예술비평의 역할과 비평적 이유들의 추론적 성격 = The Role of Art Criticism and the Nature of Reasons in the Art-Critical Reasoning

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Art criticism is an activity which reaches a conclusion on the basis of the relevant critical reasons provided that it follows the norm of rationality. These critical reasons may be regarded either as participating in logical inferences (‘the theoretical model’) or as reasons for action (‘the practical model’). Whichever model we may take, it depends on how we think about the role of art criticism and whether there are general principles of criticism. In this paper, first of all, I critically examine a practical model by Anthony Cross and a theoretical model by Noël Carroll, respectively. Second, I investigate a hybrid theory by Emine Tuna, a particularist, whose account attempts to incorporate the theoretical and the practical model, and criticize that her revisionist version cannot be successful. Finally, I argue that the particularist may still have an alternative revisionist account if he introduces presumption as a means of replacing general principles in critical reasoning.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 임마누엘 칸트, "판단력 비판" 아카넷 2009

2 박배형, "칸트 미학과 인식의 문제" 한국미학회 84 (84): 115-146, 2018

3 하선규, "칸트 미학과 바움가르텐 미학의 연관성에 관한 연구 - 칸트 전(前)비판기의 미학적 논의와 『판단력비판』을 중심으로" 한국미학예술학회 46 : 3-44, 2016

4 임일환, "예술 가치론과 pro tanto, prima facie 이유들" 한국미학회 82 (82): 185-233, 2016

5 이해완, "비평철학" 북코리아 [서울] 2015

6 박정훈, "감성학과 취미비판 - 바움가르텐과 칸트의 미학 구상" 한국미학회 83 (83): 37-73, 2017

7 Rescher, Nicholas, "Presumption and the Practices of Tentative Cognition" Cambridge University Press 2006

8 Ziff, Paul, "Philosophic Turnings" Cornell University Press 1966

9 Carroll, Noël, "On Criticism" Routledge 2009

10 Hopkins, Robert, "Knowing Art: Essays in Aesthetics and Epistemology" Springer 2007

11 Dancy, Jonathan, "Ethics without Principles" Clarendon; Oxford University Press 2004

12 Whately, Richard, "Elements of Rhetoric" Southern Illinois University Press 1963

13 Kant, Immanuel, "Critique of the Power of Judgment" Cambridge University Press 2000

14 Isenberg, Arnold, "Critical Communication" 58 (58): 1949

15 Fried, Michael, "Art and Objecthood" 5 (5): 1967

16 Cross, Anthony, "Art Criticism as Practical Reasoning" 57 (57): 2017

17 Sibley, Frank, "Approach to Aesthetics: Collected Papers on Philosophical Aesthetics" Oxford University Press 2001

18 Kauffeld, Fred J., "Anyone Who Has a View: Theoretical Contributions to the Study of Argumentation" Kluwer 2003

19 Danto, Arthur, "After the End of Art: Contemporary Art and the Pale of History" Princeton University Press 1997

20 Stolnitz, Jerome, "Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art Criticism: A Critical Introduction" Houghton Mifflin 1960

21 Berger, John, "About Looking" Vintage International 1980

22 Godden, David M., "A Theory of Presumption for Everyday Argumentation" 15 (15): 2007

23 Tuna, Emine H., "A Kantian Hybrid Theory of Art Criticism: A Particularist Appeal to the Generalists" 74 (74): 2016