From Invisible Beneficiaries to Independent Rights Holders: How the Disability Rights Movement Changed Korea’s Law and Society

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Like most other societies, Korean society has long viewed disability as a medical problem or a personal tragedy. People with disabilities were considered objects of medical treatment, charity, and social welfare. Society and its legal system thus treated people with disabilities in paternalistic ways rather than as rights bearers. However, some persons with disabilities and their supporters began to raise their voices to protest such mistreatment and discrimination. They claimed that people with disabilities should be regarded not as objects but as subjects or rights holders. The long process of struggling for equal treatment for persons with disabilities finally resulted in changes in government policies and legislation, including the enactment of the Disability Discrimination Act (DDA) in 2007. The DDA is not just a new law; it is a comprehensive law that represents a significant paradigm shift in disability rights and associated discourses. The new social and human rights models of disabilities have replaced the charity and medical models. The enactment of the Transportation Convenience Act in 2005 was also an essential step toward creating a more inclusive and integrated society. People with disabilities publicly asserted their right to mobility: They should not have to remain inside homes or institutions. Correspondingly, this article charts how waves of activism and legal reform in Korea transformed societal and governmental perceptions of disability to recognize and protect the rights of persons with disabilities increasingly. Intertwined struggles by disabilities groups, civic organizations, and lawyers raised the public awareness of disability rights. They pushed the National Assembly to enact or amend laws that significantly affected the lives of people with disabilities in South Korea.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 유동철, "한국 장애운동의 성과와 과제" 한국사회복지정책학회 (21) : 5-32, 2005

2 정창권, "조선시대 장애인 예술가의 존재양상" 한국학연구소 (38) : 423-458, 2011

3 김명수, "장애인 이동권에 관한 헌법적 고찰" 법학연구원 19 (19): 105-130, 2007

4 "jigeob jaehwal beob [Act on the Employment Promotion and Vocational Rehabilitation of Persons with Disabilities]"

5 U.N. Department Of Economic And Social Affairs, "The United Nations and Disability: 70 Years of the Work towards a More Inclusive World"

6 Kyung Mee Kim, "The Current Status and Future of Center for Independent Living in Korea" 23 : 67-, 2008

7 "Teuksu gyoyuk jinheung beob [Act on the Promotion of Education for the Handicapped]"

8 "Supreme Court [S. Ct.], 2015Du45113, April 12, 2016"

9 Clark W. Sorensen, "Success and Education in South Korea" 38 : 10-, 1994

10 "Simsin jangaeja bokji beob [Welfare Act for Mentally and Physically Disabled Persons]"

11 "Seoul Southern District Court [Seoul Southern Dist. Ct.], 2013Ga-Hap102207, Sept. 30, 2013"

12 "Seoul Southern District Court [Seoul Southern Dist. Ct.], 2012Ga-Hap13003, June 26, 2013"

13 "Seoul High Court [Seoul High Ct.], 2017Na2061141, Nov. 23, 2018"

14 "Seoul High Court [Seoul High Ct.], 2009Ga-Dan99509, Sept. 10, 2010"

15 "Seoul Central District Court [Seoul Central Dist. Ct.], 2011Ga-Hap38092, Aug. 30, 2013"

16 "Seoul Central District Court [Seoul Central Dist. Ct.], 1996Ga-Hap158, Feb. 21, 1996"

17 "Sadan Beopin Duroo"

18 Tong-Hyung Kim, "S. Korea Covered Up Mass Abuse, Killings of ‘Vagrants’"

19 "Rep. of the Comm. on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities" 2014

20 Rahn Kim, "National Assembly Passes ‘Dogani Law’"

21 Chang Yeop Kim, "Naneun ‘napp eun’ Jangaein-igo Sip da [I want to be a ‘bad’ person with disabilities]" 51-, 2002

22 Mary Ann Jackson, "Models of Disability and Human Rights: Informing the Improvement of Built Environment Accessibility for People with Disability at Neighborhood Scale?" 7 : 3-, 2018

23 Dae-kyu Yoon, "Law and Democracy in South Korea: Development since 1987" 155-156, 2010

24 "Korea Differently Abled Federation"

25 "Jeonguk Jangaein Chabyeol Cheolpye Yeondae [Solidarity against Disability Discrimination]"

26 Seok Pyo Hong, "Jangaeinbeob Yeongu [A Study on Disability Law]" 385-, 2016

27 Won Young Kim, "Jangaein undongi balmyeonghan gwolliwa geue daehan sabeop chegyeeui suyonge daehan yeongu [A Study on the Rights Invented through Movement for the Disabled and its Embodiment in Korean Judiciary System]" 8 : 207-, 2010

28 "Jangaein goyong chokjin deung-e gwanhan beobyul [Promotion, etc. of Employment of Disabled Persons Act]"

29 "Jangaein deunge daehan teuksu gyoyuk beob [Act on Special Education for Persons with Disabilities, Etc.]"

30 "Jangaein chabyeol geumji mit gwolli guje deunge gwanhan beobnyul [Act on the Prohibition of Discrimination against Persons with Disabilities, Remedy against Infringement of Their Rights, etc.]"

31 "Jangaein chabyeol geumji mit gwolli guje deunge gwanhan beobnyul [Act on the Prohibition of Discrimination against Persons with Disabilities, Remedy against Infringement of Their Rights, etc.]"

32 "Jangaein chabyeol geumji mit gwolli guje deunge gwanhan beobnyul [Act on the Prohibition of Discrimination against Persons with Disabilities, Remedy against Infringement of Their Rights, etc.]"

33 Hyun-guk Youm, "Jangaein Chabyeol Geumji beop Haeseolseo [A Commentary on the Disability Discrimination Act]" 358-, 2017

34 NHRCK (National Human Rights Comission of Korea), "Jangaein Chabyeol Geumji beop Eehang Jego Mit Jangaein Ingwon Jeungji neul Wihan Toronhoe [Public Hearing for Enhancement of KDDA and Improvement of People with Disabilities Rights]" 137-, 2016

35 Mi Yeon Kim, "Human Rights and Disability Advocacy" 119-121, 2014

36 Maya Sabatello, "Human Rights and Disability Advocacy" 6-, 2014

37 Yeon-Soon Jung, "Human Rights Letter, The National Human Rights Commission of Korea"

38 "Heuimang Beob [Hope Law]"

39 "Hanguk Yeoseong Jangaein Yeonhap [The Korea Differently Abled Women United]"

40 "Gyotong yakjaeui idong pyeoneui jeungjin beob [Act on Promotion of the Transportation Convenience of Mobility Disadvantaged Persons] (“Transportation Convenience Act”)"

41 "Gyotong yakjaeui idong pyeoneui jeungjin beob [Act on Promotion of Transportation Convenience of Mobility Disadvantaged Persons] (“Transportation Convenience Act”)"

42 "Gyotong yakjaeui idong pyeoneui jeungjin beob [Act on Promotion of Transportation Convenience of Mobility Disadvantaged Persons] (“Transportation Convenience Act”)"

43 "Gyeongchal wonho beob [Police Assistance Act]"

44 "Gunsa wonho beob [Military Assistance Act]"

45 The Office of Court Administration, "Guidelines on Judicial Assistance for People with Disabilities (Publication No. 32-9740029-0000587-01.)"

46 "G.A. Res. 3447 (XXX), Declaration on the Rights of Disabled Persons"

47 Patricia Goedde, "From Dissidents to Institution-Builders: The Transformation of Public Interest Lawyers in South Korea" 4 : 63-, 2009

48 "Disabled People’s International Korea"

49 Theresia Degener, "Disability in a Human Rights Context" 5 : 35-, 2016

50 Cliona Kimber, "Disability Discrimination Law in the United States, Australia, and Canada" 166-, 1993

51 "Daegu District Court [Daegu Dist. Ct.], 80Ga-Hap295, Jan. 29, 1981"

52 Eunjung Kim, "Curative Violence: Rehabilitating Disability, Gender, and Sexuality in Modern Korea" 2015

53 "Constitutional Court [Const. Ct.], 2006Hun-Ma1098, Oct. 30, 2008"

54 "Constitutional Court [Const. Ct.], 2002Hun-Ma52, Dec. 18, 2002"

55 Do Hyun Kim, "Chabyeole Jeohanghara: Hangukeui Jangaein Undong 20nyeon [Resist Discrimination: 20 Years Of The Disability Movement In Korea]" 39-, 2007

56 Celeste Arrington, "Cause Lawyering and Movement Tactics: Disability Rights Movements in South Korea and Japan" 42 : 5-, 2020

57 "Byeonhosa beob [Attorney-at-Law Act]"

58 D. Aaron Lacy, "Am I My Brother’s Keeper: Disabilities, Paternalism, and Threats to Self" 44 : 55-, 2003

59 Dong-Chul Yu, "Achievements of and challenges facing the Korean disabled people’s movement" 33 : 1259-, 2018

60 Sam Hee Han, "A person using a wheelchair committed suicide"