Comparing the Arrangements of Governance and Sustainable Development in OECD Countries: Coupled or Decoupled?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study attempts to analyze to what extent governance and sustainable development (SD) empirically appear compatible in the thirtyfive OECD countries through the fuzzy-set ideal type analysis, and identify which ideal types appear coupled or decoupled, and then reveal which countries belong to the coupled types or to the decoupled types. In short, twenty-two countries (including Sweden (fuzzy score, 0.953), Denmark (0.920), Finland (0.914), Norway (0.911) in Type 1 (G*S, ‘strong G-S coupled countries’); and Turkey (0.906), Greece (0.833), Mexico (0.828) in Type 4 (g*s, ‘lite g-s coupled countries’) are in line with the accepted conventions regarding the compatible relationship between governance and SD. On the other hand, the rest of thirteen countries (including USA (fuzzy score, 0.815), Luxembourg (0.721), Australia (0.660) in Type 2 (G*s, ‘G-s decoupled countries’); and Slovenia (0.728), France (0.644), Czech Rep. (0.625) in Type 3 (g*S, ‘g-S decoupled countries’) may indicate that the relationship of governance and SD is in fact experiencing tensions in the national contexts. These findings are characterized by the substance (of SD) and procedure (of governance) divide. Considering the results, this study focuses on the idea of reflexivity or reflexive capacity.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최영준, "사회과학에서 퍼지셋 활용의 모색: 퍼지 이상형 분석과 결합 요인 분석을 중심으로" 정부학연구소 15 (15): 307-336, 2009

2 양재진, "복지국가의 저발전에 관한 실증 연구: 제도주의적 신권력자원론의 타당성 검토" 한국정치학회 46 (46): 79-97, 2012

3 이도형, "발전행정론의재구성을위한시론:현대 발전이론의 이론적 시사점과 발전전략적 함의를 중심으로" 한국행정학회 36 (36): 43-63, 2002

4 Jung, G. H, "What is green governance" 31 : 23-37, 2002

5 Kvist, J, "Welfare reform in the Nordic countries in the 1990s : Using fuzzy-set theory to assess conformity to ideal types" 9 (9): 231-252, 1999

6 Glasbergen, P, "Understanding partnerships for sustainable development analytically:The ladder of partnership activity as a methodological tool" 21 (21): 1-13, 2010

7 Rhodes, R. A. W, "Understanding governance: Ten years on" 28 (28): 1243-1264, 2007

8 Benn S, "Towards new forms of governance for issues of sustainability:Renewing relationships between corporates, government, and community" 9 (9): 1-9, 2005

9 허태욱, "Towards Reflexive Governance for Sustainable Development" 서울대학교행정대학원 25 (25): 1-22, 2010

10 Bambra, C, "The worlds of welfare: Illusory and gender blind" 3 (3): 201-211, 2004

11 Voß, J. -P, "The politics of reflexive governance : Challenges for designing adaptive management and transition management" 16 (16): 9-, 2011

12 Jessop, B, "The new politics of local governance in Britain" Oxford University Press 11-32, 2000

13 Jordan, A, "The governance of sustainable development: Taking stock and looking forwards" 26 (26): 17-33, 2008

14 Bell, S, "Sustainable development indicators: The tyranny of methodology revisited" 6 (6): 222-239, 2011

15 Hezri, A, "Sustainability indicators, policy and governance: Issues for ecological economics" 60 (60): 86-99, 2006

16 Waas, T, "Sustainability assessment and indicators: Tools in a decision-making strategy for sustainable development" 6 (6): 5512-5534, 2014

17 Robinson, J, "Squaring the circle? Some thoughts on the idea of sustainable development" 48 (48): 369-384, 2004

18 Bertelsmann Stiftung, "SGI 2017 Scores" Bertelsmann Stiftung 2017

19 Sachs, J, "SDG Index and dashboards report 2017: Global responsibilities" Bertelsmann Stiftung and Sustainable Development Solutions Network 2017

20 Pierre, J, "Reinventing governance" 37 (37): 591-609, 2009

21 Voß, J. -P, "Reflexive governance for sustainable development" Edward Elgar 2006

22 Ragin, C. C, "Redesigning social inquiry: Fuzzy sets and beyond" University of Chicago Press 2008

23 Rihoux, B, "Qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) and related systematic comparative methods: Recent advances and remaining challenges for social science research" 21 (21): 679-706, 2006

24 Rawls, J, "Political liberalism" Columbia University Press 1993

25 Bertelsmann Stiftung, "Policy performance and governance capacities in the OECD and EU: Sustainable governance indicators 2017" Bertelsmann Stiftung 2017

26 Hyden, G, "Operationalizing governance for sustainable development" 17 (17): 13-31, 2001

27 석재은, "OECD 복지국가 지속가능성의 다차원적 평가와 지속가능 유형별 복지정책의 특성" 한국보건사회연구원 34 (34): 5-35, 2014

28 Sørensen, E, "Network governance and post-liberal democracy" 27 (27): 197-237, 2005

29 Li, G, "Multi-attribute decision making with generalized fuzzy numbers" 66 (66): 1793-1803, 2015

30 Treib O, "Modes of governance : A note towards conceptual clarification" 14 (14): 1-20, 2005

31 Dodson, M, "Mining, minerals and sustainable development" 2002

32 Lafferty, W. M, "Implementing Sustainable Development" Oxford University 2000

33 Goodin, R. E, "Green political theory" Polity 1992

34 Dean, M, "Governmentality: Power and rule in modern society" Sage 1999

35 Tosun, J, "Governing the interlinkages between the sustainable development goals : Approaches to attain policy integration" 1 (1): 1700036-, 2017

36 Weale, A, "Governing sustainability" Cambridge University Press 2009

37 Kooiman, J, "Governing as governance" Sage 2003

38 Bleischwitz, R, "Governance of sustainable development: Co-evolution of corporate and political strategies" 7 (7): 27-43, 2004

39 Lafferty, W. M, "Governance for sustainable development: The challenge of adapting form to function" Edward Elgar 2004

40 Dodson, M, "Governance for sustainable development: Strategic issues and principles for Indigenous Australian communities" Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research 2003

41 Zeijl‐Rozema, A, "Governance for sustainable development: A framework" 16 (16): 410-421, 2008

42 UNDESA, "Governance and development: Thematic think piece" UN System Task Team on the post-2015 UN Development Agenda 2012

43 Stojanović, I, "Good governance as a tool of sustainable development" 5 (5): 558-557, 2016

44 Gough, I, "Globalization and regional welfare regimes: The East Asian case" 1 (1): 163-189, 2001

45 Katz, H, "Global Civil Society 2006/7" SAGE 2006

46 Ragin, C. C, "Fuzzy-set social science" University of Chicago Press 2000

47 Kvist, J, "Fuzzy set ideal type analysis" 60 (60): 474-481, 2007

48 Farrell, K. N, "From *for*to governance for sustainable development in Europe: What is at stake for further research" 8 (8): 127-150, 2005

49 Hass, P. M, "Emerging forces in environmental governance" United Nations University Press 2004

50 Scharpf, F, "Disaffected democracies: What’s troubling the trilateral countries" Princeton University Press 2000

51 Barnes, M, "Designing citizen-centred governance" Joseph Rowntree Foundation 2008

52 Ragin, C. C, "Democratization and political culture in comparative perspective: Festschrift für Dirk Berg-Schlosser" Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften 2005

53 March, J. G, "Democratic governance" Free Press 1995

54 Sharma, S. D, "Democracy, good governance, and economic development" 3 (3): 29-62, 2007

55 Doherty, B, "Democracy and green political thought" Routledge 1996

56 Bell, S, "Delivering sustainability therapy in sustainable development projects" 75 (75): 37-51, 2005

57 Dryzek, J, "Deliberative democracy and beyond: Liberals, critics, contestations" Oxford University Press 2000

58 Kooiman, J, "Debating governance: Authority, steering, and democracy" Oxford University Press 2000

59 Klijn, E. H, "Complexity in governance network theory" 1 (1): 61-70, 2014

60 Schneider, C. Q, "Case studies nested in fuzzy-set QCA on sufficiency:Formalizing case selection and causal inference" 45 (45): 526-568, 2016

61 Boström, M, "A reflexive look at reflexivity in environmental sociology" 3 (3): 6-16, 2017