외설적 표현권의 전의미 = The Overall Meaning of Pornographic Rights to Express

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

For Plato and Aristotle in ancient times a work of art was considered valuable if it could provide good for the society. Plato convicts art because, as he claims, it destroys our psychic harmony, while Aristotle defends art because it cathartically drains away our fear, pity, and violence. In modern times, though, the so-called artistic legitimacy depends largely on individual free choice rather than traditional social values. This does imply that pornographic rights to express outweigh some various social threats allegedly caused by pornographic representations. Further pornographers ought to face feminists` rebel with a cause. Feminists` accusation that sexually explicit materials lead to social gender inequality as well as chilling individual autonomy can not so much be nullified as be incorporated within the supremacy of freedom to offend that modern democracies have made. That does by no means suggest, however, that freedom of speech, conceived and protected as a fundamental negative liberty, ignores either societal values or women`s serious critiques of pornographic literature. Thus the concept of liberal pornographic neutralizability seeks both free speech and aesthetic utility. And further the right to free speech is ready to accept the openness of the future which recognizes the complexity and uncertain nature of human culture including potentially marginal and possibly innovative pornographic arts. Free speech right has to allow room for adventure that will inevitably be a part of such a fluxive and human enterprise. That is, I suppose, what pornographic rights to express should all mean.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 talkasia, "추원강"

2 황필홍, "자유와 공동체" 도서출판 고원 2001

3 신양숙, "외설물 규제에 관하여, In 낙태 포르노 인간복제" 도서출판 고원 15-47, 1999

4 "박경신"

5 신명아, "남성히스테리 증후로서의 포르노그라피에 대한 정신분석적 해체, In 낙태 포르노 인간복제" 도서출판 고원 51-87, 1999

6 "김미루"

7 Russell, Bertrand, "What I Believe" Routledge 2004

8 Lorde, Audre, "Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 569-574, 2007

9 Leidholdt, Dorchen, A, "The Sexual Exploitation of Women and Girls: A Violation of Human Rights, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 418-422, 2007

10 Butler, Judith, "The Force of Fantasy: Feminism, Mapplethorpe, and Discursive, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 487-508, 2007

11 Sun, Chyng F, "The Fallacies of Fantasies, In Pornography: Driving the Demand in International Sex Trafficking" Captive Daughters Media 233-250, 2007

12 Linsley, William A, "The Case Against Censorship of Pornography, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 176-190, 1998

13 "The Attorney General's Commission on Pornography: Final Report" U. S. Department of Justice 1986

14 Dworkin, Andrea, "Suffering and Speech, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 154-165, 2007

15 Garry, Ann, "Sex, Lies and Pornography, In Contemporary Moral Problems" Wadsworth 373-385, 2003

16 "Report of the Commission on Obscenity and Pornography" Bantam Books 1979

17 Stoltenberg, John, "Refusing to Be a Man: Essays on Sex and Justice" UCL Press 2000

18 Mannig, Rita C, "Redefining Pornography, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 191-201, 1998

19 Christensen, F. M, "Pornography: The Other Side" Praeger Publishers 1990

20 MacKinnon, Catharine A, "Pornography: Driving the Demand in International Sex Trafficking, In Pornography: Driving the Demand in International Sex Trafficking" Captive Daughters Media 31-42, 2007

21 Ferguson, Frances, "Pornography, The Theory" The University of Chicago Press 2004

22 Langton, Rae, "Pornography, Speech Acts, and Silence, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 338-349, 1998

23 Cornell, Drucilla, "Pornography's Temptation, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 551-568, 2007

24 Berns, Walter, "Pornography vs. Democracy: The Case for Censorship" (Winter) : 1-24, 1971

25 Ramos, Norma, "Pornography is a Social Justice Issue, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 45-47, 2007

26 Hawkins, Gordon, "Pornography in a Free Society" Cambridge University Press 2007

27 Slade, Joseph W, "Pornography in America: A Reference Handbook" ABC-CLIO, Inc 2000

28 Gracyk, Theodore A, "Pornography as Representation: Aesthetic Considerations, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 155-175, 1998

29 Brod, Harry, "Pornography and the Alienation of Male Sexuality, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 114-121, 1998

30 Russell, Diana E. H, "Pornography and Rape: A Causal Model, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 48-93, 2007

31 Lynn, Barry, "Pornography and Free Speech: The Civil Rights Approach, In Contemporary Moral Problems" Wadsworth 365-373,

32 Royalle, Candida, "Porn in the USA, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 540-550, 2007

33 Carter, Angela, "Polemical Preface: Pornography in the Service of Women, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 527-539, 2007

34 Grube, G. M. A, "Plato's Republic" Hackett Publishing Company 1982

35 Nussbaum, Martha, "Philosophy and Literature, In The Cambridge Companion to Greek and Roman Philosophy" Cambridge University Press 225-251, 2003

36 "Paris Adult Theatre I v. Slaton"

37 Mill, J. S, "On Liberty" Hackett 1978

38 MacKinnon, Catharine A, "Not a Moral Issue, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 169-197, 2007

39 Dworkin, Ronald, "Liberty and Pornography, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 149-154, 1998

40 Sandel, Michael, "Liberalism and the Limits of Justice" Cambridge University Press 1982

41 Hwang, Pilhong, "Liberal Pornographic Rights: Private Right over Public Menace" 17 (17): 225-240, 2003

42 Sandel, Michael, "Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?" Farrar, Straus and Giroux 2009

43 Mercer, Kobena, "Just Looking for Trouble: Robert Mapplethorpe and Fantasies of Race, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 460-476, 2007

44 Baird, Robert M, "Introduction, Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 9-17, 1998

45 Cornell, Drucilla, "Introduction, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 1-15, 2007

46 Procida, Richard, "Global Perspectives on Social Issues: Pornography" Lexington Books 2003

47 Altman, Andrew, "Freedom of Speech and Religion, In Practical Ethics by Hugh LaFollette" Oxford University Press 358-386, 2003

48 Dahnke, Michael D, "Film, Art, and Filmart: An Introduction to Aesthetics Through Film" University Press of America 2007

49 Dority, Barbara, "Feminist Moralism, ”Pornography,“ and Censorship, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 149-154, 1998

50 Christensen, F. M, "Elicitation of Violence: The Evidence, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 259-282, 1998

51 Michelman, Frank I, "Conceptions of Democracy in American Constitutional Argument: The Case of Pornography Regulation, In Pornography: Private Right or Public Menace?" Prometheus Books 303-304, 1998

52 Gutmann, Amy, "Communitarian Critics of Liberalism" 14 : 308-322, 1985

53 Dickie, George, "Art and the Aesthetic: An Institutional Analysis" Cornell University Press 1974

54 Butcher, S. H, "Aristotle's Poetics"

55 Dworkin, Andrea, "Against the Male Flood: Censorship, Pornography, and Equality, In Feminism and Pornography" xford University Press 19-38, 2007

56 Rawls, John, "A Theory of Justice, In Political Liberalism" Columbia University Press 1993

57 Chow, Rey, "'Love Me, Master, Love Me, Son': A Cultural Other Pornographically Constructed in Time, In Feminism and Pornography" Oxford University Press 509-524, 2007