대학생의 도덕 양심, 도덕 판단과 정치 성향의 관계 = The relationship between moral conscience, moral judgment, and political views

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Moral judgment is often driven by moral conscience. Namely, moral conscience is an inner moral value which plays a substantial role in moral judgment. Additionally, individuals demonstrate social and cultural moral values through their political views. The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between moral conscience, moral judgment, and political views. A total of 428 university students (154 men and 274 women) participated in this study. The findings indicated that there was a significant positive correlation between moral conscience and moral judgment. Moral conscience was influenced by political views (liberal and conservative). Liberal groups showed significantly higher mean scores in moral conscience and moral judgment than conservative groups. A difference in gender was evident as women had significantly higher scores than men in moral conscience. This suggests that moral judgments are indeed produced by moral conscience. These findings help illuminate the nature and intractability of moral conscience and moral judgment through political views. In addition, moral conscience should be recognized as an important mechanism of moral judgment in moral and civil education.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이명곤, "토마스 아퀴나스의 양심과 도덕적 의식에 대한 고찰 ―‘synderesis’와 ‘conscientia’의 개념규정과 한글 번역에 관하여―" 인간학연구소 (25) : 99-144, 2013

2 이정일, "토마스 아퀴나스, 헤겔, 그리고 칸트에 있어서 양심" 한국중세철학회 (8) : 2002

3 백춘현, "아펠 양심론의 담론적 성격과 도덕교육적 의의" 한국윤리교육학회 (25) : 111-128, 2011

4 신동준, "순자론" 인간사랑 2007

5 천병돈 역, "맹자의 철학" 예문서원 2000

6 조현규, "동양 교육사상" 학지사 2009

7 양대종, "도덕적 양심의 기원에 대한 고찰" 한국니체학회 (23) : 179-210, 2013

8 정창우, "도덕교육의 새로운 해법" 교육과학사 2020

9 Robinson, M., "What Is Freedom Of Conscience?" 87 (87): 33-44, 2018

10 Skitka, L. J., "The psychology of moral conviction" 4 (4): 267-281, 2010

11 Westen, D., "The political brain" Public Affairs 2007

12 Curry, O. S., "The evolution of morality" Springer 27-51, 2016

13 Haidt, J., "The emotional dog and its rational tail : A social intuitionist approach to moral judgment" 108 : 814-834, 2001

14 Shweder, R. A., "The emergence of morality in young children" University of Chicago Press 1-83, 1987

15 Turiel, E., "The culture of morality" Cambridge University Press 2002

16 Purzycki, "The cognitive and cultural foundations of moral behavior" 39 : 490-501, 2018

17 Voland, E., "The biological evolution of conscience-fromparent-offspring conflict to morality" 77 (77): 251-271, 2014

18 Stenner, K., "The authoritarian dynamic" Cambridge University Press 2005

19 Dawkins, R., "The God Delusion" Bantam Press 2006

20 MacCann, S. J. H., "Societal threat, authoritarianism, conservatism and U. S. state death penalty sentencing(1977-c2004)" 94 : 985-1014, 2008

21 Rawls, J., "Political liberalism" Columbia University Press 1993

22 Dellantonio, S., "Philosophy and Cognitive Science" SAPERE 239-262, 2012

23 May, L., "On Conscience" 20 : 57-67, 1983

24 DeScioli. P., "Mysteries of morality" 112 (112): 281-299, 2009

25 Graham, J., "Liberal and conservatives rely on different sets of moral foundations" 96 (96): 1029-1046, 2009

26 Habermas, J., "Justification and applicatiion" MIT Press 1993

27 Haidt, J., "Intuitive ethics : How innately prepared intuitions generate culturally variable virtues" 133 (133): 55-66, 2004

28 Jost, J. T., "Ideology; Its resurgence in social, personality, and political psychology" 3 : 707-721, 2008

29 Kinder, D. E., "Handbook of social psychology( Vol.2)" Mcgraw-Hill 778-867, 1998

30 Nietzsche, F., "Ethics" Oxford University Press 1994

31 Dahlqvist, V., "Development of the perceptions of conscience questionnaire" 4 (4): 182-193, 2007

32 Rachels, J., "Created from animals: the moral implications of Darwinism" Oxford University Press 1990

33 Janoff-Bulman, R., "Conscience: The do’s and don’ts of moral regulation" 2010

34 Giubilini, A., "Conscience" Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosopy