V-stranding with null arguments in coordination and its interpretation

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper explores the reasons why V-stranding negative replies allow the interpretation that negates every argument in the antecedent coordinate clause as noted in Russian by Landau (2021). We observed a similar pattern in Korean, where VP ellipsis is not attested, thus V-stranding VP ellipsis is not an analytic option. For an alternative account of the relevant construction, we propose an argument ellipsis analysis with De Morgan’s laws syntactically implemented via negation lowering into coordination. In constructions observing De Morgan’s laws, the negation of a disjunction is interpreted as the conjunction of the negations while the negation of a conjunction is construed as the disjunction of the negations. We generalize that in the absence of functional heads licensing null categories, negation does not undergo lowering, exerting no influence on the coordinator combining null arguments in V-stranding constructions. This yields a conjunctive interpretation by default, generating a denotation where every conjunct is negated. Effectively, the syntactic process of negation lowering accompanied by coordinator switch feeds the interpretations in compliance with De Morgan’s laws, although this process is constrained by diverse configurations such as the presence of adverbial expressions.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Barbosa, Pilar P., "pro as a minimal nP : Toward a unified approach to pro-drop" 53 (53): 487-526, 2019

2 Pesetsky, David, "Zero syntax" The MIT Press 1995

3 Kurafuji, Takeo, "Words and their twists 6, A collection of memorials to Professor Sachiko Shimazu" Ritsumeikan University 227-242, 2018

4 Park, Bum-Sik, "When can scope economy be violated?" Hankwukmwunhwasa 525-544, 2003

5 Otani, Kazuyo, "V-raising and VP-ellipsis" 22 (22): 345-358, 1991

6 Grice, H. Paul, "Syntax and semantics" Academic Press 41-58, 1975

7 Chomsky, Noam, "Syntactic structures" Mouton 1957

8 Huang, C. -T. James, "Remarks on empty categories in Chinese" 18 (18): 321-337, 1987

9 Takahashi, Daiko, "Quantificational null objects and argument ellipsis" 39 (39): 307-326, 2008

10 Huang, C. -T. James, "Principles and parameters in comparative grammar" The MIT Press 56-76, 1991

11 Fillmore, Charles, "Pragmatically controlled zero anaphora" 12 : 95-107, 1986

12 Landau, Idan, "On the non-existence of verb-stranding VP-ellipsis" 51 (51): 341-365, 2020

13 Chao, Wynn, "On ellipsis" University of Massachusetts 1987

14 Laka, Itziar, "Negation in syntax: On the nature of functional categories and projections" Massachusetts Institute of Technology. 1990

15 Yang, Myung-Hee, "Hyentay Kwuke Tayyonge-ey kwanhan yenkwu (A study on the substitutes in the modern Korean language)" Seoul National University 1996

16 Landau, Idan, "Ellipsis with a coordinated antecedent : An alternative to V-stranding VP-ellipsis" 75 (75): 1-23, 2021

17 Saito, Mamoru, "Ellipsis and pronominal reference in Japanese clefts" Nanzan University 1 (1): 21-50, 2004

18 Krivochen, Diego Gabriel, "De Morgan’s laws and NEG-raising : A syntactic view" 1 (1): 112-121, 2019

19 Huang, C. -T. James, "Comments on Hasegawa’s paper" Connecticut College 77-93, 1988

20 Li, Yen-Hui Audrey, "Born empty" 151 (151): 43-68, 2014

21 이우승 ; 박명관, "Argument Ellipsis vs. V-Stranding VP Ellipsis: Evidence from Conjunctive/Disjunctive Constructions in Korean" 한국생성문법학회 31 (31): 515-536, 2021

22 Gribanova, Vera, "A new argument for verb-stranding verb phrase ellipsis" 44 (44): 145-157, 2013