경련(Seizure)과 실신(Syncope)의 감별진단을 위한 암모니아와 유산의 유용성 = An Examination of Serum Ammonia and Lactate for Differentiating Seizure and Syncope

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: Seizure and syncope are main causes of patient visits to an emergency department (ED). However, differentiating two diseases through history taking and several ancillary tests is difficult in an ED. Some reports have claimed that ammonia or lactate could differentiate between seizure and other medical diseases. Therefore, this study evaluated the ability of ammonia and lactate to differentiate seizure and syncope.
Methods: We reviewed the medical records of 388 patients who visited an ED with seizure or syncope. There were 271patients in the seizure group (69.8%) and 117 patients in the syncope group (30.2%). Ammonia and lactate levels were compared between the two groups. The optimal level of ammonia and lactate, and their sensitivity and specificity,were evaluated to determine their ability to differentiate seizure and syncope.
Results: There were more male in seizure group (66%),but the average age was higher in the syncope group (51±21 yrs) (p<0.05). The time interval from symptom to ED was similar between the two groups (seizure group: 213±803 min and syncope group: 184±512 min, p=0.724). The mean ammonia level in the seizure group was higher than the syncope group (85±86 μg/dl and 49±29 μg/dl, respectively,p<0.001). The mean lactate level was also higher in the seizure group than the syncope group (3.5±2.9 mmol/L and 1.6±1.5 mmol/L, respectively, p<0.05). When the cutoff value for ammonia was 50 μg/dL [Area under curve (AUC): 0.617, 95% CI: 0.556-0.678] the sensitivity was 61%and the specificity was 52%. When the cut-off value for lactate was 2 mmol/L [AUC: 0.745, 95% CI: 0.692-0.798] the sensitivity was 60% and the specificity was 76%.
Conclusion: Serum ammonia or lactate may serve as an ancillary method for differentiating seizure and syncope, but their sole application is unacceptable due to their low sensitivity and specificity.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Tan C, "Validation of the san francisco syncope rule in two hospital emergency departments in an asian population" 20 : 487-497, 2013

2 Petkar S, "Transient loss of consciousness: summary of NICE guidance" 99 : 901-903, 2013

3 Zhang Q, "The inotropic effects of ammonia on isolated perfused rat hearts and the mechanisms involved" 214 : 4048-4054, 2011

4 Medeiros WM, "The dysfunction of ammonia in heart failure increases with increasing the intensity of resistance exercise even with the use of appropriate drug therapy" 2012

5 Yilmaz S, "Syncope or seizure? The diagnostic value of synchronous tilt testing and video-EEG monitoring in children with transient loss of consciousness" 24 : 93-96, 2012

6 Sheldon R, "Syncope diagnostic scores" 55 : 390-395, 2013

7 McKeon A, "Seizure versus syncope" 5 : 171-180, 2006

8 Hazouard E, "Losing consciousness: role of the venous lactate levels in the diagnosis of convulsive crises" 27 : 604-607, 1998

9 Task Force for the Diagnosis and Management of Syncope, "Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of syncope (version 2009)" 30 : 2631-2671, 2009

10 Gauer RL, "Evaluation of syncope" 84 : 640-650, 2011

11 Andersen LW, "Etiology and Therapeutic Approach to Elevated Lactate Levels" 88 : 1127-1140, 2013

12 Rodrigues Tda R, "Epilepsy or syncope? An analysis of 55 consecutive patients with loss of consciousness, convulsions, falls, and no EEG abnormalities" 33 : 804-813, 2010

13 Beghi E, "Diagnosis and treatment of the first epileptic seizure: guidelines of the Italian League against Epilepsy" 47 (47): 2-8, 2006

14 Tomita K, "Clinical significance of plasma ammonia in patients with generalized convulsion" 50 : 2297-2301, 2011