지리적 분산이 정책결정의 질에 미치는 영향 분석: 세종시 이전 사례를 중심으로 = The Effect of Geographic Dispersion on Decision Quality : The Case of Sejong City

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study analyzed how the geographic dispersion of central government departments influenced on the decision quality in public policy-making. We divided sub-variables of geographic dispersion into face-to-face contact, time pressure, and group discussion, and policy typology into routine policy, non-routine policy, and multi-departmental policy on the theoretical basis. To find out impacts of geographic dispersion on decision quality, we carried out mainly in-depth interview with directors and heads of the departments who play the key role in public policy-making. The analysis results are as followings. First, in cases of routine policy the impacts of geographic dispersion were insignificant, because government has overcome the troubles through the practical use of electronic approval and SNS. Second, in cases of non-routine policy the geographic dispersion had the negative impacts on the decision quality by the decreased opportunities of face-to-face contact and group discussions, but the increased time pressure to review. Third, in cases of multi-departmental policy the geographic dispersion also had the negative impacts on the decision quality due to increased time pressure and work overload of high-rank officials. Finally, we suggested that Korean government have to search the alternatives to cope that problem since the geographic dispersion decreased the accuracy and timeliness of public policy-making.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김동욱, "정부분할과 지역균형발전" 2010

2 김은경, "일본의 수도이전정책 중단과 정책시사점" 경기연구원 1-25, 2010

3 "인터뷰, 중앙일보 P기자(2017년 11월 3일 10:00-11:00); 뉴시스 L국장(2017년 9월 18일 18:30-19:30)"

4 "인터뷰, 기재부 A장관(2017년 9월 18일 17:00-19:00); 국조실 L장관(2017년 9월 8일 17:00-18:30)"

5 "인터뷰, 국무조정실 J과장, M서기관, K사무관(2017년 5월 19일 14:00-14:30); 산업부 K과장, C사무관(2017년 6월 12일 14:30-15:00)"

6 "인터뷰, 교육부 B실장(2017년 9월 25일 17:00-19:00); 보훈처 L실장(2017년 4월 11일 11:00 -14:00); 국무조정실 M실장(2017년 5월 19일 14:30-15:00); 산업부 K실장( 2017년 6월 12일 14:30-14:30); 고용부 P실장(2017년 10월 20일 15:00-16:00); 문화체육부 K실장(2017년 10월 27일 17:00-18:00); 국무조정실 J국장(2017년 5월 19일 13:30- 14:00); 교육부 K국장(2017년 9월 11일 15:00-17:00); 고용부 K국장(2017년 10월 20일 15:00-16:00)"

7 허준영, "세종시 이전 기관 공무원이 경험하는 행정비효율성에 관한 연구: 근거이론의 적용" 한국행정학회 49 (49): 127-159, 2015

8 하혜수, "대한민국 역대 정부 주요 정책과 국정운영: 이명박 정부" 대영문화사 2014

9 전영평, "국정운영의 측면에서 본 세종시 정부 분할 이전의 평가" 사회과학연구원 17 (17): 75-95, 2010

10 김갑성, "국가균형발전을 위한 세종시 건설계획의 문제점과 개선" 2 (2): 61-72, 2010

11 하혜수, "공공정책의 정치적 채택에 영향을 미치는 요인에 관한 연구- 세종시 수정안을 중심으로 -" 한국비교정부학회 15 (15): 343-362, 2011

12 Kocher, Martin G., "Time is Money -Time Pressure, Incentives, and the Quality of Decision-making" 61 : 375-392, 2006

13 Maul, A. J., "Time Pressure and Stress in Human Judgement and Decision Making" Plenum Press 1993

14 Lillrank, Paul, "The Quality of Standard, Routine and Nonroutine Processes" 24 (24): 215-233, 2003

15 Allen, Thomas J., "The Organization and Architecture of Innovation: Managing the Flow of Technology" Elsevier Inc 2006

16 Bogacz, Rafal, "The Neural Basis of the Speed-Accuracy Tradeoff" 33 (33): 10-16, 2010

17 Iselin, E. R., "The Impact of Information Diversity on Information Overload Effects in Unstructured Managerial Decision Making" 15 : 163-173, 1989

18 DeFond, M., "The Geography of SEC Enforcement and Auditor Reporting for Financially Distressed Clients" University of Southern California 2011

19 Malloy, C., "The Geography of Equity Analysts" 60 (60): 719-755, 2005

20 Ben-Zur, H., "The Effects of Time Pressure on Risky Choice Behavior" 47 : 89-104, 1981

21 Ahituv, Niv, "The Effects of Time Pressure and Completeness of Information on Decision Making" 15 (15): 153-173, 1998

22 Iselin, E. R., "The Effect of Information Load and Information Diversity on Decision Quality in a Structured Decision Task" 21 : 147-184, 1988

23 Er, M. C., "The Anonymity and Proximity Factors in Group Decision Support System" 14 : 75-83, 1995

24 Busemeyer, J. R., "Survey of Decision Field Theory" 43 : 345-370, 2002

25 Diederich, A., "Simple Matrix Methods for Analyzing Diffusion Models of Choice Probability, Choice Response Time and Simple Response Time" 47 : 304-322, 2003

26 Sivakumar, K., "Service Quality: The Impact of Frequency, Timing, Proximity, and Sequence of Failures and Delights" 78 : 41-58, 2014

27 Cleary, Paul, "Satisfaction may not Suffice! A Commentary on ‘A Patient’s Perspective’" 14 (14): 35-37, 1998

28 Parasuraman, A., "Reassessment of Expectations as a Comparison Standard in Measuring Service Quality: Implications for Further Research" 58 : 111-124, 1994

29 Baron, R. S., "Reaffirmation of Social Comparison Views of Choice Shift: Averaging and Extremity Effects in an Autokinetic Situation" 33 : 521-530, 1976

30 Audretsch, D., "R&D Spillovers and the Geography of Innovation and Production" 86 (86): 630-652, 1996

31 Knoben, Joris, "Proximity and Inter-organizational Collaboration" 8 (8): 71-89, 2006

32 Bodnaruk, A., "Proximity Always Matter: Local Bias when the Set of Local Companies Changes" 13 (13): 629-656, 2009

33 Greitemeyel, J., "Preference-consistent Evaluation of Information in the Hidden Profile Paradigm: Shared Group Level Explanations for the Dominance of Shared Information in Group Decisions" 84 : 322-339, 2003

34 Zakay, D., "Post-Decision Confidence and Conflict Experienced in a Choice Process" 58 : 75-80, 1985

35 Sepucha, Karen R., "Policy Support for Patient-Centered Care: The Need for Measurable Improvements in Decision Quality" 54-62, 2004

36 Feldman, Martha S., "Organizational Routines as a Source of Continuous Change" 11 : 611-629, 2000

37 Pentland, Brian T., "Organizational Routines as Grammars of Action" 39 : 484-510, 1994

38 Torre, A., "On the Analytical Dimension of Proximity Dynamics" 34 (34): 169-180, 2000

39 Kennedy, Andrew, "On What Basis should the Effectiveness of Decision Aids be Judged?" 6 (6): 255-268, 2003

40 Scholten, Lotte, "Motivated Information Processing and Group Decision-making: Effects of Process Accountability on Information Processing and Decision Quality" 43 : 539-552, 2007

41 Thaler, Richard H., "Mental Accounting and Consumer Choice" 4 (4): 199-214, 1985

42 Ivkovich, Z., "Local does as Local is: Information Content of the Geography of Individual Investors’ Common Stock Investments" 60 (60): 267-306, 2005

43 Baik, B., "Local Institution Investors. Informational Asymmetries, and Equity Returns" 97 : 81-106, 2010

44 Bishop, G. D., "Informational Influence in Group Discussion" 12 : 92-104, 1974

45 Hwang, Mark I., "Information Dimension, Information Overload and Decision Quality" 25 (25): 213-218, 1999

46 Pachella, R., "Human Information Processing: Tutorials in Performance and Cognition" Erlbaum 1974

47 Schulz-Hardt, Stefan, "Group Decision Making in Hidden Profile Situation: Dissent as a Facilitator for Decision Quality" 91 (91): 1080-1093, 2006

48 Choi, Jeong-Hag, "Geographic Proximity between Auditor and Client: How does It Impact Audit Quality?" 31 (31): 43-72, 2012

49 Brown, R., "Further Comment on the Risky-shift" 29 : 468-470, 1965

50 Laursen, Keld, "Exploring the Effect of Geographical Proximity and University Quality on University-Industry Collaboration in the United Kingdom" 45 (45): 507-523, 2011

51 Shields, M. D., "Effects of Information Supply and Demand on Judgment Accuracy: Evidence from Corporate Managers" 58 : 284-303, 1983

52 Diederich, A., "Dynamic Stochastic Models for Decision Making under Time Constraints" 41 : 260-274, 1997

53 Kedia, S., "Do the SEC’s Enforcement Preferences Affect Corporate Misconduct?" 51 (51): 259-278, 2011

54 Schachter, S., "Deviation, Rejection, and Communication" 46 : 190-207, 1951

55 Pava, Calvin H. P., "Designing Managerial and Professional Work for High Performance: A Sociotechnical Approach" (Spring) : 126-135, 1983

56 Keinan, G., "Decision making under Stress: Scanning of Alternatives under Physical Threat" 64 : 219-228, 1987

57 Janis, I. L., "Decision Making: A Psychological Analysis of Conflict. Choice, and Commitment" Free Press 1977

58 Busemeyer, J. R., "Decision Making under Uncertainty: A Comparison of Simple Scalability, Fixed-sample, and Sequential-sampling Models" 11 : 538-564, 1985

59 Young, Diana L., "Decision Making under Time Pressure, Modeled in a Prospect Theory Framework" 118 : 179-188, 2012

60 Busemeyer, J. R., "Decision Field Theory: A Dynamic-cognitive Approach to Decision Making in an Uncertain Environment" 100 : 432-459, 1993

61 Cheng, Joseph L. C., "Coordination and Output Attainment in Work Units Performing Nonroutine Tasks: A Cross-National Study" 6 : 23-39, 1985

62 Burnstein, E., "Contemporary Problems in Group Decision-making" Academic Press 1982

63 Stasser, G., "Computer Simulation as a Research Tool: The DISSCUSS Mode of Group Decision Making" 24 : 393-422, 1998

64 Svenson, O., "Choices and Judgements of Incompletely Described Decision Alternatives under Time Pressure" 75 : 153-169, 1990

65 Sutter, M., "Bargaining under Time Pressure in an Experimental Ultimatum Game" 81 : 341-347, 2003

66 Woodworth, R. S., "Accuracy of Voluntary Movements" 3 : 1-101, 1899

67 Liu, Charles C., "Accounting for Speed-Accuracy Tradeoff in Perceptual Learning" 61 : 107-114, 2012

68 Smith, Amy K., "A Model of Customer Satisfaction with Service Encounters Involving Failure and Recovery" 36 : 356-372, 1999

69 Maxham, James G., Ⅲ, "A Longitudinal Study of Complaining Customers’ Evaluations of Multiple Service Failures and Recovery Efforts" 66 : 57-71, 2003

70 DeSanctis, G., "A Foundation for the Study of Group Decision Support System" 33 : 589-609, 1987

71 Smith, J. F., "A Cost-Benefit Mechanism for Selecting Problem-Solving Strategies: Some Extensions and Empirical Tests" 29 : 370-396, 1982