality/truth, as the principle of representation, utopian literature addresses reality only as a “missing term” which exists only inversely in the text.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이혜수, "초기소설사 연구 18세기 국외 연구동향" 영미문학연구회 (24) : 220-237, 2008

2 제임슨, 프레드릭, "유토피아의 정치학, In 뉴레프트 리뷰 2" 길 352-377, 2009

3 이혜수, "뉴 아틀란티스』와『로빈슨 크루소』에 나타난 신대륙에 대한 상상력: 식민주의와 유토피아 사용법" 한국18세기영문학회 10 (10): 37-68, 2013

4 Frye, Nortrhop, "Varieties of Literary Utopias, In Utopias and Utopian Thought" Houghton Mifflin 25-49, 1966

5 Mezciems, Jenny, "Utopia and ‘The Things which is not’: More, Swift, and Other Lying Idealists" 52 : 40-62, 1982

6 Davis, J. C., "Utopia and the Ideal Society : A Study of English Utopian Writing, 1516-1700" Cambridge UP 1981

7 More, Thomas, "Utopia" Norton 1992

8 Marin, Louis, "Toward a Semiotic of Utopia: Political and Fictional Discourse in Thomas More's Utopia, In Structure, Consciousness, and History" Cambridge UP 261-282, 1978

9 Bruce, Susan, "Three Early Modern Utopias" Oxford UP 2009

10 McKeon, Michael, "Theory of the Novel: A Historical Approach" Johns Hopkins UP 2000

11 Elliot, Robert C., "The Shape of Utopia : Studies in a Literary Genre" U of Chicago P 1970

12 Watt, Ian, "The Rise of the Novel : Studies in Defoe, Richardson, and Fielding" U of California P 2000

13 McKeon, Michael, "The Origins of the English Novel, 1600-1740" Johns Hopkins UP 1987

14 Greenblatt, Stephen, "Renaissance Self-Fashioning from More to Shakespeare" U of Chicago P 1980

15 Jameson, Fredric, "Of Islands and Trenches: Neutralization and the Production Utopian Discourse, In The Ideologies of Theory II: The Syntax of History" U of Minnesota P 75-101, 1988

16 McCutcheon, Elizabeth, "Litotes: Denying the Contrary" 31-32 : 116-121, 1971

17 Mannheim, Karl, "Ideology and Utopia : An Introduction to the Sociology of Knowledge" Harcourt Brace Jovanovich 1985

18 James, Louis, "From Robinson to Robina, and Beyond: Robinson Crusoe as a Utopian Concept, In Utopias and the Millennium" Reaktion Book 33-45, 1993

19 Hunter, Paul, "Before Novels : The Cultural Contexts of the Eighteenth-Century English Fiction" Norton 1990

20 Traugott, John, "A Voyage to Nowhere with Thomas More and Jonathan Swift: Utopia and The Voyage to the Houyhnhnms" 69 : 534-565, 1961

21 Lewis. C. S., "A Jolly Invention, In Utopia" Norton 1992