Rural students’ evolving educational aspirations and the sense of ‘fit’ in the changing context of China’s higher education: a life history approach

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Since the restoration of the Gaokao (College Entrance Examination) in 1977 and the nationwide higher education expansion that started in 1998, millions of rural students have enrolled in urban universities. Though Chinese rural students’ educational trajectories have received extensive attention, their subjective experiences in the rapidly changing context of the higher education system remain insufficiently represented in the literature. This paper utilises a life history approach to explore three successful rural students’ journeys towards and through higher education, graduating from university in the 1980s, 1990s, and 2000s. Through interweaving the social context and individual accounts in this paper, I examine how educational aspirations (as individual choices and strategies) are shaped by changes in the social milieus in which one is situated and how rural students perceive classed differences in the context of an expanding urban–rural divide. I highlight the point that rural families’ aspirations towards higher education are not simply personal preference but rather are constructed within the nexus of perceived limitations and opportunities and are complexly shaped by the social and economic context. I argue that, though the forms of symbolic domination might vary across the studied timeframe—from clothes to extra-curricular activities to comprehensive ability—the rural students’ disadvantaged situation in the urban university remained largely unchanged.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Cheng, M., "“College Material” and their cultural production: A narrative study of contemporary rural kids’ growth" China Social Sciences Press 2018

2 Liu, Y., "‘Knowledge changes fate’ or ‘education’ ‘Knowledge changes destiny’ or ‘Education leaves man untouched by fate?’" 1 (1): 85-, 2015

3 Reay*, D., "‘It’s all becoming a habitus’: Beyond the habitual use of habitus in educational research" 25 (25): 431-444, 2004

4 Hutchings, M., "‘Higher than Einstein’: Constructions of going to university among working-class non-participants" 16 (16): 69-91, 2001

5 Reay, D., "‘Fitting in’ or ‘standing out’: Working‐class students in UK higher education" 36 (36): 107-124, 2010

6 Xie, A., "‘Education is useless’ or ‘education is hopeless’: A reconceptualization of education for the rural underclass" 3 : 92-108, 2017

7 Reay, D, "‘Always knowing’ and ‘never being sure’: Familial and institutional habituses and higher education choice education choice" 2006

8 Lehmann, W., "Working-class students, habitus, and the development of student roles: A Canadian case study" 33 (33): 527-546, 2012

9 Wanhua Ma, "Why the rural poor get fewer opportunities to leading research universities?" 교육연구소 13 (13): 263-271, 2012

10 Liu, Y, "When choices become chances: Extending boudon’s positional theory to understand university choices in contemporary China" 62 (62): 125-146, 2018

11 Archer, L., "University’s not for Me-I’m a Nike Person’: Urban, Working-Class Young People’s Negotiations of Style’, Identity and Educational Engagement" 41 (41): 219-237, 2007

12 Li, A., "Unfulfilled promise of educational meritocracy? Academic ability and China’s urban-rural gap in access to higher education" 51 (51): 115-146, 2019

13 Haveman, R., "The role of higher education in social mobility" 16 (16): 125-150, 2006

14 Ju, S., "The regional disparity of China’s CEE enrolment under equal educational opportunity" 1 : 30-35, 2005

15 Bourdieu, P., "The logic of practice" Stanford University Press 1990

16 Bourdieu, P., "The inheritors: French students and their relation to culture" The University of Chicago Press 1979

17 Deng, Z., "The impact of the cultural revolution on trends in educational attainment in the People’s Republic of China" 1997

18 Meng, X., "The impact of interrupted education on subsequent educational attainment: A cost of the Chinese cultural revolution" 50 (50): 935-959, 2002

19 Bourdieu, P., "The genesis of the concepts of habitus and field" 2 (2): 11-24, 1985

20 Bourdieu, P., "The forms of capital (1986)" 1 : 81-93, 2011

21 Bourdieu, P., "The forms of capital" 1 : 81-93, 1986

22 Li, F. L., "The effect of parents’ education on children’s studies at school and social activities" 48 (48): 143-156, 2015

23 Shi, W., "The current situation, main reason of regional disparity in Gaokao and key points in dealing with this problem" 1 : 37-40, 2013

24 Bell, D, "The coming of post-industrial society" Basic Books 1973

25 Ross, H., "The college entrance examination in China: An overview of its social-cultural foundations, existing problems, and consequences: Guest editors’ introduction" 43 (43): 3-10, 2010

26 Xie, A., "The children of humble families: Cultural capital deprivation and elite field adaptation: A follow-up study of rural students in “985” universities" 4 : 45-64, 2018

27 Tierney, W. G., "The SAGE encyclopedia of social research methods" Sage 2018

28 Xu, C. L, "Tackling rural-urban inequalities through educational mobilities: Rural-origin Chinese academics from impoverished backgrounds navigating higher education" 4 (4): 179-202, 2020

29 Xie, A., "Successful rural students in China’s elite universities: Habitus transformation and inevitable hidden injuries?" 80 (80): 21-36, 2020

30 Li, C. L., "Socio-political changes and inequality of educational opportunity" 3 : 86-98, 2003

31 Li, H, "Rural students’ experiences in a Chinese elite university: Capital, habitus and practices" 34 (34): 829-847, 2013

32 Postiglione, G. A., "Rural students in a Chinese top-tier university: Family background, school effects, and academic performance" 50 (50): 63-74, 2017

33 Kong, P. A., "Routledge Contemporary China Series 134" Routledge 2015

34 Reay, D., "Rethinking social class: Qualitative perspectives on class and gender" 32 (32): 259-275, 1998

35 Scandone, B., "Re-thinking aspirations through habitus and capital: The experiences of British-born Bangladeshi women in higher education" 18 (18): 518-540, 2018

36 Bourdieu, P., "Practical reason: On the theory of action" Stanford University Press 1998

37 Bourdieu, P., "Physical space, social space and habitus" 10 : 87-101, 1996

38 Liao, Q., "Learning experiences of rural students in elite universities: Reflections on the theory of production" 37 (37): 77-84, 2016

39 Kwong, J., "Is everyone equal before the system of grades: Social background and opportunities in China" 34 (34): 93-108, 1983

40 Xie, A, "Inside the college gate: Rural students and their academic and social success" 2015

41 Bourdieu, P., "In other words: Essays towards a reflexive sociology" Stanford University Press 1990

42 Chen, J, "Hysteresis effects and emotional suffering: Chinese rural students’ first encounters with the urban university"

43 Lan Yu ; Hoi K. Suen, "Historical and Contemporary Exam-driven Education Fever in China" 한국교육개발원 2 (2): 17-33, 2005

44 Mok, K. H., "Higher education, changing labour market and social mobility in the era of massification in China" 29 (29): 77-97, 2016

45 Clandinin, D. J., "Handbook of narrative inquiry: Mapping a methodology" Sage Publications 2006

46 Lehmann, W., "Habitus transformation and hidden injuries: Successful working-class university students" 87 (87): 1-15, 2014

47 Bai, L, "Graduate unemployment: Dilemmas and challenges in China’s move to mass higher education" 185 : 128-144, 2006

48 Kipnis, A., "Governing educational desire: Culture, politics, and schooling in China" University of Chicago Press 2011

49 Xie, A, "Family strategies, guanxi, and school success in Rural China" Routledge 2016

50 Coleman, J. S., "Families and schools" 16 (16): 32-38, 1987

51 Liu, J., "Expansion of higher education in China and inequality in entrance opportunities: 1978–2003" 3 : 158-179, 2006

52 Mok, K. H., "Employability and mobility in the valorisation of higher education qualifications: The experiences and reflections of Chinese students and graduates" 38 (38): 264-281, 2016

53 Buchmann, C., "Education and stratification in developing countries: A review of theories and research" 27 : 77-102, 2001

54 Bourdieu, P., "Distinction: A social critique of the judgement of taste" Harvard University Press 1984

55 Reay, D., "Degrees of choice : Class, race, gender and higher education" Trentham Books 2005

56 Thøgersen, S, "Critical readings on the communist party of China Vol. 4" Brill 1117-1140, 2017

57 Harker, R., "Code and habitus: Comparing the accounts of Bernstein and Bourdieu" 14 (14): 169-178, 1993

58 Chen, J, "Clothing and identity: Chinese rural students’ embodied transformations in the urban university" 2021

59 Li, M., "Citizenship education and migrant youth in China: Pathways to the urban underclass" Routledge 2015

60 Liu, Y, "Choices, risks and rational conformity: Extending Boudon’s positional theory to understand higher education choices in contemporary China" 77 : 525-540, 2018

61 Chen, J, "Chinese rural students’ social mobility experiences through higher education across four decades: from 1980s to 2010s" University College London 2021

62 Li, H, "Changing status, entrenched inequality: How English language becomes a Chinese form of cultural capital" 2020

63 Stahl, G, "Bourdieu, habitus and social research" Palgrave Macmillan 21-38, 2015

64 Ferrarotti, F., "Biography and the social sciences" 1 : 57-80, 1983

65 Vincent, C., "Being strategic , being watchful , being determined : Black middle-class parents and schooling class parents and schooling" 2012

66 Bourdieu, P., "An invitation to reflexive sociology" University of Chicago press 1992