Decentralization, legitimacy, and democracy in post-Soviet Central Asia

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

During the 1990s, a conventional wisdom emerged, based on literature going back decades, that political decentralization might be among the most effective forces for democratization. If ordinary people could participate in autonomous local governments, democracy would be built from the ground up, ultimately shaping the entire political system. Once decentralization reforms were implemented across the world, however, the results were disappointing. Authoritarianism not only thrived at the local level, it could also undermine democratization at the national level. Thus, local-national transference still held, but sometimes as a poison. In this context, the case of post-Soviet Kyrgyzstan is an anomaly. Here, the relative success of political decentralization—rather than its failure—nevertheless failed to spur democratization at the national level. I argue that this is because decentralization allowed national authorities to appease international donors while they consolidated their own power. Moreover, while decentralization empowered local communities, it did so in ways that personalized local authority and pitted local and national authorities against one another, resulting in intense localism and antagonistic center-local relations that undermined any democratic transference. The case study findings are based on ten months of field research, which includes interviews with local and national officials, ordinary villagers, and representatives of NGOs and international organizations.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 The World Bank, "World Development Report, 1997: The state in a changing world" Oxford University Press 1997

2 Radnitz, S., "Weapons of the wealthy: Predatory regimes and elite-led protests in central Asia" Cornell University Press 2010

3 Herrfahrdt-Pahle, E., "Two steps forward, one step back: ¨Institutional change in Kyrgyz water governance" Springer 277-301, 2008

4 Robert T. Gannett, "Tocqueville and Local Government: Distinguishing Democracy's Second Track" Cambridge University Press (CUP) 67 (67): 721-736, 2005

5 Massicard, E., "The uzbek mahalla: Between state and society" Routledge 205-218, 2003

6 Manor, J., "The political economy of democratic decentralization" The World Bank 1999

7 Almond, G. A., "The civic culture: Political attitudes and democracy in five nations" Sage Publications, Inc 1963

8 Eugene Huskey, "The Barriers to Intra-Opposition Cooperation in the Post-Communist World: Evidence from Kyrgyzstan" Informa UK Limited 26 (26): 228-262, 2010

9 Cornelius, W. A., "Subnational politics and democratization:Tensions between center and periphery in the Mexican political system" University of California 3-16, 1999

10 Ayten Alkan, "Strengthening Local Democracy or Neo-Liberal Conversions? New Local Governmental Legislation in Turkey" Institut Za Lokalno Samoupravo in Javna Narocila Maribor 9 (9): 23-38, 2011

11 Fattakhov, B., "Stanovlenie Mestnogo Samoupravleniya v Kyrgyzstane" (15-16) : 2013

12 Umbetalieva, T., "Sotsialno-ekonomicheskaya I obshchestvenno politicheskaya situatsiia v strane: Politicheskaya situatsiia v strane glazami kazakhstantsev" AAO 2009

13 Siegel, D., "Social ties and state formation in post-soviet central Asia" City University 2016

14 Baimyrzaeva, M., "Shortcomings of institutional reform in public sector governance: The case of Kyrgyzstan" University of Southern California 2010

15 Levada-Center, "Russian Public Opinion, 2018" Moxcow 2019

16 The World Bank, "Rural development: From vision to action" The World Bank 1997

17 Humphrey, C., "Rethinking bribery in contemporary Russia" Martin’s Press 216-241, 2000

18 Babken Babajanian, "Promoting empowerment? The World Bank's Village Investment Project in Kyrgyzstan" Informa UK Limited 34 (34): 499-515, 2015

19 Boris-mathieu Pétric, "Post-Soviet Kyrgyzstan or the birth of a globalized protectorate" Informa UK Limited 24 (24): 319-332, 2005

20 Dahl, R. A., "Polyarchy : Participation and opposition" Yale University Press 1972

21 RAFIS ABAZOV, "Policy of economic transition in Kyrgyzstan" Informa UK Limited 18 (18): 197-223, 1999

22 Jonathan T. Hiskey, "Pitfalls of power to the people: Decentralization, local government performance, and system support in Bolivia" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 37 (37): 64-88, 2003

23 Hale, H. E., "Patronal politics: Eurasian regime dynamics in comparative perspective" Cambridge University Press 2015

24 Gerd Schonwalder, "New Democratic Spaces at the Grassroots? Popular Participation in Latin American Local Governments" Wiley 28 (28): 753-770, 1997

25 PATRICK HELLER, "Moving the State: The Politics of Democratic Decentralization in Kerala, South Africa, and Porto Alegre" SAGE Publications 29 (29): 131-163, 2001

26 Alymkulov, E., "Local government in the Kyrgyz republic" Local Government and Public Service Reform Initiative 2001

27 A. Vetter, "Local Political Competence in Europe: A Resource of Legitimacy for Higher Levels of Government?" Oxford University Press (OUP) 14 (14): 3-18, 2002

28 Jonathan T. Hiskey, "Local Context and Democratization in Mexico" Wiley 49 (49): 57-71, 2005

29 Ibraimova, A., "Legal and institutional framework for empowerment of rural communities in the Kyrgyz republic" LIT Verlag 2009

30 Anderson, J., "Kyrgyzstan: Central Asia’s Island of de mocracy" Harwood Academic Publishers 1999

31 Marat, E., "Kyrgyzstan. Nations in Transit" Freedom House Press 2012

32 Marat, E., "Kyrgyzstan. Nations in Transit" Freedom House Press 2018

33 Marat, E., "Kyrgyzstan. Nations in Transit" Freedom House Press 2017

34 Mahabat Baimyrzaeva, "Kyrgyzstan's Public Sector Reforms: 1991–2010" Informa UK Limited 34 (34): 555-566, 2011

35 International Crisis Group., "Kyrgyzstan at ten: Trouble in the “Island of democracy”" ICG 2001

36 Freedom House, "Kyrgyzstan" Freedom House 2003

37 International Republican Institute., "Kazakhstan national opinion poll"

38 Dave, B., "Kazakhstan Nations in Transit" Freedom House Press 2013

39 Timothy Frye, "Is Putin’s popularity real?" Informa UK Limited 33 (33): 1-15, 2016

40 Baimyrzaeva, M., "Institutional reforms in Kyrgyzstan" 4 (4): 29-33, 2005

41 National Statistics Committee of the Kyrgyz Republic, "Indeks lichnogo doveriya grazhdanna k gosudarstvu za II kvartal 2013g"

42 UNDP, "Human development as the focus of local self-governance: National human development report of the Kyrgyz republic" United Nations Development Programme

43 Grindle, M. S., "Going local: Decentralization, democra tization, and the promise of good governance" Princeton University Press 2007

44 The World Bank, "FY19 Uzbekistan: Country opinion survey report" The World Bank 2019

45 Diamond, L., "Developing democracy: Toward consolidation" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1999

46 USAID, "Democracy, human rights and governance Assessment of the Kyrgyz republic" 2013

47 Vetter, A., "Democracy versus efficiency? Comparing local government reforms across Europe" VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften 11-28, 2003

48 UCLG, "Decentralization and local democracy in the world" The World Bank 2008

49 UNDP, "Decentralised governance for development: A combined practice note on decentralisation" local governance and urban/rural development

50 Levitsky, S., "Competitive authoritarianism:Hybrid regimes after the cold war" Cambridge University Press 2010

51 Lucy Earle, "Community development, ‘tradition’ and the civil society strengthening agenda in Central Asia" Informa UK Limited 24 (24): 245-260, 2005

52 McGlinchey, E., "Chaos, violence, dynasty: Politics and Islam in central Asia" University of Pittsburgh Press 2011

53 Paul D. Hutchcroft, "Centralization and Decentralization in Administration and Politics: Assessing Territorial Dimensions of Authority and Power" Wiley 14 (14): 23-53, 2001

54 Olcott, M. B., "Central Asia’s new states: Independence, foreign policy, and regional security" United States Institute of Peace Press 1996

55 George, A. L., "Case studies and theory development in the social sciences" MIT Press 2005

56 Mukanova, N., "Assessing ‘new public management’ reforms in Kyrgyzstan" Open Society Institute 2008

57 Fraser, A., "Aid-recipient sovereignty in historical context" Oxford University Press 45-73, 2009

58 Snyder, R., "After the state withdraws: Neoliberalism and subnational authoritarian regimes in Mexico" University of California 295-341, 1999

59 ARIS, "About us"