일본 중국사학자의 중국인식과 ‘공동체론’ －혐중(嫌中)의 기원－ = A study on the perception of Chia by the Japanese historians of China

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Japanese intellectuals who had enjoyed the first half of the 20th century, such as Naito Konan, Yano Zinichi, and Yamaji Aizan, all viewed the Chinese society as a typically different society from Japan and Europe. While there is a prospect of reaching the same stage as Europe, even if it is very late, if we stand on the development stage theory, the Chinese society from the very first place has a history different from that of Europe and Japan. Most of these conclusions have resulted in a devastating effect on China, but if we overturn them, we will be able to discover new possibilities in Chinese society that can not be found in Western and Japanese society.
Especially, when we reconsider the discussions that viewed the nation-state building in China as a hopeless, we will be able to give a big impression.
This social typological view that has been forgotten in the postwar period has recently emerged again. In this regard, I would like to find out the clues that these China issues can only fairly compare and contrast the characteristics of both China and Japan without emphasizing heterogeneity and not serving any more in the vilification and abomination on China.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박훈, "｢近世化｣論と日本：｢東アジア｣の捉え方をめぐって" 勉誠出版 2015

2 岸本美緖, "｢帝國｣日本の學知]岩波講座3卷東洋學の磁場" 岩波書店 2006

3 與那覇潤, "중국화하는 일본:동아시아 ‘문명의 충돌’ 1천년사" 페이퍼로드 2013

4 가라타니 고진, "제국의 구조" 도서출판b 2016

5 岡本隆司, "近代中国をみつめる" 2014

6 박훈, "明治維新史研究 8" 2012

7 박훈, "思想史から東アジアを考える" 國立臺灣大學出版 2016

8 足立啓二, "專制國家史論－中國史から世界史へ" 柏書房 1998

9 與那覇潤, "內藤湖南のアジア認識－日本近代思想史からみる" 勉誠出版 2013

10 岡本隆司, "中国｢反日｣の源流" 講談社選書メチエ 2011

11 岡本隆司, "中国の論理－歴史から解き明かす" 中公新書 2016

12 與那覇潤, "『支那論』解說" 文藝春秋 2013

13 박훈, "‘연속하면서 혁신’ - 幕末정치사와 明治維新을 보는 시각" 일본사학회 (40) : 119-138, 2014

14 박훈, "‘봉건사회’-‘군현사회’와 동아시아 ‘근대’ 시론(試論)" 동북아역사재단 (57) : 288-328, 2017

15 박훈, "100년 전의 거울－20세기 초 日本의 ‘中國論’을 통해 본 ‘國家’ 문제"