도시 하천 호안(護岸)경관에 대한 평가모형에 관한 연구 - 중국 하북성(河北省) 형태시(邢臺市) 칠리하(七裏河)를 사례로 - = A Study on the Evaluation Model of Urban River Revetment Landscape - Focused on Qili River in Xingtai City of Hebei Province, China -

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study is the result of an empirical analysis of Qili river in Hebei Province, China after constructing a landscape evaluation model using the Fuzzy-Delphi method and the DEMATEL-ANP method. After reducing the first 54 indicators to 40 indicators using the first questionnaire according to the Delphi method, as a result of the second questionnaire and data processing according to the expert Fuzzy-Delphi method, all evaluation indicators reached the convergence standard. After deleting the indicators whose median value was lower than the critical value, the final evaluation system for urban riverside revetment landscape was constructed centering on 22 indicators. The derived model is functional classification in four areas, namely in terms of water management, in terms of proximity to water, in terms of beneficial to water, in terms of protection of water, and functional, safety, landscape, ecological, and socio-economic aspects are classified into five criteria. The top five factors of the greatest influence of the evaluation indicators were River water landscape(C11), construction investment(C19), plant coverage(C16), hydrophilicity of the revetment(C10), and overall visual harmony(C9). However, considering that the weight of the factor of diversity of human landscape(C12) was the lowest, it was confirmed that the revetment landscape of urban rivers pays more attention to the interaction between natural landscape and waterscape, which almost excludes human landscape. On the other hand, in the urban landscape evaluation system, the order of the five rule layers was in the order of landscape aesthetics > ecology > socio-economics > function> safety, which was evaluated as a result of reflecting the overall landscape perception and attraction of the coastal landscape of the city's waterway. The overall landscape evaluation of the Qili river revetment is satisfaction at 70.93points, but urgent improvement is needed in Drowning rescue facilities(C6), Cultural landscape diversity(C12), and Embodiment of history, culture, and customs(C22) It turned out to be necessary.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 Fuzzy-Delphi법과 DEMATEL-ANP법으로 경관평가 모형을 구축한 뒤 하북성 형태시 소재 칠리하(七裏河)를 사례로 실증 분석한 결과이다. Delphi법에 따른 1차 설문지를 이용하여 최초 54개 지표를 40개 지표로 줄인 후 전문가 Fuzzy-Delphi법에 따른 2차 설문지 및 데이터 처리 결과 모든 평가 지표는 수렴기준에 도달하였다. 평가지표 중간값이 임계값보다 낮은 지표를 삭제한 뒤 최종적으로 22개 지표를 중심으로 도시 하천 호안지역 경관 평가체계를 구성하였다. 도출된 모델은 치수, 친수, 이수, 보수 등 4개 방면의 기능분류이며, 다시 기능적 측면, 안전성 측면, 경관적 측면, 생태적 측면, 사 회경제적 측면 등 5가지 기준으로 유형화되었다. 평가지표 중 영향력이 큰 상위 5개 요인은 수역경관 (C11), 건설투자(C19), 식물피복률(C16), 호안의 친수성(C10), 시각적 조화(C9) 순이었다. 그러나 인문 경관의 다양성(C12)요인의 가중치가 최하위임을 볼 때 도시 하천의 호안경관과 인문경관은 거의 배 제된 상태이며, 자연경관과 수역경관의 상호작용에 더 많은 관심을 기울이고 있음이 확인되었다. 한편 도시 경관평가 체계에서 5개 준칙층의 순서는 경관 미학성> 생태성 > 사회경제성 > 기능성 > 안전성 순으로 나타났는데 이는 도시 내 수로의 호안 지역 경관의 전체적인 경관 감지와 흡인력을 반영한 결과로 평가되었다. 칠리하 호안구역의 종합적 경관 평가치는 70.93점으로 만족스러운 수준이지만 익수사고에 대비한 구조시설(C6) 인문경관의 다양성(C12) 그리고 역사문화 풍습의 구현(C22) 항목에 있어서는 시급한 개선이 필요한 것으로 밝혀졌다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이수동 ; 강현경 ; 장한솔, "호안 녹화용 매트 시공 후 식생변화 모니터링 - 성남시 탄천을 중심으로 -" 한국환경생태학회 24 (24): 302-317, 2010

2 조용현 ; 최대희, "수변 생태벨트 평가방법 개발에 관한 연구" 한국조경학회 42 (42): 123-132, 2014

3 이원철 ; 박찬돈, "대도시 수변공간의 친수성 평가체계에 관한 연구" 한국주거환경학회 12 (12): 185-195, 2014

4 "https://xxgk.mot.gov.cn/"

5 "https://www.cnki.net/index/"

6 "https://scholar.google.com/"

7 "https://baike.baidu.com/item/"

8 Yang, D., "Waterfronts: Spatial composition and cultural use" University of London 2006

9 Xin Li, "Visual quality evaluation model of an urban river landscape based on random forest" Elsevier BV 133 : 108381-, 2021

10 Chen, X., "Urban Waterfront Design Study hydrophilic Embankment" Northwest A&F University 2011

11 Wang, Z., "Theory and Strategy of Landscape Design for Urban River Ecological Revetment Engineering" Huazhong University of Science and Technology Press 2014

12 Ishikawa, A., "The max-min Delphi method and fuzzy Delphi method via fuzzy integration" 55 (55): 241-253, 1993

13 Yin, C., "The ecological function, protection and utilization of land/in land water ecotones" 15 (15): 331-335, 1995

14 Himansu Sekhar Mishra, "The development of a tool for assessing the environmental qualities of urban blue spaces" Elsevier BV 49 : 126575-, 2020

15 Yazawa, Y., "The Relationship between Evaluations of Water Channels Landscape and Landscape Elements in Sub-urban Residential Area in Tokyo, Japan" 501 (501): 012-027, 2020

16 Wang, X., "The Northern Revetment Space of Waterfront Landscape Design Research" Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology 2015

17 Zhu, X., "The Method Study of Waterside City's Waterfront Construction Landscape Design" Wuhan University of Technology 2008

18 Yang, J., "The Landscape Design Research of Water Revetment Area in Old Town of Hefei: In the Case of Ring Park" Hefei Polytechnic University 2012

19 Pieczyńska, E., "The Ecology and management of aquatic-terrestrial ecotones" UNESCO 103-140, 1990

20 Shu, Q., "The City Revetment Waterscape Design" Nanjing Forestry University 2007

21 Junjie Luo, "Semantic Riverscapes: Perception and evaluation of linear landscapes from oblique imagery using computer vision" Elsevier BV 228 : 104569-, 2022

22 Ji, F., "Research on Urban Design Guideline of the Ecological Problems Related to the Yinchuan City Diannong River Waterfront" Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology 2020

23 Xiang, J., "Research on Methods of Bulkhead Landscape Design in City Space: Case Study of Jiangdong Culture Plaza Bulkhead Design Etc" Chongqing University 2015

24 Liu, X., "Research on Ecological Revetment of Xi'er River in Dali City" Southwest Forestry University 2008

25 Wang, J., "Research of Urban River Ecological Bank: Protection Landscape Establishment and Estimation in Hangzhou" Zhejiang University 2016

26 Everard, M., "Rediscovering the value of urban rivers" 15 : 293-314, 2012

27 Chang, T., "Reclaiming the city: Waterfront development in Singapore" 48 (48): 2,085-2,100, 2011

28 Xu, D., "Public Facilities Along the Waterfront Environment Planning and Design Strategy" 20 : 117-119, 2010

29 Dictionary, O., "Oxford English Dictionary" 1993

30 Ni, W., "Modern Chinese Dictionary" People's China Publishing House 1994

31 Kim, K., "Landscape Design of the Waterside" Vyland 2005

32 Liu, S., "Landscape Design of the Revetment of Hanzha River from the Perspective of "Urban Double Repair”" Hubei University of Technology 2021

33 Li, C., "Identification of a threshold value for the DEMATEL method using the maximum mean de-entropy algorithm to find critical services provided by a semiconductor intellectual property mall" 36 (36): 9,891-9,898, 2009

34 Delbecq, A., "Group techniques for program planning: A guide to nominal group and Delphi processes" Scott, Foresman and Company 186-189, 1975

35 Freitag, B., "Floodplain management: a new approach for a new era" Island Press 2012

36 Qiao, L., "Evaluation of urban river landscape design rationality based on AHP" 1 (1): 75-81, 2008

37 Lei Feng, "Evaluation of Urban Park Landscape Satisfaction Based on the Fuzzy-IPA Model: A Case Study of the Zhengzhou People’s Park" Hindawi Limited 2022 : 1-7, 2022

38 Kang, M., "Evaluation of Ecosystems for Ecological Management of Urban Rivers" Graduate School of Sangmyung University 2008

39 Ding, L., "Evaluation and Design of the Use of the Urban River Ecology Embankments: Take the Ningbo Jiangdong District River Course as the Examplet" Zhejiang University of Technology 2012

40 Eom, T., "Evaluation after implementation of natural river maintenance" Kyungwon University 2011

41 Zihao Man, "Effects of revetments on soil ecosystems in the urban river-riparian interface" Elsevier BV 25 (25): 105277-, 2022

42 Uchida, T., "Ecological significance of masonry revetments in plant biodiversity" 9 (9): 1,353-1,359, 2015

43 Rui Sun, "Ecological pervious concrete in revetment and restoration of coastal Wetlands: A review" Elsevier BV 303 : 124590-, 2021

44 Chen, Y., "Ecological Design in Flood Control Area: JiaoZuo Dasha River Case" Tianjin University 2020

45 Lee, H., "Design of Ecological Hangang Dunchi Considering Changes in the Water Level of the Han River" Graduate School of Seoul National University 2013

46 Li, S., "Design and Example Analysis of Landscape Revetment Structure" Huazhong University of Science and Technology Press 2012

47 Yu, K., "Design Accessible and Ecological Water Edges for Unstable Water Level: Qijiang Park in Zhongshan City" 37-38, 2002

48 Saaty, T., "Decision making: The analytic hierarchy and network processes(AHP/ANP)" 13 : 1-35, 2004

49 Mavi, R., "Critical success factors of sustainable project management in construction: A fuzzy DEMATEL-ANP approach" 194 : 751-765, 2018

50 Clark, J., "Coastal zone management handbook" CRC press 2018

51 Xiao, H., "Classification and Landscape Design oF Ecological Emba nkment Mode of Riparian Buffer Zone: study on the Baihe Upstream River Basin in Beijing" Beijing Forestry University 2012

52 Gastil, R., "Beyond the edge: New York's new waterfront" Princeton Architectural Press 2002

53 Liu, B., "Bank Planning and Design in Renovation of Water System of Land-scape" 3 : 52-55, 2004

54 Kim, B., "Analysis on the Urban Waterfront for River Restoration" The Korea Contents Association 105-106, 2012

55 Bao, J., "Analysis on the Design Mode of Urban Riverway Revetment: A Case Study of Landscape Design of Dasi River in Jiyang District, Jinan City, Shandong Province" Beijing Forestry University 2021

56 Yan, L., "Analysis of influencing factors on the management performance of expressway construction project based on DEMATEL method" IEEE 4,198-4,201, 2009

57 Ling Wang, "An Evaluation Model of Riparian Landscape: A Case in Rural Qingxi Area, Shanghai" MDPI AG 11 (11): 1512-, 2022

58 Lim, Y., "An Analysis of Urban River Waterfront Landscape Image and Preference Factors" Hanyang University 2009

59 Timur, U., "Advances in landscape architecture" IntechOpen 2013

60 Eom, H., "A study on the method of securing hydrophilicity in the water front" Graduate School of Kyunggi university 1995

61 Kwon, l., "A study on the creation of natural rivers in urban middle and small rivers for the restoration of river ecology: focusing on the Yangjaecheon Stream and Hongjecheon Stream basins" University of Seoul 2007

62 Jang, M., "A study on the application of natural river shore protection method through numerical models and mathematical experiments" Graduate School of University of Seoul 2011

63 Lam, K., "A material supplier selection model for property developers using fuzzy principal component analysis" 19 (19): 608-618, 2010

64 Jang, S., "A basic design concept for riverfront and landscape in urban stream" 3 : 71-88, 2000

65 Kim, Y., "A Study on the Evaluation of Environmental Conditions of Natural River Restoration Project" Graduate School of Sejong University 2012

66 Seo, Y., "A Study on the Ecological Characteristics and Assessment of types of Ecological Stream" 1 : 53-54, 2014

67 Lee, S., "A Study on the Design Method through Analysis of Waterfront Space in Urban Areas" 2010

68 Seok, S., "A Study on the Characteristics of Vegetation Structure in the Natural: Type Lakeside Construction Section of the Han River" Graduate School of University of Seoul 2012

69 Oh, J., "A Study on the Characteristics of Urban Waterfront Landscape" Graduate School of Chung-Ang University 2010

70 Shin, B., "A Study on the Characteristics and Management of Ecological Change and Landscape Conservation Area in Amsa-dong, Hangang River" Graduate School of University of Seoul 2023

71 Ju, S., "A Study on the Changes in Early Vegetation after Greening Construction on the Concrete Lakeside along the lower reaches of the Hangang River and the Tancheon River" Dankook University 2009

72 Moon, J., "A Study on Techniques of River Environment Improvement for Urban Environment Improvement: Focused on Kyung-An Stream-" Central University 2001

73 Li, S., "A Study on Revetment Construction in Garden" Beijing Forestry University 2007

74 Kang, H., "A Study of Ecological Change Aspects in Tanche on Ecological Landscape Conservation Area，Seoul" 13 (13): 23-32, 2010