Navigating in a Sea of Plastics: A Critical Reflection on the Legal Responses in the Philippines to Marine Plastic Debris

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

One of the greatest threats to marine biodiversity in our oceans today is plastic debris. A number of international commitments and declarations highlight the need to prioritize actions to address marine plastic pollution. However, actions taken in many countries to minimize plastic waste have not been sufficient. The Philippines, which is among the biodiversity hotspots in the world, has emerged as among the top marine plastic debris polluters with the largest source of single use plastics leaking into the ocean. As one navigates around its over 7,100 islands, one cannot miss the sea of plastics in its oceans and communities. But the Philippines has no overarching national plastics legislation. While national laws exist to tackle solid wastes, pollution in general, and aquatic or marine pollution, these are inadequate to address the growing menace of marine plastic pollution in the country. The 20-year-old national solid waste management law, Ecological Solid Waste Management Act (RA 9003) could, however, provide opportunities to set out a policy framework to address plastic wastes. However, there are gaps in the legal and institutional frameworks. Since majority of plastic wastes in the Philippines come from land-based sources due to the unregulated use and indiscriminate dumping of plastics, an overarching legal framework regulating plastic wastes and coherence of existing laws and regulations on marine pollution are critical. In examining the domestic legal frameworks for marine plastic pollution, key policy and institutional responses have been identified. The existing policy gap can be addressed if the national government sets clear guidelines on the legal provision on ‘non-environmentally acceptable products or packaging.’ Greater coordination by many governmental agencies involved in marine plastic pollution governance is also required. Likewise, it is vital to recognize the important role of local governments in the implementation framework. Lessons can be drawn from jurisprudence as set by the courts in ensuring coordination between national agencies and local governments in accordance with their mandates.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Senate of the Philippines 18th Congress, "Villar eyes law making manufacturers responsible for plastic products’ Press Release"

2 Britta D. Hardesty, "Using numerical model simulations to improve the understanding of micro-plastic distribution and pathways in the marine environment" 4 : 30-, 2017

3 "UNEP/EA.4/Res. 6, on marine plastic debris and microplastics"

4 UNEP/EA. 3/Res. 7, "UNEP/EA.3/Res.7, on marine plastic debris and microplastics"

5 "UNEP/AHEG/2020/4/1/Add.1"

6 "U.N. EA of the UNEP, Ad Hoc Open-Ended Expert Group on Marine Litter and Microplastics 4th Meeting, UNEP/AHEG/2020/4/1/Add.1"

7 "Toxic Substances and Hazardous and Nuclear Wastes Control Act, Rep. Act No. 6969 (Phil.)"

8 Center of International Environmental Law, "Support Grows to Control Plastic Waste in International Trade Treaty"

9 Ocean Conservancy and McKinsey Center for Business and Environment, "Stemming the tide: Land-based strategies for a plastic-free ocean"

10 Shwarz, Anna, "Sources, transport, and accumulation of different types of plastic litter in aquatic environments: a review study" 143 : 92-, 2019

11 Filane Mikee Cervantes, "Solon Urges NSWMC To Provide List of Non-Eco-Friendly Products"

12 Romeo Dizon, "San Fernando hailed for work on zero waste"

13 Laurent C.M. Lebreton, "River plastic emissions to the world’s oceans"

14 Laurent C.M. Lebreton, "River plastic emissions to the world’s oceans"

15 "Revised Coast Guard Law, Pres. Dec. No. 601 (Phil.). Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases (A.M. No. 09-6-8-SC) Extended Producers Responsibility (EPR) Act of 2020, Senate Bill 1331 (Phil.)"

16 Geradin, Damien, "Regulatory Co-opetition: Transcending the Regulatory Competition Debate" 2005

17 "Pollution Control Law, Pres. Dec. No. 984 (Phil.)"

18 Chris Sherrington, "Plastics in the Marine Environment, eunomia"

19 Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives, "Plastics Exposed: How Waste Assessments and Brand Audits Are Helping Philippine Cities Fight Plastic Pollution"

20 Jambeck, Jenna R., "Plastic waste inputs from land into the ocean" 347 : 768-, 2015

21 Wai-Chin Li, "Plastic waste in the marine environment: A review of sources, occurrence and effects" 566 : 333-, 2016

22 Hannah Ritchie, "Plastic Pollution"

23 Convention on Biological Diversity, "Philippines – Main Details"

24 Jun Endo, "Philippines slams the door on world’s plastic waste"

25 "Philippine Fisheries Code, Rep. Act No. 8550, as amended by Rep. Act No. 10654 (Phil.)"

26 "National Solid Waste Management Status Report"

27 Environmental Management Bureau - Department of Environment and Natural Resources, "National Solid Waste Management Status Report"

28 "National Solid Waste Management Commission (NSWMC), Res. No. 19, series of 2009 approving the adoption of Guidelines on the Phasing Out of NEAP Materials"

29 Dexter A See, "NSWMC Urged to Provide List of Non-Environmentally Acceptable Products"

30 "Marine Pollution Decree, Pres. Dec. No. 979 (Phil.)"

31 International Union for Conservation of Nature, "Marine Plastics and Coastal Communities (MARPLASTICCS) Project"

32 Deo Florence L. Onda, "Marine Microbes and Plastic Debris: Research Status and Opportunities" 149 : 71-, 2020

33 "Local Government Code of 1991, Rep. Act No. 7160 (Phil.)"

34 Oceana, "Groups to NSWMC: Plastic Straws and Stirrers in the NEAPP List Most Welcome But Not Enough to Reduce Plastic Pollution"

35 Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity, "Global Biodiversity Outlook 5" 2020

36 Antonia Corinthia C. Naz, "Funding Solid Waste Disposal: A Study from the Philippines" EEPSEA 2006

37 "Expanded National Integrated Protected Areas Act, Rep. Act No. 11038 (Phil.)"

38 "Ecological Solid Waste Management Act of 2000, §3(kk), Rep. Act No. 9003 (Phil.)"

39 Edith Smeets, "Ecological Indicators, vol. 2 of Encyclopedia of Ecology (5 vols.)" Elsevier 867-970, 2008

40 Acosta, Voltaire, "Development of the Philippines National Solid Waste Management Strategy 2012-2016" 16 : 9-, 2012

41 World Wildlife Fund, "Coral Triangle: Facts. See"

42 "Climate Change Act, Rep. Act No. 9279 (Phil.)"

43 "Clean Water Act, Rep. Act No. 9275 (Phil.)"

44 European Environment Agency, "Air Pollution in Europe 1997: Executive Summary"

45 Graeme Macfadyen, "Abandoned, lost or otherwise discarded fishing gear" UNEP/FAO 2009

46 Oceana, "31 LGUs sign nationwide petition to ban single-use plastic"