소비자의 귀추추론 오류 대한 연구 = An Investigation of Consumer’s Fallacy of Abductive Reasoning

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구에서는 어떤 결과로부터 원인을 추론하는 귀추추론 과정에서 발생하는 오류에 대해 탐구하고자 한다. 구체적으로는 추론과제의 표현방식에 따라 오류의 발생이 어떻게 달라지는지 알아보기 위해 세 번의 실험을 실시하였다. 본 연구에서는 다음과 같은 사실을 발견할 수 있었다. 첫째, 문장형태의 추론과제가 기저율 정보를 포함하지 않은 경우에도 연역적 조건추론과 귀추적 조건추론을 혼동하는 역오류가 발생하였고 그 결과로 원인에 대한 귀추추론 자체에도 오류가 발생하였다. 둘째, 기저율 정보가 포함되지 않은 빈도형태의 추론과제의 경우에는 역오류가 발생하지 않았고 원인에 대한 귀추추론 자체에도 오류가 발생하지 않았다. 마지막으로 기저율 정보가 포함되지 않은 그림형태의 추론과제의 경우에는 문장형태의 추론과제의 경우와 같이 역오류가 발생하였고 그 결과로 원인에 대한 귀추추론 자체에도 오류가 발생하였다. 본 연구의 결과를 근거로 이론적ㆍ실무적 시사점을 제시하고 한계점과 향후 연구에 대해 논의하였다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study investigated the fallacy of abduction which reasoned the causes from the consequences. Especially, current study researched the influence of representation format on the occurrence of the fallacy. The results was as follows. First, even when the information about base-rate is not provided, the inverse fallacy occurred, which is the confusion between the abductive reasoning and the deductive reasoning. And consequently, the fallacy of abductive reasoning for the causes occurred. Second, when the information about base-rate is not provided, in the case of representation format by frequency, the inverse fallacy didn’t occur and the fallacy of abductive reasoning for the causes didn’t, either. Third, when the information about base-rate is not provided, in the case of representation format by picture, the inverse fallacy occurred and the fallacy of abductive reasoning for the causes did, too. On the basis of these results, theoretical and practical implications were suggested and the limitations and future research were discussed.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 요약
• Ⅰ. 서론
• Ⅱ. 이론적 배경 및 가설설정
• Ⅲ. 연구 1
• Ⅳ. 연구 2
• Ⅴ. 연구 3
• Ⅵ. 결론 및 시사점
• 참고문헌
• Abstract

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 허경옥, "소비시장과 소비자행동의 효율성 분석: 제품과 서비스를 대상으로" 한국소비문화학회 11 (11): 149-169, 2008

2 송인숙, "가전제품에 대한 불만대응행동에서 나타나는 소비자의 문제행동 연구" 한국소비문화학회 11 (11): 175-195, 2008

3 Patokorpi, Erkki, "What could abductive reasoning contribute to human computer interaction? A technology demostication view" 7 (7): 113-131, 2009

4 Kahnemann, Daniel, "Timid choices and bold forecasts: A Cognitive perspective on risk taking" 39 : 17-31, 1993

5 Pollard, Paul, "The role of representativeness in statistical inference. In Thinking and reasoning" Routledge & Kegan Paul 1983

6 Wang, Hongbin, "The order effect in human abductive reasoning: an empirical and computational study" 18 (18): 215-247, 2006

7 Villejoubert, Gaelle, "The inverse fallacy: an account of deviations from Bayes's theorem and the additivity principle" 30 (30): 171-178, 2002

8 Harman, Gilbert, H, "The inference to the best explanation" 74 : 88-95, 1965

9 Sloman, Steven, A, "The empirical case for two systems of reasoning" 119 : 3-22, 1996

10 Miles, Amanda, "The effects of visual representation on Bayesian decision making and Bayesian reasoning" 1 : 1-6, 2008

11 Nilsson, Hakan, "The cognitive substrate of subjective probability" 31 (31): 600-620, 2005

12 Koehler, Jonathan J, "The base rate fallacy reconsidered:Descriptive, normative and methodological challenges" 19 : 1-53, 1996

13 Bar-Hilel, Maya, "The base rate fallacy in probability judgments" 44 : 211-233, 1980

14 Josang, Audun, "The base rate fallacy in belief reasoning" 2010

15 Sedlmeier, Peter, "Teaching Bayesian reasoning in less than two hours" 130 : 380-400, 2001

16 Kahnemann, Daniel, "Subjective probability: A judgment of representativeness" 3 : 430-454, 1972

17 Kahnemann, Daniel, "Representativeness revisited: Attribute substitution in intuitive judgment. In Heuristics and biases: The psychology of intuitive judgment" Cambridge University Press 2002

18 Evans, Jonathan St. B. T, "Rationality and Reasoning" Psychology Press 1996

19 Macchi, Laura, "Pragmatic aspects of the base rate fallacy" 48A : 188-207, 1995

20 Brase, Gary L, "Pictorial Representations in Statistical Reasoning" 23 : 369-381, 2009

21 Kahnemann, Daniel, "On the reality of cognitive illusions" 103 : 582-591, 1996

22 Kahnemann, Daniel, "On the psychology of prediction" 80 : 237-251, 1973

23 Chapman, Gretchen B, "Numeracy, frequency, and Bayesian reasoning" 4 (4): 34-40, 2009

24 Lundberg, C. Gustav, "Made sense and remembered sense: Sensemaking through abduction" 21 (21): 691-709, 2000

25 Kahnemann, Daniel, "Judgement under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases" Cambridge University Press 1982

26 Shafir,Eldar, "Intuitions and rationality and cognition. In Rationality: Psychological and philosophical perspectives" Routledge 1993

27 Card, Stuart K, "Information visualization: using vision to think" Academic Press 1999

28 Wolfe, Christopher R, "Information seeking on Bayesian conditional probability problems: A fuzzytrace theory account" 8 : 85-108, 1995

29 Brase, Gary L, "Individuation, counting and statistical inference: the role of frequency and whole-object representations in judgment under uncertainty" 127 : 3-21, 1998

30 Stanovich, Keith E, "Individual differences in reasoning: Implications for the rationality debate" 23 : 645-726, 2000

31 Osman, Magda, "Individual differences in causal learning and decision making" 120 : 93-112, 2005

32 Sedlmeier, Peter, "Improving statistical reasoning: Theoretical models and practical implications" Erlbaum 1999

33 Gigerenzer, Gerd, "How to improve Bayesian reasoning without instruction: Frequency formats" 102 : 684-704, 1995

34 Gilovich, Thomas, "Heuristics and biases: The psychology of intuitive judgement" Cambridge University Press 2002

35 Reyna, Valerie F, "Fuzzy processing in transitivity development" 23 : 37-63, 1990

36 Kellen, Vince, "Facilitating Conditional Probability Problems with Visuals. In Human-computer interaction, Part Ⅱ" Springer 2007

37 Hamm, Robert, M, "Explanation for common responses to the blue/ green cab probabilistic inference word problem" 72 : 219-242, 1993

38 Thagard, Paul, "Explaining Disease: Correlations, Causes, and Mechanism" 8 : 61-78, 1988

39 Dawes, Robyn, M, "Equating inverse probabilities in implicit personality judgments" 4 : 396-400, 1993

40 Kardes, Frank R, "Consumer Behavior and Managerial Decision Making" Pearson-Prentice Hall 2002

41 Kardes, Frank R, "Consumer Behavior" South-Western Cengage Learning 2008

42 Josang, Audun, "Conditional reasoning with subjective logic" 15 (15): 5-38, 2008

43 Lichtenstein, Sarah, "Calibration of probabilities: The state of the art to 1980. In Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases" Cambridge University Press 1982

44 Barbey, Aron, K, "Base-rate respect: From ecological rationality to dual processes" 30 : 241-297, 2007

45 Glockner, Andreas, "Base-rate Respect by intuition: Approximating Rational choices in base-rate tasks with multiple cues" Max Planck Institute for Research on Collective Goods 2008

46 Evans, Jonathan St. B. T, "Background beliefs in Bayesian Inference" 30 (30): 179-190, 2002

47 Cosmides, Leda, "Are humans good intuitive statisticians after all? Rethinking some conclusions from the literature on judgment under uncertainty" 58 : 1-73, 1996

48 Koehler, Derek J, "An evidential support accumulation model of subjective probability" 46 : 152-197, 2003

49 Dull, Richard B, "A comparison of three visual representations of complex multidimensional accounting information" 13 : 117-131, 1999