Teaching to Listen, Question, and Ponder: An Investigation into Promoting an Enquiring Atmosphere in a Mathematics Classroom

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study reports on a classroom-based intervention that lasted eight lessons with the particular focus of exploring whether and how specific activities, strategies, and questions may promote an enquiring atmosphere in a mathematics classroom, i.e., a classroom environment in which stu-dents feel safe to investigate new mathematical ideas in order to produce, share, and test their conjectures in search for a proof. Although many researchers agree on the central role that conjec-tures and proofs should play in all students’ mathematical experiences, many students find it dif-ficult to engage with conjecturing and proving. In this paper we argue that the classroom atmos-phere has a crucial influence in helping students to overcome these difficulties and we focus our investigation on an English secondary mathematics classroom taught by the first author. Stu-dents’ responses to questionnaires, prompts, tasks, and interview questions were analysed in order to evaluate the impact of the intervention. The analysis suggests that specific activities, strategies, and questions can be used by teachers to facilitate an enquiring classroom atmosphere. However, for these to be effective, the teacher needs to explicitly teach students how to listen, question, and ponder in order to give students the tools to formulate conjectures and proofs.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Zack, V., "‘You have to prove us wrong’: proof at elementary school level" University of Helsinki 4 : 291-298, 1997

2 Claxton, G., "Wise up: the challenge of lifelong learning" Bloomsbury 1999

3 Perks, P., "Why don’t they prove?" 24 (24): 43-45, 1995

4 Rav, Y., "Why do we prove theorems?" 7 (7): 5-41, 1999

5 Lampert, M., "When the problem is not the question and the solution is not the answer: Mathematical knowing and teaching" 27 (27): 29-63, 1990

6 Elliott, J., "What is action-research in schools" 10 : 355-357, 1978

7 Schoenfeld, A. H., "What do we know about mathematics curricula?" 13 (13): 55-80, 1994

8 Rowe, M. B., "Wait time and rewards as instructional variables, their influence on language, logic and fate control" 11 (11): 81-94, 1974

9 Morselli, F., "Use of examples in conjecturing and proving: an explanatory study" 4 : 185-192, 2006

10 Stylianides, A. J., "Understanding and describing mathematical knowledge for teaching: Knowledge about proof for engaging students in the activity of proving" 11 : 307-332, 2008

11 Mason, J., "Thinking mathematically" Addison Wesley 1982

12 Reid, D.A., "The meaning of proof in mathematics education" 458-468, 2005

13 Smith, J., "The lazy teacher’s handbook" Crown House 2010

14 Denscombe, M., "The good research guide for small-scale social research projects" Oxford University Press 2010

15 Kramarski, B., "The challenge of self-regulated learning in mathematics teachers’ professional training" 72 (72): 379-399, 2009

16 Ainley, J., "Telling questions" 118 : 24-26, 1987

17 Lampert, M., "Teaching problems and the problem of teaching" Yale University Press 2001

18 Love, E., "Teaching mathematics: Action and awareness" The Open University 1992

19 Knuth, E. J., "Teachers’ conceptions of proof in the context of secondary school mathematics" 5 : 61-88, 2002

20 Martino, A. M., "Teacher questioning to promote justification and generalization in mathematics: what research practice has taught us" 18 (18): 53-78, 1999

21 Yackel, E., "Sociomathematical norms, argumentation, and autonomy in mathematics" 27 (27): 458-477, 1996

22 Boekaerts, M., "Self-regulated learning: A new concept embraced by researchers, policy makers, educators, teachers, and students" 7 (7): 161-186, 1997

23 Knuth, E. J., "Secondary school mathematics teachers' conceptions of proof" 33 (33): 379-405, 2002

24 Harel, G., "Second Handbook of Research on Mathematics Teaching and Learning" Information Age Publishing 805-842, 2007

25 Brown, L., "Same/different: A ‘natural’ way of learning mathematics" 2 : 153-160, 2000

26 Harel, G., "Research on Collegiate Mathematics Education (vol. 3)" AMS 234-283, 1998

27 Cohen, H., "Research methods in education" Routledge 2011

28 Watson, A., "Questions and prompts for mathematical thinking" ATM 1998

29 Hersh, R., "Proving is convincing and explaining" 24 (24): 389-399, 1993

30 Stylianides, A. J., "Proving in the elementary mathematics classroom" Oxford University Press 2016

31 Reid, D. A, "Proofs in mathematics education: Research, learning and teaching" Sense 2010

32 Lakatos, I., "Proofs and refutations: The logic of mathematical discovery" Cambridge University Press 1976

33 Coe, R., "Proof practices and constructs of advanced mathematics students" 20 : 41-53, 1994

34 Martin, W. G., "Proof frames of preservice elementary teachers" 20 (20): 41-51, 1989

35 Stylianides, A. J., "Proof constructions and evaluations" 72 : 237-253, 2009

36 Stylianides, A. J., "Proof and proving in school mathematics" 38 (38): 289-321, 2007

37 Bagnato, J. S., "Promoting Executive Function in the Classroom" The Guilford Press 160-174, 2010

38 NCTM, "Principles and standards for school mathematics" NCTM 2000

39 Gabriel J. Stylianides, "Posing New Researchable Questions as a Dynamic Process in Educational Research" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 18 (18): 83-98, 2020

40 DfES, "Pedagogy and practice: Teaching and learning in the secondary school unit 7: Questioning" HMSO 2004

41 Stein, M. K., "Orchestrating productive mathematical discussions: Five practices for helping teachers move beyond show and tell" 10 (10): 313-340, 2008

42 Amit, M., "Multiple representations in 8th grade algebra lessons: are learners really getting it?" 2 : 57-64, 2005

43 Mathematical Association, "Maths talk" Stanley Thornes 1992

44 Department for Education, "Mathematics: Programmes of study: Key Stages 1–2 (National Curriculum in England)"

45 National Curriculum in England, "Mathematics programmes of study: key stage 3" Department for Education

46 Hodgen, J., "Mathematics inside the black box" Department of Education and Professional Studies, King’s College 2006

47 Polya, G., "Mathematics and plausible reasoning" Princeton University Press 1954

48 Schoenfeld, A. H., "Mathematical problem solving" Academic Press 1985

49 Bills, L., "Making Meaning in Mathematics: Visions of mathematics 2 (vol. 1)" QED Press 103-116, 1999

50 Polya, G., "Let us teach guessing (video)" Mathematical Association of America

51 Mason, J., "Learning and doing mathematics" QED 1999

52 Sfard, A., "Learning Mathematics through Conversation; Is it as Good as they say?" 18 (18): 41-51, 1998

53 Fischbein, E., "Intuition in science and mathematics: An educational approach" Reidel 1987

54 Ollerton, M., "Inclusive Mathematics 11-18" Continuum 2001

55 Shilling-Traina, L. N., "Impacting prospective teachers’ beliefs about mathematics" 45 : 393-407, 2013

56 Mason, J., "Generic examples: Seeing the general in the particular" 15 (15): 277-290, 1984

57 Gilderdale, C., "Generating curiosity in mathematics learning"

58 Zazkis, R., "Generalization of patterns: The tension between algebraic thinking and algebraic notation" 49 (49): 379-340, 2002

59 Mason, J., "Fundamental constructs in mathematics education" Routledge Falmer 2004

60 Stylianides, G. J., "Facilitating the transition from empirical arguments to proof" 40 (40): 314-352, 2009

61 Mercer, N., "Exploring talk in School: Inspired by the work of Douglas Barnes" Sage 55-72, 2008

62 Mason, J., "Encyclopedia of Mathematics Education" Springer Netherlands 513-519, 2014

63 Bieda, K. N., "Enacting Proof-Related Tasks in Middle School Mathematics: Challenges and Opportunities" 41 (41): 351-382, 2010

64 Lampert, M., "Effective and Responsible Teaching: The New Synthesis" Jossey-Bass 295-314, 1992

65 Cobb, P., "Education and Mind: Institutional, Social, and Developmental Processes" Oxford University Press 91-115, 1993

66 Alcock, L., "Doctoral students’ use of examples in evaluating and proving conjectures" 69 : 111-129, 2008

67 Johnston-Wilder, S., "Developing thinking in geometry" The Open University PCP 2005

68 Mason, J., "Designing and using mathematical tasks" QED Press 2006

69 Mason, J, "Convincing myself and others" 177 : 31-36, 2001

70 Ball, D. L., "Constructivism in education: Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of Education" University of Chicago Press 193-224, 2000

71 Reid, D. A., "Conjecture and refutations in grade 5 Mathematics" 33 (33): 5-29, 2002

72 Stylianides, G. J., "Compendium for research in mathematics education" National Council of Teachers of Mathematics 237-266, 2017

73 National Governors Association Center for Best Practices & Council of Chief State School Officers, "Common core state standards for mathematics" National Governors Association Center for Best Practices & Council of Chief State School Officers 2010

74 Black, P., "Assessment for Learning: Putting it into practice" Open University Press 2003

75 Mason, J., "Aspects of teaching secondary mathematics" Routledge Falmer 105-120, 2002

76 Mason, J., "Aspects of teaching secondary mathematics" Routledge Falmer 248-258, 2002

77 Stylianides, G. J., "An analytic framework of reasoning-and-proving" 28 (28): 9-16, 2008

78 Stringer, E. T., "Action research in education" Pearson Prentice Hall 2008

79 Healy, L., "A study of proof conceptions in algebra" 31 (31): 396-428, 2000

80 Ball, D. L., "A research companion to Principals and Standard for School Mathematics" National Council of Teachers of Mathematics 27-44, 2003

81 Cañadas, M. C., "A proposal of categorisation for analysing inductive reasoning" 401-408, 2005

82 Lankshear, C., "A handbook for teacher research: from design to implementation" Open University Press 2004

83 Ingram, J., "A critical analysis of the role of wait time in classroom interactions and the effects on student and teacher interactional behaviours" 46 (46): 37-53, 2016

84 Yackel, E., "A Research Companion to Principles and Standards for School Mathematics" National Council of Teachers of Mathematics 227-236, 2003