Comparison of Two Types of 1-L Polyethylene Glycol-ascorbic Acid as Colonoscopic Bowel Preparation: A Prospective Randomized Study

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background/Aims: Recently, 1-L polyethylene glycol-ascorbic acid (PEG-Asc) has been used to reduce the volume of preparation agents in colonoscopy. This clinical trial aimed to compare the efficacy and safety of two types of 1-L PEG-Asc (CleanViewAL® [Tae Joon Pharmaceutical Company, Seoul, Korea] and Plenvu® [Norgine, Harefield, United Kingdom]) in average-aged adults.
Methods: This study was a prospective, randomized, non-inferiority, open-label, phase 4 clinical trial. The primary endpoint was the efficacy evaluated using the Boston bowel preparation scale (BBPS), and the secondary endpoint was clinical safety.
Results: In total, 173 patients were assigned to either the CleanViewAL® (n=84) or Plenvu® (n=89) group. Overall cleansing successes of 97.6% (82/84) and 98.8% (88/89) were achieved in the CleanViewAL® group and in the Plenvu® group, respectively, showing that CleanViewAL® has similar bowel cleansing efficacy to Plenvu® (95% CI, -0.052 to 0.027; p=0.207). The total BBPS score was 8.67±1.00 and 8.70±0.76 in the CleanViewAL® group and Plenvu® group, respectively (p=0.869). The most common adverse symptom was nausea, and no adverse symptoms requiring hospitalization were reported in either group. There were no cases of critical hypernatremia and liver dysfunction exceeding the common terminology criteria for adverse events grade I. An overall satisfaction score (scale of 1 to 10) showed no difference between the two groups (p=0.289). However, the CleanViewAL® group showed a higher taste satisfaction score (scale of 1 to 5) than the Plenvu® group (CleanViewAL®: 2.90±0.91, Plenvu®: 2.60±0.86, p=0.028).
Conclusions: Both types of 1-L PEG-Asc, CleanViewAL® and Plenvu®, are effective and safe bowel cleansing agents in average-aged adults. CleanViewAL® was preferred in terms of taste satisfaction.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이연호 ; 정성연 ; 김유선 ; 정헤진 ; 권민정 ; 곽철훈 ; 배송이 ; 문정섭 ; 김지원 ; 김수환 ; 이국래, "대장내시경 장정결제로서 Sodium Phosphate 정제와 2 L Polyethylene Glycol with Ascorbic Acid의 무작위 대조군 연구" 대한소화기학회 65 (65): 27-34, 2015

2 Tan JJ, "Which is the optimal bowel preparation for colonoscopy-a meta-analysis" 8 : 247-258, 2006

3 Belsey J, "Systematic review : adverse event reports for oral sodium phosphate and polyethylene glycol" 29 : 15-28, 2009

4 이석원 ; 방창석 ; 박태영 ; 석기태 ; 백광호 ; 김동준, "Split-dose Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy: 2 Liters Polyethylene Glycol with Ascorbic Acid versus Sodium Picosulfate versus Oral Sodium Phosphate Tablets" 대한소화기학회 70 (70): 89-95, 2017

5 Yoshida N, "Safety and Efficacy of a same-day low-volume 1 L PEG bowel preparation in colonoscopy for the elderly people and people with renal dysfunction" 61 : 3229-3235, 2016

6 Amitay EL, "Risk Factors of Inadequate Bowel Preparation for Screening Colonoscopy" 10 : 2740-, 2021

7 Toledo TK, "Review article : colon cleansing preparation for gastrointestinal procedures" 15 : 605-611, 2001

8 Bitoun A, "Results of a prospective randomised multicentre controlled trial comparing a new 2-L ascorbic acid plus polyethylene glycol and electrolyte solution vs. sodium phosphate solution in patients undergoing elective colonoscopy" 24 : 1631-1642, 2006

9 Dae Hyung Woo ; Kyeong Ok Kim ; Da Eun Jeong ; Yoon Jeong Nam ; Si Hyung Lee ; Byung Ik Jang ; Tae Nyeun Kim, "Prospective analysis of factors associated with inadequate bowel preparation for colonoscopy in actual clinical practice" 대한장연구학회 16 (16): 293-298, 2018

10 Bechtold ML, "Optimizing bowel preparation for colonoscopy : a guide to enhance quality of visualization" 29 : 137-146, 2016

11 Yang HJ, "Novel sulfate tablet PBK-1701TC versus oral sulfate solution for colon cleansing : a randomized phase 3 trial" 35 : 29-36, 2020

12 DeMicco MP, "Novel 1 L polyethylene glycol-based bowel preparation NER1006for overall and right-sided colon cleansing : a randomized controlled phase 3 trial versus trisulfate" 87 : 677-687.e3, 2018

13 Belsey J, "Meta-analysis : the relative efficacy of oral bowel preparations for colonoscopy 1985-2010" 35 : 222-237, 2012

14 Froehlich F, "Impact of colonic cleansing on quality and diagnostic yield of colonoscopy : the European Panel of Appropriateness of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy European multicenter study" 61 : 378-384, 2005

15 Weir MA, "Hyponatremia and sodium picosulfate bowel preparations in older adults" 109 : 686-694, 2014

16 Rex DK, "Hyperosmotic low-volume bowel preparations : is NER1006 safe?" 89 : 656-658, 2019

17 Carlos Quezada-Gutiérrez ; María Teresa Álvarez-Bañuelos ; Jaime Morales-Romero ; Clara Luz Sampieri ; Raúl Enrique Guzmán-García ; Evangelina Montes-Villaseñor, "Factors associated with the survival of colorectal cancer in Mexico" 대한장연구학회 18 (18): 315-324, 2020

18 Ajit Sood ; Ramit Mahajan ; Arshdeep Singh ; Vandana Midha ; Varun Mehta, "Endoscopy for assessment of mucosal healing in ulcerative colitis: time bound or response guided?" 대한장연구학회 20 (20): 297-302, 2022

19 Mareth K, "Endoscopic recognition and classification of colorectal polyps" 32 : 227-240, 2022

20 Hong SN, "Efficacy and safety of split-dose bowel preparation with 1 L polyethylene glycol and ascorbate compared with 2 L polyethylene glycol and ascorbate in a Korean population : a phase IV, multicenter, randomized, endoscopist-blinded study" 95 : 500-511.e2, 2022

21 Koo Ja Seol ; Byeon Jeong-Sik ; Lee Bo-In ; Jung Sung-Ae ; Kim Tae Il ; Jeen Yoon Tae, "Efficacy and Safety of TJP-008 Compared to 2 L PEG with Ascorbate in Colon Cleansing: A Randomized Phase 3 Trial" 거트앤리버 소화기연관학회협의회 16 (16): 259-268, 2022

22 Maida M, "Effectiveness of very low-volume preparation for colonoscopy : a prospective, multicenter observational study" 26 : 1950-1961, 2020

23 Maida M, "Effectiveness and safety of 1L PEG-ASC preparation for colonoscopy in patients with inflammatory bowel diseases" 53 : 1171-1177, 2021

24 Sung Chan Jeon ; 김재현 ; Sun Jung Kim ; Hye Jung Kwon ; Youn Jung Choi ; 정경원 ; 김성은 ; Won Moon ; 박무인 ; 박선자, "Effect of Sending Educational video Clips via Smartphone mobile messenger on Bowel Preparation before Colonoscopy" 대한소화기내시경학회 52 (52): 53-58, 2019

25 Calderwood AH, "Comprehensive validation of the Boston bowel preparation scale" 72 : 686-692, 2010

26 "Common terminology criteria for adverse events. [Internet]"

27 Schreiber S, "Colon cleansing efficacy and safety with 1 L NER1006 versus sodium picosulfate with magnesium citrate : a randomized phase 3 trial" 51 : 73-84, 2019

28 Bisschops R, "Colon cleansing efficacy and safety with 1 L NER1006 versus 2 L polyethylene glycol + ascorbate : a randomized phase 3 trial" 51 : 60-72, 2019

29 Jeeyeon Kim ; 김현건 ; 김경옥 ; 김형욱 ; Jongha Park ; Jeong-Sik Byeon ; Sung-Wook Hwang ; Hyun Deok Shin ; 신정은 ; Hyo-Joon Yang ; 이현석 ; 정윤호 ; 조영석 ; 주영은 ; Dae-Seong Myung ; Kyu Chan Huh ; Eu Mi Ahn, "Clinical comparison of low-volume agents (oral sulfate solution and sodium picosulfate with magnesium citrate) for bowel preparation: the EASE study" 대한장연구학회 17 (17): 413-418, 2019

30 Jang JY, "Bowel preparations as quality indicators for colonoscopy" 20 : 2746-2750, 2014

31 Hassan C, "Bowel preparation for colonoscopy : European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy(ESGE)Guideline-Update 2019" 51 : 775-794, 2019

32 Keswani RN, "AGA clinical practice update on strategies to improve quality of screening and surveillance colonoscopy : expert review" 161 : 701-711, 2021

33 Di Palma JA, "A randomized clinical study evaluating the safety and efficacy of a new, reduced-volume, oral sulfate colon-cleansing preparation for colonoscopy" 104 : 2275-2284, 2009

34 Kim EJ, "A Korean experience of the use of Boston bowel preparation scale : a valid and reliable instrument for colonoscopy-oriented research" 20 : 219-224, 2014