Building education groups as school collaboration for education improvement: a case study of stakeholder interactions in District A of Chengdu

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

School collaboration has become a popular approach for education improvement in global education reform. This study examined the dynamics of stakeholder school collaboration in China to improve public education using a case study focused on an Education Group government initiative in Chengdu, China. Frist an introduction to a global reform for education improvement through school collaboration is given, followed by a review of global reform for school collaboration and Hargreaves and Shirley’s discussion on design and innovation for school networks and collaboration to visualize the framework for the interpretation of the stakeholders’ school collaborative interactions. Then, the school collaboration for education improvement in China is examined in detail based on 20 interviews with stakeholders from educational authorities, the lead and member schools involved in the establishment of the Education Groups in Chengdu, China. The interviews were designed based on a review of policy documents about construction of the Education Groups in Chengdu. The fndings revealed that the establishment of the Education Groups in Chengdu was driven by both top-down initiatives and bottom-up innovations, and while there had been some success in improving education quality in the lower performing schools, the stakeholder interactions had been hindered by the lack of policy coordination within and beyond the education reforms. It was concluded that a collective institutional context was needed to foster the shared values and trust needed between all stakeholders and promote the sustainable reform of the Education Groups to ensure education equity and quality.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Ainscow, M., "Using collaboration as a strategy for improving schools in complex and challenging circumstances: What makes the diference?" National College for School Leadership 2006

2 Meng, F., "Three modes of running schools by group in elementary education in China" 441 : 40-45, 2016

3 Yong, G. L. C. C, "The role of heads of department in cluster secondary schools in Singapore" University of Leicester 2006

4 Gao, Y., "The present situation and developmental trend of educational groups in China (in Chinese)" 22 (22): 36-42, 2011

5 Hargreaves, A., "The global fourth way: The quest for educational excellence" Corwin 2012

6 Hargreaves, A., "The fourth way: The inspiring future of educational change" Corwin 2009

7 OECD, "Strong performers and successful reformers in education: Lessons from PISA for the United States" OECD 2011

8 Weick, K, "Sensemaking in organizations" Sage Publications 1995

9 Armstrong, P. W., "School-toschool collaboration in England: A confgurative review of the empirical evidence" 2021

10 Armstrong, P. W., "School-to-school support within a competitive education system : Views from the inside" 29 (29): 614-633, 2018

11 Jensen, B., "School turnaround in Shanghai: The empowered-management program approach to improving school performance" Center for American Progress 2013

12 West, M., "School leadership-international perspectives" Springer 1-18, 2010

13 Keddie, A., "School autonomy, accountability and collaboration:A critical review" 47 (47): 1-17, 2015

14 Gu, M., "Portraits of Chinese schools" Higher Education Press & Springer 2017

15 Zhong, K., "Paired assistance in China: Origins, formation and development" 2013 (2013): 14-24, 2013

16 The Central Committee of CCP, & The State Council, "Outline of national medium-term and long-term program for education reform and development" The Central Committee of CCP & The State Council 2010

17 Ministry of Education, Ministry of Finance, "Opinions on rotation of school leaders and teachers in compulsory education schools at county (district) level" Ministry of Education 2014

18 Chengdu City Education Bureau, "Opinions on promoting development of “Education Groups”" Chengdu City Education Bureau 2009

19 Chengdu City Education Bureau, "Opinions on further improvement of development of Education Groups" Chengdu City Education Bureau 2016

20 Ministry of Education, "Opinions on enhancing the balanced development of compulsory education" Ministry of Education 2005

21 The General Ofce of the Central Committee of CPC, "Opinions on deepening reform of education system and mechanism" The General Ofce of the Central Committee of CPC & The General Ofce of the State Council 2017

22 The State Education Commission, "Notifcation of minutes of national conference on one-on-one educational assistance" The State Education Commission 1994

23 Hayes, G., "Local partnerships: Blowing in the wind of national policy changes" 39 (39): 425-446, 2013

24 Tan, C., "Learning from Shanghai: Lessons on achieving education success" Springer Singapore 2013

25 Hadfeld, M., "Leading school-based networks" Routledge 2009

26 The National People’s Congress, "Law of regional autonomy for ethnic minorities in the People’s Republic of China" The National People’s Congress 1984

27 Liu, J., "Inequality in public school admission in urban China:Discourses" Springer 2018

28 Muijs, D, "Improving schools through collaboration: A mixed methods study of school-to-school partnerships in the primary sector" 41 (41): 563-586, 2015

29 Liang, X., "How Shanghai does it:Insights and lessons from the highest-ranking education system in the world" World Bank Group 2016

30 Befy, M., "Has the “Ambition Success Networks” educational program achieved its ambition?" 111-112 : 271-293, 2013

31 Sato, M., "Gako wo kaigakusuru: Manabi no kyodotai no kosou to jisen (Reforming schools: concepts of Learning Community and its practices)" Iwanami Shoten 2012

32 Yang, X., "Exploring the new mechanisms of balanced high quality development of regional compulsory education: An example of collective school running" 24 : 1-9, 2014

33 Zhou, Z., "Equity in excellence:Experiences of East Asian high-performing education systems" Springer 27-41, 2019

34 OECD, "Equity and quality in education: Supporting disadvantaged students and schools" OECD 2012

35 Armstrong, P., "Efective school partneships and collaboration for school improvement: A review of the evidence" Department for Education 2015

36 Yuan, Z, "Education quality as the priority for urban-rural integration" Educational Science Publishing House 2012

37 Shi, G., "Education Groups: Time shift of balanced development of education" Zhejing University Press 2011

38 Tan, C., "Dynamics of change: Decentralised centralism of education in Singapore" 8 (8): 155-168, 2007

39 Han, Z., "Contemporary value systems in China" China Social Sciences Press & Springer 2018

40 Liu, J, "Constructing resource sharing collaboration for quality public education in urban China: Case study of school alliance in Beijing" 59 : 9-19, 2018

41 Chapman, C., "Collaborative school turnaround:A study of the impact of school federations on student outcomes" 12 (12): 200-226, 2013

42 Muijs, D., "Collaboration and networking in education" Springer 2011

43 The General Ofce of the Central Committee of CPC, "China’s educational modernization 2035" The General Ofce of the Central Committee of CPC & The General Ofce of the State Council 2019

44 Group of Book Series of Comprehensive Education Reform of Chengdu, "Chengxiang Yiti Ronghe Fazhan: Chengdu Shi Mingxiao Jietuan Fazhan Shijian Yanjiu (Integrated Development of Urban and Rural Areas: A study on the practice of Chengdu Elite School Groups)" People’s Publishing House 2019

45 Ainscow, M., "Changing education systems: A research-based approach" Routledge 2020

46 Liu, J, "Annual report on China’s education (2019)" Social Sciences Academic Press 204-219, 2019

47 Gergen, K. J, "An invitation to social construction" SAGE Publications 2015

48 Burr, V, "An introduction to social constructionism" Routledge 1995

49 Liu, X., "A best-know school group: “Chengdu Model” with balanced coverage of high quality education" 29 (29): 15-19, 2015