Regional Integration, Growth and Convergence = Regional Integration, Growth and Convergence

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper examines empirically whether and how regional integration leads to convergence and growth amongst developing countries. Using standard growth models for nearly 100 developing countries over 1970-2004 we cannot establish robust growth effects of regional integration as such at the aggregated level of analysis even after using alternative measures of regional integration. However, because we find that trade and FDI promote growth, and because regional integration tends to increase trade and FDI, regional integration still has a positive impact on growth in its members through the effects of increased trade and investment on growth. Further, country-specific growth diagnostics do suggest that regional integration can be a binding constraint to growth as “deep” regional approaches can help to address crucial rail, road, air and energy links amongst countries (e.g. in the East African Community). Our findings also suggest that initially high levels of regional income disparities will lead to greater decreases in disparities. Whilst the level of intra-regional trade and incomes do not explain changes in income disparities, the presence of a regional Development Finance Institutions (e.g. Central American or East African development banks) with a relatively high loan exposure to GDP ratio tends to reduce regional income disparities suggesting a useful role for deeper integration in achieving regional cohesion. A one percentage point increase in exposure by DFIs leads to a drop of σ of about one percentage point. Finally, while the macro economic literature on regional integration tends to highlight only limited expected effects of African regional integration itself, our work at the firm level in three African countries (Benin, Malawi and South Africa) is indicative of significant dynamic effects of regional integration through the effects on firm level productivity in Africa. We suggest that in the future, further growth analytical work is undertaken which combines the development of methods to examine the effects of regions and measurement of the various types of regional integration.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Hammouda, B., "Why doesn’t Regional Integration Improve Income Convergence in Africa" UNECA 2007

2 Rodrik, D., "The new global economy and developing countries: making openness work" Overseas Development Council 1999

3 Viner J., "The customs union issue" Carnegie Endowment for International Peace 1950

4 Carmignani, F., "The Road to Regional Integration in Africa: Macroeconomic Convergence and Performance in COMESA" Oxford University Press 15 (15): 212-250, 2006

5 Olley, Steven, "The Dynamics of Productivity in the Telecommunications Equipment Industry" 64 (64): 1263-1297, 1996

6 Qureshi, M., "State Business Relations and firm performance in Zambia"

7 Soloaga, I., "Regionalism in the Nineties: What Effect on Trade" 12 (12): 2001

8 Ethier, W. J., "Regionalism in a multilateral world" 106 : 1214-1245, 1998

9 Vamvakidis, A., "Regional integration and economic growth" 12 (12): 251-270, 1998

10 Frankel, Jeffrey, "Regional Trading Blocs in the World Trading System" Institute for International Economics 1997

11 Meyn, M., "Regional Integration in African, Caribbean and Pacific Countries" A Review of the Literature, Report for the EC’s DG Development 2008

12 Levy Y.E., "Regional Integration and the Location of FDI, IADB Draft"

13 Schiff, "Regional Integration and Technology Diffusion. The case of the North American Free Trade Agreement, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3132" 2003

14 Velde, D.W. te, "Regional Integration and Poverty" Ashgate 2006

15 Velde, D.W., "Regional Integration and Foreign Direct Investment in Developing Countries" 15 (15): 41-70, 2006

16 Blomstrom, M. A. Kokko, "Regional Integration and Foreign Direct Investment" NBER 1997

17 Venables, A.J., "Regional Integration Agreements; a force for convergence or divergence" World Bank Policy research 1999

18 Coe, D. T., "North-South R&D Spillovers" 107 : 134-149, 1997

19 Holmes, M. J., "New evidence on Long-run output convergence among Latin American countries" 8 (8): 299-319, 2005

20 Mutoti, N., "Macroeconomic convergence in COMESA, Bank of Uganda Working Paper, WP 01/2006" 2006

21 Coe, D.T., "International R&D Spillovers" 39 (39): 859-887, 1995

22 Grossman, G.M., "Innovation and Growth in the Global Economy" MIT press 1991

23 Ghura, D., "Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa" 43 (43): 605-634, 1996

24 Aziz Wane, A., "Growth and Convergence in WAEMU Countries" IMF 2004

25 Henrekson, M., "Growth Effects of European Integration" 41 (41): 1537-1557, 1997

26 Gasiorek, M., "Globalisation and Deep Integration" CARIS 2008

27 Djankov, S., "Foreign Investment and productivity Growth in Czech Enterprises" 14 : 49-64, 2000

28 Neary, J.P, "Foreign Direct Investment and the Single Market" Draft paper CEPR and University College Dublin 2001

29 Levinsohn, James, "Estimating Production Functions Using Inputs to Control for Unobservables" 70 (70): 317-341, 2000

30 Jones, B., "Economic Integration and Convergence of Per Capita Income in West Africa" 14 : 18-47, 2002

31 IMF/World Bank, "Doha Development Agenda and Aid for Trade, submitted to the Development Committee of the IMF and World Bank"

32 Aitken, B.J., "Do Domestic Firms Benefit from Direct Foreign Investment? Evidence from Venezuela" 89 : 605-618, 1999

33 Haddad, M., "Are there positive spillovers from direct foreign investment? Evidence from panel data for Morocco" 42 : 51-74, 1993

34 Frankel, J., "An Estimate of the Effect of Common Currencies on Trade and Income" 2002