고고학 해석의 지평 넓히기 -고고학 자료에 대한 다양한 인식 검토- = An examination of the different perceptions of the archaeological record

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The various approaches used to interpret the archaeological evidence are based on different perceptions of the archaeological record. This paper aims to examine the interpretative possibilities and limitations of culture- historical archaeology and the various approaches of processual (the New Archaeology, behavioral archaeology, and Darwinian evolutionary archaeology) and post-processual archaeology (contextual archaeology, phenomenological approaches to the landscape, and a ``structuring`` archaeology) with focus on the way in which the archaeological record is perceived. In doing so, it is hoped that a better understanding of these approaches may be obtained, as well as the acknowledgement that, in the interpretation of a common data set, the dissimilar results produced by the various approaches should be regarded as being interpretations with different points of focus, rather than as being contrasting interpretations. It is suggested that this will help lay down the foundations for a more symbiotic relationship between the various archaeological approaches currently in use within Korean archaeology.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이희준, "죽음의 고고학" 사회평론 2009

2 성춘택, "브루스 트리거의 고고학사" 사회평론 2010

3 마이클 오브라이언, "다윈 진화고고학" 나남 2005

4 성춘택, "다위니즘으로 고고학하기, In 다윈 진화고고학" 603-615, 2005

5 성춘택, "다위니즘과 진화고고학의 원칙" 호남고고학회 17 : 113-133, 2003

6 콜린 렌프류, "고고학의 주요개념" 도서출판 고고 2010

7 김종일, "고고학 이론: 입문" 도서출판 고고 2009

8 김종일, "경관고고학의 이론적 특징과 적용 가능성" 한국고고학회 11 (11): 110-145, 2006

9 Thomas, J., "Time, Culture and Identity: An Interpretative Archeology" Routledge 1996

10 Hodder, I., "Theoretical Archaeology, In Symbolic and Structural Archaeology" Cambridge University Press 1-16, 1982

11 Wylie, A., "The reaction against analogy" 8 : 63-111, 1985

12 Thomas, J., "The politics of vision and archaeologies of landscape, In Landscape: politics and perspectives" Berg 19-48, 1993

13 O’Brien, M. J, "The historical development of an evolutionary archaeology, In Darwinian Archaeologies" Plenum Press 17-32, 1996

14 Thomas, J., "The hermeneutics of megalithic space, In Interpretative Archaeology" Berg 73-97, 1993

15 Hodder, I., "The Present Past: An Introduction to Archaeology for Archaeologists" Batsford 1982

16 Tilley, C., "The Materiality of Stone, In Explorations in Landscape Phenomenology" Berg 2004

17 Collingwood, R. G., "The Idea of History" Oxford University Press 1946

18 Childe, V. G., "The Danube in Prehistory" Oxford University Press 1929

19 Schiffer, M. B., "Technological Perspectives on Behavioral Change" University of Arizona Press 1992

20 Hodder, I., "Symbols in Action: Ethnoarchaeological Studies of Material Culture" Cambridge University Press 1982

21 Tilley, C., "Round barrows and dykes as landscape metaphors" 14 : 185-203, 2004

22 Hodder, I., "Reading the Past" Cambridge University Press 1986

23 Fleming, A., "Post-processual landscape archaeology: A critique" 16 (16): 267-280, 2006

24 Cummings, V, "Places of Special Virtue: Megaliths in the Neolithic Landscape of Wales" Oxbow 2004

25 Fleming, A., "Phenomenology and the megaliths of Wales: A dreaming too far?" 18 : 119-125, 1999

26 Tilley, C., "Metaphor and Material Culture" Blackwell Publishers 1999

27 Renfrew, C, "Megaliths, territories and populations, In Acculturation and continuity in Atlantic Europe" De Temple 198-220, 1976

28 Fleming, A., "Megaliths and post-modernism: The case of Wales" 79 : 921-931, 2005

29 Barrett, J. C, "Material culture, humanity and the beginnings of the Neolithic, In Internationale Fachtagung an der Johann Wolfgang Githe-Univerita¨t" Universita¨tsforschungen zur prahistorischen Archa¨ologie 2005

30 Cummings, V., "Landscapes in motion. Interactive computer imagery and the Neolithic landscapes of the Outer Hebrides, In U.K. Chapter of Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology" British Archaeological Reports 2000

31 Patrik, L. E, "Is there an archaeological record?" 8 : 27-62, 1985

32 Buchli, V. A., "Interpreting material culture, In Interpreting Archaeology: Finding Meaning in the Past" Routledge 181-193, 1995

33 Hodder, I., "Interpretative archaeology and its role" 56 : 7-18, 1991

34 Johnsen, H, "Hermeneutics and archaeology: On the philosophy of contextual archaeology" 57 (57): 419-436, 1992

35 Barrett, J. C., "Fragments from Antiquity: An Archaeology of Social Life in Britain, In 2900-1200 BC" Blackwell 1994

36 Barrett, J. C., "Fields of discourse: Reconstructing a social archaeology" 7 : 5-16, 1998

37 Cummings, V, "Divided places: Phenomenology and asymmetry in the monuments of the Black Mountains, southeast Wales" 12 : 57-70, 2002

38 Day, P. E, "Ceramic Change and the practice of eating and drinking in Early Bronze Age Crete, In Cuisine and Society in Prehistoric Greece" Oxbow Books 45-62, 2004

39 LaMotta, V. M., "Behavioral archaeology: toward a new synthesis, In Archaeological Theory Today" Polity Press 14-64, 2001

40 Reid, J. J, "Behavioral archaeology: four strategies" 77 : 864-869, 1975

41 Binford, L., "Behavioral archaeology and the ‘Pompeii Premise" 37 : 195-208, 1981

42 Schiffer, M. B, "Behavioral Archaeology. New York: Academic Press, In Re-constructing Archaeology" Cambridge University Press 1987

43 O’Brien, M. J., "Basic Incompatibilities between Evolutionary and Behavioral Archaeology" 63 (63): 485-498, 1998

44 McGuire, R., "Archaeology: Reflections of a Prodigal Son, In Expanding Archaeology" University of Utah Press 162-177, 1995

45 Barrett, J. C., "Archaeology as the investigation of the contexts of humanity, In Deconstructing Context: A Critical Approach to Archaeological Practice" Oxbow Books 194-211, 2006

46 McGlade, J., "Archaeology and the ecodynamics of human-modified landscapes" 69 : 113-132, 1995

47 McGlade, J., "Archaeology and evolution of cultural landscapes: Towards an interdisciplinary research agenda, In The Archaeology and Anthropology of Landscape: Shaping Your Landscape" Routledge 458-482, 1999

48 Thomas, J., "Archaeology and Modernity" Routledge 2004

49 Tilley, C., "An Ethnography of the Neolithic" Cambridge University Press 1996

50 Barrett, J. C., "Agency and the archaeological record, In Archaeological Theory Today" Polity Press 141-164, 2001

51 Barrett, J. C., "A thesis on agency, In Agency in Archaeology" Routledge 61-68, 2000

52 Barrett, J. C., "A perspective on the early architecture of western Europe, In Constructing Power: Architecture" Lit Verlag 2006

53 Gould, R. A, "A dialogue on the meaning and use of analogy in ethnoarchaeological reasoning" 1 : 335-381, 1982

54 Tilley, C., "A Phenomenology of Landscape: Places, Paths and Monuments" Berg 1994

55 Barrett, J., "A Phenomenology of Landscape. A Crisis in British Landscape Archaeology?" 9 (9): 276-294, 2009