사법권한 배분의 기준과 모델 = Standards and Models on the Allocation of Judicial Power

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The Constitutional Court, like ordinary courts, exercises judicial power. Concerning how to allocate judicial powers between the Constitutional Court and ordinary courts, two standards of allocation might be suggested: one is that based upon principle, the other, upon policy. Issues particular to constitutional adjudication should be left to the Constitutional Court With regard to particularity, dichotomy that divides constitutional issues from sub-constitutional issues cannot be intact sustained. Issues arising from conflicts between democracy and constitutionalism can be properly handled by the Constitutional Court. Individual control over ordinary and administrative power can be properly exercised by ordinary courts. However, institutional control over political power should be left to the Constitutional Court. Two models of allocation might be conjured up. One is horizontal division model, the other, vertical coordination model. Although each model has its own strong and weak points, the latter seems better alternative in three aspects. The function of the Constitutional Court and ordinary courts resemble; Watershed to divide tasks of the both judiciaries is not easy to find; Organizational and human resources abound in ordinary courts can be made use of while supplementary character of the constitutional adjudication sustained.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 장영수, "헌법학, 제6판" 홍문사 2011

2 홍성방, "헌법학(하)" 박영사 2010

3 성낙인, "헌법학 제11판(개정판)" 법문사 2011

4 성낙인, "헌법학" 2011

5 최희수, "헌법재판의 본질과 헌법재판소의 헌법상 편제 - 헌법개정 논의에 부쳐 -" 한국비교공법학회 9 (9): 161-187, 2008

6 박승호, "헌법재판의 본질, In 헌법재판연구(Ⅰ)" 경인문화사 1998

7 헌법재판소, "헌법재판실무제요(제1개정증보판)" 2008

8 계희열, "헌법재판과 국가기능" 헌법재판소 1998

9 정태호, "헌법소원의 개념과 역사적 발전" 4 : 1996

10 허영, "헌법소송법론" 박영사 2010

11 정종섭, "헌법소송법" 박영사 2008

12 이동훈, "헌법강의론" 동방문화사 2009

13 전광석, "한국헌법론 제7판" 집현재 2011

14 김하열, "법률해석과 헌법재판:법원의 규범통제와 헌법재판소의 법률해석" 한국법학원 108 : 5-53, 2008

15 이준일, "대법원과 헌법재판소의 합리적 권한분배" 법학연구원 (48) : 179-201, 2007

16 Ernst Benda, "Verfassungsprozeßrecht, 2.Aufl" 2000

17 Hartmut Maurer, "StaatsrechtⅠ, 4.Aufl" 2005

18 Robert Walter, "Gabriele Kucsko-Stadlmayer, Grundriss des österreichischen Bundesverfassungsrechts"

19 Klaus Schlaich, "Das Bundesverfassungsgericht, 7.Aufl" 2007