A Momentary Lapse of Reason? Assessing the Pre- and Post-Brexit Preferences of UK Citizens

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

We analyze the persistence of the major determinants of distrust toward the European Union (EU) and pro-Brexit voting attitudes of citizens of the United Kingdom. Looking both backward and forward, our analysis confirms that Euroscepticism is deep-rooted, although the data reveal differences across different parts of the country. We observe no major transformation in the favor of the EU over the last two decades or in the post-referendum period. We also carry out an age-period-cohort analysis by interacting age and cohort effects with time to analyze the evolution of individual preferences. We find that an aging population will promote Eurosceptic assertiveness. We then implement a demographic forecasting analysis to predict whether the level of distrust of older cohorts can be offset by differing attitudes among younger cohorts in the future. On the contrary, we find that demographic trends will tend to strengthen distrust in the EU.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• I. Introduction II. Literature Review III. Pre-Brexit Determinants: Data and Methodology IV. Pre-Brexit Determinants: Results V. Post-Brexit Persistence? Results from an APC Analysis VI. Conclusion

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Jolly, S. K., "Xenophobia and immigrant contact: French public attitudes towards immigration" 51 (51): 464-473, 2014

2 Eichengreen, B., "Will Brexit age well? Cohorts, seasoning and the age-leave gradient, past, present and future" 2021

3 Curtice, J., "Why Leave won the UK's EU referendum" 55 : 19-37, 2017

4 Alabrese, E., "Who voted for Brexit? Individual and regional data combined" 56 : 132-150, 2019

5 Becker, S. O., "Who voted for Brexit? A comprehensive district-level analysis" 32 (32): 601-650, 2017

6 Powdthavee, N., "Who got the Brexit blues? The effect of Brexit on subjective wellbeing in the UK" 86 : 471-494, 2019

7 Kuhn, T., "When European integration becomes costly: The euro crisis and public support for European economic governance" 21 (21): 624-641, 2014

8 Liberini, F., "Was Brexit caused by the old and unhappy? Or by financial feelings?" 161 : 287-302, 2019

9 Carey, S., "Undivided loyalties: Is national identity an obstacle to European integration?" 3 (3): 387-413, 2002

10 Clements, B., "Understanding ‘utilitarian’ support for European integration in Scotland and Wales: The role of economic interests, national identity and party support" 21 (21): 1-21, 2011

11 Gabel, M., "Understanding variation in public support for European integration" 27 (27): 3-19, 1995

12 Rhodebeck, L. A., "The politics of greed? Political preferences among the elderly" 55 (55): 342-364, 1993

13 Los, B., "The mismatch between local voting and the local economic consequences of Brexit" 51 (51): 786-799, 2017

14 Hobolt, S. B., "The Brexit vote: A divided nation, a divided continent" 23 (23): 1259-1277, 2016

15 Hall, S. G., "The Brexit controversy: What light does evidence shed?" 43 : 5-14, 2019

16 Grasso, M., "Thatcher’s children, Blair’s babies, political socialization and trickle-down value change: An age, period and cohort analysis" 49 : 1-20, 2017

17 Goodwin, M., "Taking back control? Investigating the role of immigration in the 2016 vote for Brexit" 19 (19): 450-464, 2017

18 David, Q., "Scale matters in contextual analysis of extreme right voting and political attitudes" 71 : 509-536, 2018

19 Brigevich, A., "Regional identity and support for Europe: Distinguishing between cultural and political social identity in France" 26 (26): 475-507, 2016

20 Gabel, M., "Public support for European integration: An empirical test of five theories" 60 (60): 333-354, 1998

21 Danigelis, N. L, "Population aging, intracohort aging, and sociopolitical attitudes" 72 (72): 812-830, 2007

22 Schonfeld, B., "Policy or partisanship in the United Kingdom? Quasi-experimental evidence from Brexit" 2019

23 Fannon, Z., "Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Economics and Finance" Oxford University Press 2019

24 Arnorsson, A., "On the causes of Brexit" 55 : 301-323, 2018

25 Fetzer, T., "Measuring the regional economic cost of Brexit: Evidence up to 2019" CEPR 2020

26 Çokluk, Ö., "Logistic regression: Concept and application" 10 (10): 1397-1407, 2010

27 Crescenzi, R., "It’s not about the money! EU funds, local opportunities, and Euroscepticism" 84 : 2020

28 Garry, J., "Inequality, state ownership and the European Union: How economic context and economic ideology shape support for the European Union" 16 (16): 139-154, 2014

29 Lee, N., "Immobility and the Brexit vote" 11 (11): 143-163, 2018

30 de Mello, L., "Greying the budget: Ageing and preferences over public policies" 70 : 70-96, 2017

31 Fullerton, A. S., "Generational conflict or methodological artifact? Reconsidering the relationship between age and policy attitudes in the U.S., 1984-2008" 74 (74): 643-673, 2010

32 Elgün, Ö., "Exposure to European Union policies and support for membership in the candidate countries" 60 (60): 391-400, 2007

33 McLaren, L., "Explaining mass-level Euroscepticism: Identity, interests, and institutional distrust" 42 (42): 233-251, 2007

34 Alexandre-Collier, A., "Euroscepticism under Margaret Thatcher and David Cameron: From theory to practice" 17 : 115-133, 2015

35 Hertner, I., "Europhiles or Eurosceptics? Comparing the European policies of the Labour Party and the Liberal Democrats" 12 (12): 63-89, 2017

36 Luedtke, A., "European integration, public opinion and immigration policy: Testing the impact of national identity" 6 (6): 83-112, 2005

37 Anderson, C. J., "Economic benefits and support for membership in the EU: A cross-national analysis" 15 (15): 231-249, 1995

38 Sørensen, R., "Does ageing affect preferences for welfare spending? A study of peoples’ spending preferences in 22 countries, 1985-2006" 29 : 259-271, 2013

39 Nowakowski, A., "Do unhappy citizens vote for populism?" 68 : 2021

40 Peterson, J. C., "Do people really become more conservative as they age?" 82 (82): 600-611, 2020

41 Fetzer, T., "Did austerity cause Brexit?" 109 (109): 3849-3886, 2019

42 Haselswerdt, J., "Carving out: Isolating the true effect of self-interest on policy attitudes" 114 (114): 1103-1116, 2020

43 Fidrmuc, J., "Can money buy EU love?" 60 : 2019

44 Hooghe, L., "Calculation, community and cues: Public opinion on European integration" 6 (6): 419-443, 2005

45 Clery E., "British social attitudes: The 34th Report" NatCen Social Research

46 O'Reilly, J., "Brexit: Understanding the socioeconomic origins and consequences" 14 (14): 807-854, 2016

47 Latorre, M. C., "Brexit: Everyone loses, but Britain loses the most" Peterson Institute for International Economics 2019

48 Menon, A., "Brexit and public opinion 2019" The UK in a Changing Europe 2019

49 Campos, N. F., "B for Brexit: A survey of the economics academic literature" IZA 2019

50 Danigelis, N. L., "An inter-cohort comparison of changes in racial attitudes" 13 (13): 383-404, 1991

51 Schwadel, P., "An age-period-cohort analysis of political tolerance in the United States" 55 (55): 421-452, 2014

52 Glenn, N., "Aging and conservatism" 415 : 176-186, 1974

53 Tilley, J., "Ageing and generational effects on vote choice: Combining cross-sectional and panel data to estimate APC effects" 33 : 19-27, 2014

54 Bisciari, P., "A survey of the long-term impact of Brexit on the UK and the EU27 economies" National Bank of Belgium 2019