The purpose of this thesis is to provide comprehensive implications for national R&D activities in Korea. In particular, it provides policy-making direction by measuring returns to R&D for the efficient use of government R&D expenditure. I...
http://chineseinput.net/에서 pinyin(병음)방식으로 중국어를 변환할 수 있습니다.
변환된 중국어를 복사하여 사용하시면 됩니다.
다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)
The purpose of this thesis is to provide comprehensive implications for national R&D activities in Korea. In particular, it provides policy-making direction by measuring returns to R&D for the efficient use of government R&D expenditure. I...
The purpose of this thesis is to provide comprehensive implications for national R&D activities in Korea. In particular, it provides policy-making direction by measuring returns to R&D for the efficient use of government R&D expenditure. In addition, comprehensive policy implications were derived from measuring productivity, efficiency, economies of scale and scope for national R&D programs.
First, the returns to R&D were estimated using industry-level data. The empirical analysis was conducted for the Korean manufacturing industry from 2006 to 2017.
Second, the productivity of the national R&D program was analyzed using a metafrontier approach that was assumed differently from the traditional technology convexity. The target of analysis was 6T groups, a promising future technology group, and analyzed using data from 2009 to 2018.
Finally, efficiency, economies of scale and scope were measured using the input distance function based on stochastic frontier analysis.
The main results are as follows: The average returns to R&D of the Korean manufacturing industry was 11.5 ~ 31.9%, and it was verified that it has gradually decreased during the analysis period. However, the returns to R&D of the Korean manufacturing industry has produced positive results, which can be seen as a profit effect from R&D investment. In addition, in the low-tech industry, returns to R&D decreased very rapidly during the analysis period, but in the case of the high-tech industry, it was confirmed that returns to R&D increased or maintained during the analysis period.
The national R&D productivity conducted in the 6T groups was measured to increase by about 13.78% per year on average. This could be seen as a result of advances in metatechnology. In addition, it was confirmed that the recent R&D productivity has increased compared to the past, and the productivity of each group was improved.
The R&D efficiency was measured at about 0.56, and about 72% of the programs had a low efficiency of less than 0.8. Most R&D programs were in the diseconomies of scale, and economies of scale emerged from programs that invested more than 40 billion KRW in government research funding. Also, most R&D programs have demonstrated economies of scope. This shows that government funding is more efficient when diverse outputs are generated through R&D.
목차 (Table of Contents)
1 Griliches , Z.1994 . ProductivityR & D, "the data constraint", The American economic review84 ( 1 ) , 1-23, null
2 C. B., "Rates of return to R &", D investment in the Philippines ( No . 1999-24 ) . PIDS Discussion Paper Series, 1999
3 S. C.Lovell C. A. K., "Stochastic Frontier Analysis", Cambridge University Press , New York, 2000
4 HallB. H.Mairesse , J.Mohnen , P., "Measuring the Returns to R & D", 2010
5 JonesC. I.WilliamsJ. C., "Measuring the social return to R & D", The Quarterly Journal of Economics113 ( 4 ) , 1119-1135, 1998
6 Kwon , H. U., "Measuring the rate of return to R & D", interindustry R & D spillovers in Korean manufacturing industries . Hitotsubashi journal of economics 49-57, 2003
7 rrellM. J ., "The measurement of productive efficiency", Journal of the Royal Statistical Society : Series A ( General ) 120 ( 3 ) , 253-281, 1957
8 Ejermo , O., "Productivity Spillovers of R & D in Sweden", Royal Institute of Technology , CESIS-Centre of Excellence for Science and Innovation Studies, 2004
9 Cho , Y.2004 . R, "D Spillover Effects in Korean Manufacturing Industries", Korea Review of Applied Economics 6 ( 1 ) , 209-232, null
10 Casu , B.Ferrari , A.Zhao , T., "Regulatory reform and productivity change in Indian banking", Review of Economics and Statistics 95 ( 3 ) , 1066-1077, 2013
1 Griliches , Z.1994 . ProductivityR & D, "the data constraint", The American economic review84 ( 1 ) , 1-23, null
2 C. B., "Rates of return to R &", D investment in the Philippines ( No . 1999-24 ) . PIDS Discussion Paper Series, 1999
3 S. C.Lovell C. A. K., "Stochastic Frontier Analysis", Cambridge University Press , New York, 2000
4 HallB. H.Mairesse , J.Mohnen , P., "Measuring the Returns to R & D", 2010
5 JonesC. I.WilliamsJ. C., "Measuring the social return to R & D", The Quarterly Journal of Economics113 ( 4 ) , 1119-1135, 1998
6 Kwon , H. U., "Measuring the rate of return to R & D", interindustry R & D spillovers in Korean manufacturing industries . Hitotsubashi journal of economics 49-57, 2003
7 rrellM. J ., "The measurement of productive efficiency", Journal of the Royal Statistical Society : Series A ( General ) 120 ( 3 ) , 253-281, 1957
8 Ejermo , O., "Productivity Spillovers of R & D in Sweden", Royal Institute of Technology , CESIS-Centre of Excellence for Science and Innovation Studies, 2004
9 Cho , Y.2004 . R, "D Spillover Effects in Korean Manufacturing Industries", Korea Review of Applied Economics 6 ( 1 ) , 209-232, null
10 Casu , B.Ferrari , A.Zhao , T., "Regulatory reform and productivity change in Indian banking", Review of Economics and Statistics 95 ( 3 ) , 1066-1077, 2013
11 Bloom , N.Schankerman , M.van ReenenJ., "Identifying technology spillovers and product market rivalry", Econometrica 81 ( 4 ) , 1347-1393, 2013
12 Li , S.Marinc , M., "Economies of scale and scope in financial market infrastructures", Journal of International Financial MarketsInstitutions and Money 53 , 17-49, 2018
13 D. H.LeeJ. D., "A metafrontier approach for measuring Malmquist productivity index", Empirical economics 38 ( 1 ) , 47-64, 2010
14 ChenS. S.ChenY. S.LiangW. L.Wang , Y., "D spillover effects and firm performance following R & D increases", Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 48 ( 5 ) , 1607-1634, 2013
15 Han , J., "Measuring Social Returns to R & D and Two Countervailing Spillovers", KDI Policy Study , 18, 2018
16 YeoI. K.JohnsonR. A., "A new family of power transformations to improve normality or symmetry", Biometrika 87 ( 4 ) , 954-959 . KOSIS : Korea Statistical Information Service , ( http : //kosis.kr/, 2000
17 Aigner , D. , LovellC. K.Schmidt , P., "Formulation and estimation of stochastic frontier production function models", Journal of econometrics6 ( 1 ) , 21-37, 1977
18 C. W.TingC. T.LinC. H.LinC. T., "Measuring non-convex metafrontier efficiency in international tourist hotels", Journal of the Operational Research Society 64 ( 2 ) , 250-259, 2013
19 Growitsch , C.Wetzel , H., "Testing for economies of scope in European railways : an efficiency analysis", Journal of Transport Economics andPolicy 43 ( 1 ) , 1-24, 2009
20 Cincera , M.Veugelers , R., "Differences in the rates of return to R & D for European and US young leading", 2014
21 KimS. J.JooY. J., "Economies of Scale and Scope in Daejon Citys Medical Services Industry in Korea", Journal of The Korean Regional Development Association 15 ( 3 ) , 81-105, 2003
22 ParkJ. H.Shin , K., "Efficiency of government-sponsored R & D projects : A metafrontier DEA approach", Sustainability 10 ( 7 ) , 2316, 2018
23 OliverM. E., "Economies of scale and scope in expansion of the US natural gas pipeline network", Energy Economics52 , 265-276, 2015
24 Chang , M. C.HuJ. L.ChenC. H., "A metafrontier pollution efficiency analysis of Taiwan ` s administrative regions", Journal of Cleaner Production 222 , 393-406, 2019
25 O ` DonnellC. J., "An aggregate quantity framework for measuring and decomposing productivity change", Journal of Productivity Analysis 38 , 255 ? 272, 2012
26 Chang , M. C., "An application of total-factor energy efficiency under the metafrontier framework", Energy Policy 142 , 111498, 2020
27 Meeusen , W.van den Broeck , J ., "Efficiency estimation from Cobb- Douglas production functions with composed error", International economic review , 435-444, 1977
28 B. J.KimJ. W., "An Analysis of the Economy of Scale for Domestic On-site Hydrogen Fueling Stations", Journal of Energy Engineering16 ( 4 ) , 170-180, 2007
29 Russell , R., "Theoretical productivity indices . In The Oxford Handbook of Productivity Analysis", 2018
30 Jin , Q.Kerstens , K.Van de WoestyneI., "Metafrontier productivity indices : Questioning the common convexification strategy", European Journal of Operational Research 283 ( 2 ) , 737-747, 2020
31 ParkC. I.SeoH. J., "The Efficiency and Productivity Change in the National R & D Projects of 6T Sectors", Journal of Industrial Economics and Business31 ( 1 ) , 293-325, 2018
32 Afsharian , M. , PodinovskiV. V., "A linear programming approach to efficiency evaluation in nonconvex metatechnologies", European Journal of Operational Research 268 ( 1 ) , 268-280, 2018
33 Lee , H.Choi , Y.Seo , H., "Comparative analysis of the R & D investment performance of Korean local governments", Technological Forecasting and Social Change 157 , 120073, 2020
34 J. I.NadiriM. I., "Product demand , cost of production , spillovers , and the social rate of return to R", D ( No . w3625 ) . National Bureau of Economic Research, 1991
35 Jung , W.Kim , H.Cho , S., "An Empirical Analysis on the Spillover Effects of R & D Investment in the ICT industry", Knowledge Management Research 20 ( 1 ) , 27-43, 2019
36 Wang , Q. , ChiuY. H.Chiu , C. R., "Non-radial metafrontier approach to identify carbon emission performance and intensity", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews69 , 664-672, 2017
37 Griliches , Z., "Issues in Assessing the Contribution of Research and Development to Productivity Growth", Bell Journal of Economics10 ( 1 ) , 92-116, 1979
38 Lee , W.S. , Hyun , S.J.Kim , B.H., "Research on government R & D program efficiency indicator development and application plan", Science & Technology Policy Institute, 2011
39 n-Esteve , M.V. , Picazo-TadeoA. J., "Environmental productivity in the European Union : A global Luenberger-metafrontier approach", Science of The Total Environment692 , 136-146, 2019
40 R. , GrosskopfS. , NorrisM.Zhang , Z ., "Productivity growth , technical progress , and efficiency change in industrialized countries", The American economic review , 66-83, 1994
41 van Elk , R.ter WeelB.van der WielK. , Wouterse , B., "Estimating the returns to public R & D investments : Evidence from production function models", De Economist 167 ( 1 ) , 45-87, 2019
42 R. , GrosskopfS. , LindgrenB.Roos , P., "Productivity changes in Swedish pharamacies 1980 1989 : A non-parametric Malmquist ? approach", Journal of productivity Analysis 3 ( 1 ) , 85-101, 1992
43 Inglesi-Lotz , R., "Social rate of return to R & D on various energy technologies : Where should we invest more ?", A study of G7 countries . Energy Policy 101 , 521-525, 2017
44 D. W.ChristensenL. R.DiewertW. E., "The economic theory of index numbers and the measurement of input , output , and productivity", Econometrica : Journal of the Econometric Society , 1393-1414, 1982
45 Sala-Garrido , R.Molinos-Senante , M.ndez-Sancho , F., "Comparing the efficiency of wastewater treatment technologies through a DEA metafrontier model", Chemical Engineering Journal173 ( 3 ) , 766-772, 2011
46 Thieme , C.Prior , D.Tortosa-Ausina , E., "A multilevel decomposition of school performance using robust nonparametric frontier techniques", Economics of Education Review 32 , 104-121, 2013
47 Kristensen , T. , OlsenK. R.Kilsmark , J.LauridsenJ. T.PedersenK. M., "Economies of scale and scope in the Danish hospital sector prior to radical restructuring plans", Health Policy 106 ( 2 ) , 120-126, 2012
48 Lee , B.Sohn , E.Won , D.Yeo , W.Kim , K.Kim , S., "The efficiency analysis of national R & D planning for the field of precision medicine in korea", Journal of Open Innovation : TechnologyMarket , and Complexity 4 ( 3 ) , 39, 2018
49 J. L.YangC. H.ChenC. P.D efficiency, "the national innovation system : An international comparison using the distance function approach", Bulletin of Economic Research66 ( 1 ) , 55-71, 2014
50 K. F.HamzahN. M.YuM. M., "Metafrontier Efficiency Analysis for Hospital Pharmacy Services Using Dynamic Network DEA Framework", Socio-Economic Planning Sciences , 101044, 2021
51 Baek , I.Chen , M.Lee , H., "A Study on Efficiency Analysis for Major International Airports in Korea , China and Japan Using DEA", Korea Logistics Review 30 ( 3 ) , 23-31, 2020
52 Lang , G., "Measuring the returns of R & D An empirical ? study of the German manufacturing sector over 45 years", Research Policy 38 ( 9 ) , 1438-1445, 2009
53 Corderi , D. , LinC. Y. C., "Measuring the social rate of return to R & D in coal , petroleum and nuclear manufacturing : A study", 2011
54 Schmidt , P. , LovellC. K., "Estimating technical and allocative inefficiency relative to stochastic production and cost frontiers", Journal of econometrics9 ( 3 ) , 343-366, 1979
55 G. E.CoelliT. J., "A model for technical inefficiency effects in a stochastic frontier production function for panel data", Empirical economics20 ( 2 ) , 325-332, 1992
56 ParkS. J.KimK. H.JeongS. K., "The study on the analysis of efficiency of governmental R & D programs regarding to the S & T outcomes", Journal of Korea Technology Innovation Society14 ( 2 ) , 205-222, 2011
57 Badinger HEgger P., "Intra- and inter-industry productivity spillovers in OECD manufacturing : a spatial econometric perspective", CESifo working paper No . 281, 2008
58 Jang , H.Lee , S.Suh , E., "A comparative analysis of the change in R & D efficiency : A case of R & D leaders in the technology industry", Technology Analysis & Strategic Management , 28 ( 8 ) , 886-900, 2016
59 Nemoto , J.Furumatsu , N., "Scale and scope economies of Japanese private universities revisited with an input distance function approach", Journal of Productivity Analysis41 ( 2 ) , 213-226, 2014
60 G. E.CoelliT. J., "Prediction of firm-level technical efficiencies with a generalized frontier production function and panel data", Journal of econometrics38 ( 3 ) , 387-399, 1988
61 O ’ DonnellC. J., "Productivity and Efficiency Analysis : An economic approach to measuring and explaining managerial performance", Springer Singapore, 2018
62 Shamohammadi , M. , OhD. H., "Measuring the efficiency changes of private universities of Korea : A two-stage network data envelopment analysis", Technological Forecasting and Social Change 148 , 119730, 2019
63 Sala-Garrido , R.Molinos-Senante , M.-Arce , M., "Comparing changes in productivity among private water companies integrating quality of service : a metafrontier approach", Journal of Cleaner Production216 , 597-606, 2019
64 R. , GrosskopfS. , LindgrenB.Roos , P.W. CooperA. LewinL. Seiford, "Productivity developments in Swedish hospitals : a Malmquist output index approach . In A. CharnesData envelopment analysis", Theory , methodology , and applications ( pp . 253-272 ) . Springer , Dordrecht, 1995
65 Mocholi-Arce , M.Sala-Garrido , R.Molinos-Senante , M.Maziotis , A., "Performance assessment of water companies : a metafrontier approach Accounting for quality of service and group heterogeneities", Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 74 , 100948, 2021
66 Eguchi , S.Takayabu , H.Lin , C., "Sources of inefficient power generation by coal-fired thermal power plants in China : A metafrontier DEA decomposition approach", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 110562, 2020
67 He , B. , WangJ. , WangJ. , WangK., "The Impact of Government Competition on Regional R & D Efficiency : Does Legal Environment Matter in China ` s Innovation System ?", Sustainability 10 ( 12 ) , 4401, 2018
68 Wang , H.Zhou , P.XieB. C.Zhang , N., "Assessing drivers of CO2 emissions in China ’ s electricity sector : A metafrontier production-theoretical decomposition analysis", European Journal of Operational Research 275 ( 3 ) , 1096-1107, 2019
69 Carvalho , P. , MarquesR. C., "Computing economies of vertical integration , economies of scope and economies of scale using partial frontier nonparametric methods", European Journal of Operational Research 234 ( 1 ) , 292-307, 2014
70 ChoT. Y.ChenY. S., "The impact of financial technology on China ` s banking industry : An application of the metafrontier cost Malmquist productivity index", The North American Journal of Economics and Finance 101414, 2021
71 Park , R., "An Empirical Comparison and Verification Study on the Seaport Clustering Measurement Using Meta-Frontier DEA and Integer Programming Models", Journal of Korea Port Economic Association33 ( 2 ) , 53-82, 2017
72 Lee , C.Cho , K., "Efficiency analysis and strategic portfolio model of national health technology R & D program using DEA : focused on translational research", Journal of Korean Institute of Industrial Engineers 40 ( 2 ) , 172-183, 2014
73 YangD. H., "Analysis on RTS and the Change of Productivity Efficiency of Public General Hospitals in Vietnam using Parametric and Non-Parametric Approach", Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society 15 ( 2 ) , 767-776, 2014
74 Arora , N. , TalwarS. J., "Modelling efficiency in budget allocations for Indian states using window based non-radial non-concave metafrontier data envelopment analysis", Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 70 ( C, 2020
75 Latruffe , L.Fogarasi , J.Desjeux , Y., "Efficiency , productivity and technology comparison for farms in Central and Western Europe : The case of field crop and dairy farming in Hungary and France", Economic Systems 36 ( 2 ) , 264-278, 2012