바우처 분석: 한국과 미국을 중심으로 = An Analysis of Voucher Programs in South Korea and the United States

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In recent years, vouchers have been used as a way to provide greater freedom of choice for beneficiaries of government programs, to improve efficiency through more competition among suppliers and to promote equity. There are, however, few systematic studies to provide an overview of vouchers as a tool of government action in South Korea. This study examines the definition and goals of voucher, differences between voucher and other policy tools, and key issues of voucher in South Korea and the United States. In conclusion, this study suggests key managerial issues for policy design and future research directions.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

최근 바우처가 시민의 선택권 확장, 공급자 사이의 경쟁 촉진, 형평성 제고차원에서 주목을 받고 있다. 하지만 국내의 경우 아직 바우처에 대한 체계적인 분석이 부족하다. 이에 본 연구는 바우처의 개념과 기능, 다른 정책수단과의 차이점, 그리고 한국과 미국을 중심으로 한 바우처 현황과 쟁점을 정리하고 있다. 마지막으로 바우처 정책설계 시 주요 고려사항과 향후 연구방향을 제시하고 있다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "학교선택권의 보장을 위한 학교체제 재구조화 방안에 관한 연구" 7 : 123-149, 2002

2 "재정효율성 제고를 위한 시장원리 활용방안-바우처 제도를 중심으로" 한국개발연구원 2007

3 "여행바우처 제도 시범사업 운영방안" 한국문화관광정책 연구원 2004

4 "여행바우처 제도 도입방안" 한국관광연구원 1999

5 "수요자 중심의 교육훈련체제로 - ’직업훈련카드 제도의 도입’" 국민경제교육연구소 (94) : 1998

6 "선진주요국의 학부모 학교선택 보장을 위한 학교체제 형태" 4 : 131-157, 1999

7 "사회복지서비스 전달체계에서의 바우처 도입의 의의와 가능성" 1999

8 "문화격차 분석과 문화바우처 정책설계" 10 (10): 63-89, 2006

9 "근로자복지카드 추진방안 연구" 한국조세연구원 2003

10 "교육훈련 바우처 제도의 도입방안" 1998

11 "“School Choices in Milwaukee: A Randomized Experiment.” In Learning from School Choice" Brookings Institution 1998

12 "and the Organization of Schools" 1065-1089, 1988

13 "a case study in administrative innovation and citizen participation" (v) : 537-546, 1983

14 "Who Benefits from Educational Choice Some Evidence from Europe Journal of Policy Analysis and Management" 454-476, 1994

15 "When Schools Compete, How Do They Compete? An Assessment of Chile's Nationwide School Voucher Program" 10 (10): 2003

16 "What Every American Needs to Know" 1987

17 "Vouchers: Medicare's only hope" 13 : 24-27, 1995

18 "Vouchers for Private Schooling in Columbia: Evidence from a Randomized Natural Experiment" 92 (92): 1535-1558, 2002

19 "Vouchers for Federal Targeted training Programs" 254-250, 2000

20 "Vouchers for Elementary and Secondary Education" 251-291, 2000

21 "Vouchers as a way to finance unemployment benefits" 62 : 223-227, 1999

22 "Vouchers and the Provision of Public Services Committee for Economic Development" 2000

23 "Vouchers and the Provision of Public Services" Washington D.C.: The Brookings Institution, Committee for Economic Development, and Urban Institute

24 "Vouchers and Public Policy: When Ideology Trumps Evidence." 111 : 548-567, 2004

25 "Vouchers and American Higher Education" 336-367, 2000

26 "Vouchers" 445-465, 2002

27 "Voucher and Interdistrict Choice Programs in Milwaukee American Journal of Education" 1996186-217

28 "The role of government in education" Chicago University Press 1962

29 "The effects of competition on educational outcomes: a review of the U.S. evidence" 27 : 279-341, 2002

30 "The Tools of Government: A Guide to the New Governance" Oxford University Press 2002

31 "The Public Use of Private Interest" Brookings Institution Press 1977

32 "The Politics of Vouchers" 92-118, 2000

33 "The Effectiveness and Efficiency of Private Schools in Chiles Voucher System" 33 (33): 213-239, 2000

34 "The Economics of Vouchers" 40-91, 2000

35 "The Changing Partnership Between the Voluntary Sector and the Welfare State The Future of the Nonprofit Sector" Jossey-Bass 41-60, 1989

36 "Subsidizing Health Care for the under Sixty-Five Population" 438-470, 2000

37 "Structured Choice versus Fragmented Choice: Bundling of Vouchers" 407-437, 2000

38 "Strategies for Program Integration" Washington, D.C.: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research 1995

39 "Public Finance" New York: McGraw-Hill 1996

40 "Privatizing Education; Lessons from Canada, Europe, and Asia" 292-335, 2000

41 "Privatizing Delivery of Services" 97-120, 1998

42 "Private school vouchers and student achievement: An evaluation of the Milwaukee Parental Choice Program" 113 : 553-602, 1998

43 "Private Vouchers" CA: Hoover Institution Press 1995

44 "Models of state and market in the modernisation of higher education" 21 (21): 537-554, 2000

45 "Medicare Vouchers" 407-437, 2000

46 "Market approaches to education Economics of Education Review" 1992

47 "Market Forces and Standards in Education: A Preliminary Consideration" 23 (23): 6-18, 2002

48 "Market Education. The Unknown History" New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers 1999

49 "Legal and Constitutional Issues of Vouchers" 368-393, 2000

50 "Journal of Politics" 475-491, 1994

51 "Identifying Voucher Plans without Welfare Losses" 30 (30): 175-183, 1999

52 "Housing Vouchers: The U.S. Experience" 139-175, 2000

53 "Giving Consumers of British Public Services More Choice: What can be Learned from Recent History?" 32 (32): 239-270, 2003

54 "Evidence From a Wage Voucher Experiment" 105-114, 1985

55 "Educational Vouchers: Effectiveness, Choice, and Costs" 17 (17): 373-392, 1998

56 "Education Vouchers in Principle and Practice: A Survey" 12 (12): 83-103, 1997

57 "Dimensions of Social Welfare Policy" Prentice-Hall 1993

58 "Competition and Choice in New York City Social Services" 62 (62): 82-91, 2002

59 "Common Issues for Vouchers Programs" 3-39, 2000

60 "Commissioning for quality: ten years of social care markets in England" 30 (30): 283-306, 2001

61 "Child-Care Vouchers and Cash Payments" 254-250, 2000

62 "2007년도 예산안 편성지침 및 기준" 2006년3월