Evaluation of accuracy of 3D reconstruction images using multi-detector CT and cone-beam CT

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose : This study was performed to determine the accuracy of linear measurements on three-dimensional (3D) images using multi-detector computed tomography (MDCT) and cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT).
Materials and Methods : MDCT and CBCT were performed using 24 dry skulls. Twenty-one measurements were taken on the dry skulls using digital caliper. Both types of CT data were imported into OnDemand software and identification of landmarks on the 3D surface rendering images and calculation of linear measurements were performed. Reproducibility of the measurements was assessed using repeated measures ANOVA and ICC, and the measurements were statistically compared using a Student t-test.
Results : All assessments under the direct measurement and image-based measurements on the 3D CT surface rendering images using MDCT and CBCT showed no statistically difference under the ICC examination. The measurements showed no differences between the direct measurements of dry skull and the image-based measurements on the 3D CT surface rendering images (P¤.05).
Conclusion : Three-dimensional reconstructed surface rendering images using MDCT and CBCT would be appropriate for 3D measurements.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose : This study was performed to determine the accuracy of linear measurements on three-dimensional (3D) images using multi-detector computed tomography (MDCT) and cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT).
Materials and Methods : MDCT and CBCT were performed using 24 dry skulls. Twenty-one measurements were taken on the dry skulls using digital caliper. Both types of CT data were imported into OnDemand software and identification of landmarks on the 3D surface rendering images and calculation of linear measurements were performed. Reproducibility of the measurements was assessed using repeated measures ANOVA and ICC, and the measurements were statistically compared using a Student t-test.
Results : All assessments under the direct measurement and image-based measurements on the 3D CT surface rendering images using MDCT and CBCT showed no statistically difference under the ICC examination. The measurements showed no differences between the direct measurements of dry skull and the image-based measurements on the 3D CT surface rendering images (P¤.05).
Conclusion : Three-dimensional reconstructed surface rendering images using MDCT and CBCT would be appropriate for 3D measurements.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 윤숙자, "안면비대칭 3차원 CT 분석" 대한구강악안면방사선학회 37 (37): 45-51, 2007

2 정호걸, "두개골의 3차원 영상 분석을 위한 전산화단층촬영 방법의 비교 - 상층 두께가 3차원 영상의 계측에 미치는 영향" 대한구강악안면방사선학회 34 (34): 151-157, 2004

3 전국진, "개인용 컴퓨터에서 재구성한 3차원 전산화단층영상의두부계측 재현성" 대한구강악안면방사선학회 33 (33): 6-178, 2003

4 Hildebolt CF, "Validation study of skull three-dimensional computerized tomography measurements" 82 : 283-294, 1990

5 Xia J, "Three-dimensional virtual reality surgical planning and simulation workbench for orthognathic surgery" 15 : 265-282, 2000

6 Westermark A, "Three-dimensional osteotomy planning in maxillofacial surgery including soft tissue prediction" 16 : 100-104, 2005

7 Nagashima M, "Three-dimensional imaging and osteometry of adult human skulls using helical computed tomography" 20 : 291-297, 1998

8 Kau CH, "Three-dimensional cone beam computerized tomography in orthodontics" 32 : 282-293, 2005

9 Cavalcanti MG, "Three-dimensional computed tomography landmark measurement in craniofacial surgical planning: experimental validation in vitro" 57 : 690-694, 1999

10 Olszewski R, "Three-dimensional computed tomography cephalometric craniofacial analysis: experimental validation in vitro" 36 : 828-833, 2007

11 Swennen GR, "Three-dimensional cephalometry: spiral multi-slice vs cone-beam computed tomography" 130 : 410-416, 2006

12 Baumrind S, "The reliability of head film measurements.1. Landmark identification" 60 : 111-127, 1971

13 Olszewski R, "Reproducibility of osseous landmarks used for computed tomography based three-dimensional cephalometric analyses" 38 : 214-221, 2010

14 Laine FJ, "Radiology of maxillofacial trauma" 22 : 145-188, 1993

15 Kim DO, "Quantitative evaluation of acquisition parameters in three-dimensional imaging with multidetector computed tomography using human skull phantom" 15 (15): 254-257, 2002

16 Jung H, "Quantitative analysis of three-dimensional rendered imaging of the human skull acquired from multi-detector row computed tomography" 15 : 232-239, 2002

17 Cavalcanti MG, "Quantitative analysis of spiral computed tomography for craniofacial clinical applications" 27 : 344-350, 1998

18 Richtsmeier JT, "Precision, repeatability, and validation of the localization of cranial landmarks using computed tomography scans" 32 : 217-227, 1995

19 Lagravère MO, "Plane orientation for standardization in 3-dimensional cephalometric analysis with computerized tomography imaging" 129 : 601-604, 2006

20 Hwang HS, "Maxillofacial 3- dimensional image analysis for the diagnosis of facial asymmetry" 130 : 779-785, 2006

21 Brown AA, "Linear accuracy of cone beam CT derived 3D images" 79 : 150-157, 2009

22 Periago DR, "Linear accuracy and reliability of cone beam CT derived 3-dimensional images constructed using an orthodontic volumetric rendering program" 78 : 387-395, 2008

23 Cevidanes LH, "Image analysis and superimposition of 3-dimensional cone-beam computed tomography models" 129 : 611-618, 2006

24 박재우, "Formulation of a reference coordinate system of three-dimensional (3D) head & neck images: Part I. Reproducibility of 3D cephalometric landmarks" 대한치과교정학회 35 (35): 388-397, 2005

25 Ludlow JB, "Dosimetry of 3 CBCT devices for oral and maxillofacial radiology: CB Mercuray, NewTom 3G and i-CAT" 35 : 219-226, 2006

26 Fox LA, "Diagnostic performance of CT, MPR, 3DCT imaging in maxillofacial trauma" 19 : 385-395, 1995

27 Cavalcanti MG, "Craniofacial mea-surements based on 3D-CT volume rendering: implications for clinical applications" 33 : 170-176, 2004

28 Sukovic P, "Cone beam computed tomography in craniofacial imaging" 6 (6): 31-36, 2003

29 Maki K, "Computer-assisted simulations in orthodontic diagnosis and the application of a new cone beam X-ray computed tomography" 6 (6): 95-101, 2003

30 Kragskov J, "Comparison of the reliability of craniofacial anatomic landmarks based on cephalometric radiographs and three-dimensional CT scans" 34 : 111-116, 1997

31 Chien PC, "Comparison of reliability in anatomical landmark identification using two-dimensional digital cephalometrics and three-dimensional cone beam computed tomography in vivo" 38 : 262-273, 2009

32 Williams FL, "Comparison of mandibular landmarks from computed tomography and 3D digitizer data" 16 : 494-500, 2003

33 Kumar V, "Comparison of conventional and cone beam CT synthesized cephalograms" 36 : 263-269, 2007

34 Stratemann SA, "Comparison of cone beam computed tomography imaging with physical measures" 37 : 80-93, 2008

35 Olszewski R, "Accuracy of three-dimensional (3D) craniofacial cephalometric landmarks on a low-dose 3D computed tomograph" 37 : 261-267, 2008

36 Aboudara CA, "A three-dimensional evaluation of the upper airway in adolescents" 6 (6): 173-175, 2003

37 Park SH, "A proposal for a new analysis of craniofacial morphology by 3-dimensional computed tomography" 129 : e23-e34, 2006

38 Mozzo P, "A new volumetric CT machine for dental imaging based on the cone-beam technique: preliminary results" 8 : 1558-1564, 1998

39 Swennen GR, "A new method of 3-D cephalometry Part I: The anatomic Cartesian 3-D reference system" 17 : 314-325, 2006

40 Maeda M, "3D-CT evaluation of facial asymmetry in patients with maxillofacial deformities" 102 : 382-390, 2006

41 Olszewski R, "3D CT-based cephalometric analysis: 3D cephalometric theoretical concept and software" 48 : 853-862, 2006

42 Lopes PM, "3-D volume rendering maxillofacial analysis of angular measurements by multislice CT" 105 : 224-230, 2008