중국 ‘요하문명론’의 ‘장백산문화론’으로의 확대와 백두산의 ‘선도(仙道) 제천(祭天)’ 전통

정경희 ( Jung Kyung-hee ) 국제뇌교육종합대학원 국학연구원 2018 선도문화 Vol.24 No.-

The core of ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory’, ‘Hungshan Culture(Ritual禮制 Culture, Pre-Shang先商 Culture) theory’ started as a historical theory on Zhongyuan中原 and Liaoxi遼西 region in the first place. It was gradually expanded to the east region of Liaoxi, Liaodung 遼東 and Korean peninsula. In this process, ‘the Mt. Changbai culture theory’ was emerged as the easting theory of ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory’. The basic structure of ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory’ is that the ethnic center is Manju people(prescribed as a Chinese people since Jin and Qing dynasty) and the cultural center is Chinese people excluding the primary status of Korean people in terms of ethnic group and culture. The genealogy of ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory’, ‘Hungshan Culture → Xia Jia Dian Lower Culture → Shang Culture’ had broadened to ‘〔Hungshan Culture → Xia Jia Dian Lower Culture → Shang Culture〕 →(Yen dynasty·)Kija Chosun箕子朝鮮→Wiman Chosun衛滿朝鮮→ Four Commanderies of Han dynasty→Goguryeo·Buyeo→Balhae’. This genealogy is the extansion of the historical awareness focused on Shang dynasty, the basic historical awareness of ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory’. According to this historical awareness, Goguryeo, Buyeo and Balhae as well as Yen dynasty and Kija Chosun were emphasized as a descendant of Shang dynasty. With this, Korean history was abolished from the root. As the starting point for all distortions by China is ‘Hungshan Culture(Ritual Culture, Pre-Shang Culture) theory’, the starting point for all correction of it is just ‘Hungshan Culture(Sundo仙道 Culture, Baedalkook倍達國 Culture) theory’. In the late 1990’s, chinese scholars began to apply ‘Hungshan Culture(Ritual Culture, Pre-Shang Culture) theory’ to the ancient altars that were found in the region of Mt. Baekdu to prove their ‘the Mt. Changbai culture theory’. At last, the two main centers of Sundo Heaven rituals Culture, Hungshan Culture region and Mt. Baekdu region has come into view and ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory-the Mt. Changbai culture theory’ is exposed to error. Here we can understand that the tradition of Sundo Heaven rituals was diffused from Liaoxi to Liaodung since Hungshan Culture. According to history books of Korean Sundo, Sinsi神市(Mt. Baekdu region) and Cheonggu靑邱(Hungshan Culture region) were just the two main centers of Sundo Heaven rituals Culture during Baedalkook period. When chinese scholars got to know that they were unable to drive Mt. Changbai culture - especially ‘Mt. Changbai Faith’ to the chinese culture, they changed the center of ‘Mt. Changbai Faith’ to the shamanism of Manju people as the next best thing. And they advocated that the ‘Mt. Changbai Faith’ belongs to chinese culture because the shamanism of Manju people was changed to chinese Mountain worship(Ritual Culture) since Jin and Qing dynasty. But the shamanism of Manju people was not merely their inherent shamanism, just but a type of the universal Sundo Heaven rituals of northeast asia since Baedalkook period. In spite of ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory-the Mt. Changbai culture theory’, China just got to meet Korean Sundo Culture.

통화 만발발자 제천유적을 통해 본 백두산 서편 맥족의 제천문화(Ⅱ) - 2차 제천시설 ‘선돌 2柱 · 積石 方壇 · 祭天祠’를 중심으로 -

정경희 국제뇌교육종합대학원대학교 국학연구원 2019 선도문화 Vol.27 No.-

Wanfabozi萬發撥子 relic is just the typical ‘Heaven Ritual relic’, which was condensed the formation and transition process of Maek貊 race(the chief race of Korean race)’s Heaven Ritual culture during B.C.4000~A.D. 600, from Baedalkook倍達國 to Goguryeo高句麗. It was consisted of two facilities, i.e. ① primary facilities: the three-layered circular altar(the mother-son tomb) with attached square altar and ② secondary facilities: two sets of Menhir·stone mound square altar·shrine for Heaven Ritual. The chinese excavation and research on Wanfabozi was originally intended for the purpose of proving ‘the Liao-ho river遼河 civilization theory-the Mt. Changbai長白 culture theory’, but the excavation results revealed the fictitiousness of ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory-the Mt. Changbai culture theory’. For the chinese side, the most serious and confused problem of the excavation results was the origins and thecurrent succession of the ancient civilization in Northeast Asia. First, the excavation results of the primary facilities are as follows. The typical Heaven Ritual culture of Baedalkook based on Sundo仙道 thoughts was formed in Liaodong遼東, the west of Mt. Baekdu白頭 area(Baedalkook Cheonpyeong天坪 culture) and spreaded to Liaoxi遼西, Uaryang牛河梁 area(Baedalkook Cheonggu靑邱 culture) and Cheonggu culture spreaded to Zhongyuan中原 area through the Yin殷 dynasty again. According to this cultural propagation path, the origin of Chinese civilization is nothing but the west of Mt. Baekdu area(Cheonpyeong culture). Next, the excavation results of the secondary facilities are as follows. Heaven Ritual culture of Maek race had been widespread in ‘Liaodong ~ Liaoxi area’ since B.C. 4000 and it had been pushed to ‘the west of Mt. Baekdu ~ Korean peninsula area’ during Bronze Age ~ Early Iron Age, i.e. Dangun Josun檀君朝鮮~Yeolgug(列國, the age of division of small countries after the collapse of Dangun Josun). In short, Baedalkook civilization had been succeeded to Korea, not China. The chinese side(State Administration of Cultural Heritage國家文物局), which could not accept these excavation results, concealed Heaven Ritual facilities of Wanfabozi relic finally, and concealed all altars of the west of Mt. Baekdu which were excavated in the 1990s too. 1990년대 중국의 ‘요하문명론-장백산문화론’ 정립 과정에서 백두산 서편 고제단군중 가장 전형적인 홍산문화계 고제단으로 지목, 전면 발굴이이루어졌던 만발발자 유적은 B.C.4000년~A.D.600년 무렵, 곧 배달국~고구려시기 한민족의 주족인 맥족계의 선도제천문화가 성립·변천되어가는 과정을 집약적으로 함축하고 있는 더없이 귀한 유적이다. 유적은 제천·주거·무덤시설로 이루어졌는데 제천시설이 중심이며 나머지 시설은부속시설에 해당한다. 제천시설은 다시 1차 시설 ‘3층원단(모자합장묘)· 방대’, 2차 시설 ‘선돌 2주·적석 방단·제천사’로 나뉜다. 만발발자의 1차 및 2차 제천시설은 크게 보아 B.C.4000년~A.D.600 년 무렵(정식 발굴을 거쳤을 뿐아니라 가장 넓은 시기값을 지닌 만발발자유적의 시기를 기준으로 함) 요동·요서·한반도의 ‘환호를 두른 구릉성제천시설(3층원단·적석단·나무솟대·제천사·선돌·고인돌류)’ 계통으로 중원지역에서는 전혀 나타나지 않는 형태였다. 중국측의 만발발자 유적 발굴은 애초 ‘요하문명론-장백산문화론’을 증명하기위한 목적에서 시작되었지만 결과적으로 동북아 상고문화의 기원과 계승 관계에 대한 새로운 시각을 열어주었다. 첫째, 1980년대 이래 요서 중심으로 이루어진 동북아 상고사 연구를 요동 중심으로 돌려 놓았다. 둘째, 중원문화의 기원이 배달국 요동~요서 문화였음을 보여주었다. 셋째, 중원문화가 배달국문화의 본령인 선도제천문화의 전형을 제대로 전수하지 못하고 지역문화화하였음을 보여주었다. 결과를 수용할 수 없었던 중국측은 만발발자 유적중 제천시설 부분을 은폐하며, 더하여 1990년대 발굴조사되었던 백두산 서편 고제단군 전체를 은폐하게 된다.

통화 만발발자 제천유적을 통해 본 백두산 서편 맥족의 제천문화(Ⅰ) - B.C. 4000~3500년경 ‘3층원단(層圓壇)(모자합장묘(母子合葬墓))·방대(方臺)’를 중심으로 -

정경희 ( Jung Kyung-hee ) 국제뇌교육종합대학원 국학연구원 2019 선도문화 Vol.26 No.-

In the 1990s, the chinese academic circles sought to find elements of Hungshan Culture(Ritual禮制 Culture, Pre-Shang先商 Culture) in Mt. Baekdu area according to ‘the Liao-ho river遼河 civilization theory - the Mt. Changbai長白 culture theory’. Especially they paid attention to the stone mound altar·tomb(the ancient altars) in Tonghua area, the west of Mt. Baekdu. Tonghua area was the center of Maek race(the chief race of Korean race)’s cultural domain, the west of Mt. Baekdu which has been populated and flourished since the late Neolithic period. The research on the ancient altars in the west of Mt. Baektu began in 1989 with the discovery of ‘the Liming黎明 altar’ in Tonghua, which received the attention of the chinese academic circles and the communist party of China and about 40 altar relics were surveyed or excavated until 1995. To the next step, based on these successful research results, the systematic and massive excavation on ‘the Wanfabozi altar’ in Tonghua was conducted during 1997~1999. The Wanfabozi relic was consisted of Heaven Ritual facilities, Residential facilities and Tomb facilities. Among them, Heaven Ritual facilities are the main facilities, and the remaining Residential facilities and Tomb facilities are the attached facilities of Heaven Ritual facilities. Heaven Ritual facilities continued from the late neolithic period(Baedalkuk倍達國) to Dangunjoseon檀君朝鮮 and Koguryo高句麗 period and it was consisted of ① the three-layered circular altar(the mother-son tomb) with attached square altar facility, ② the moat · two sets of Menhir · square altar · Shrine for Heaven Ritual facility. In this paper, the first facility was reviewed. The construction time of ‘the three-layered circular altar(the mother-son tomb) with attached square altar’ was B.C. 4000~3500. And the way that mother and son were buried together and the bear clay statue(Doung陶熊), jades and pottery with swastika excavated from the tomb showed that Bear熊 race(later Maek貊 race) in the late neolithic maternal society with bear-belief tradition, had embraced the advanced Heaven Ritual culture based on Sundo仙道 thoughts such as ‘Chun天·Ji地·In人(Circle·Square·Triangle)’ Thoughts(The idea of One-Three). These excavation results notices the change of research trend on the ancient history of East Asia, centering on liaoxi遼西 area since 1980s. Especially chinese scholars, according to ‘the Liao-ho river civilization theory-the Mt. Changbai culture theory’, have argued that Hungshan culture in Liaoxi area was spread to Liaodong遼東 area as well as Zhongyuan中原 area. But the excavation results of Wanfabozi altar shows that the typical Heaven Ritual culture based on Sundo thoughts was formed in Liaodong area and spreaded to Liaoxi area, and was in full bloom in Liaoxi area and again spreaded to Zhongyuan area. This is why the chinese official reports on Wanfabozi relic(State Administration of Cultural Heritage國家文物局’s) completely concealed Heaven Ritual facility.

통화 만발발자 제천유적 추보(追補) 연구: 『통화만발발자유지고고발굴보고』를 중심으로

정경희(Jung, Kyung-Hee) 한국유라시아연구원 2020 유라시아문화 Vol.3 No.-

본고는 통화 만발발자 제천유적에 대한 필자의 기존 연구에 근간 『통화만발발자유지고고발굴보고』를 추가, 만발발자 제천유적의 분기별 변천상을 새롭게 조명한 연구이다. 1기-조단(B.C.4000~B.C.3500년)의 시기, 선도사상의 요체인 삼원(천·지·인, 원·방·각)의 상징성을 요령 있게 담아낸 거대 규모의 적석단총, ‘3층원단(모자합장묘)·방대’가 조성되었다. 그 주인은 배달국 초 환웅족이 가져온 선진적 선도제천문화를 수용하여 토템족 웅족사회를 천손족 맥족(환웅족+웅족)사회로 바꾸어놓은 역량 있는 선인 지도자 웅녀군이었다. 1기(B.C.4000~B.C.3000년, 배달국 전·중기) 제천단의 거대 규모와 대비되는 간결하고 담백한 제천의 흔적은 선도제천문화의 태동기, 군더더기 없이 기본에 충실한 선도제천문화의 출발점을 보여주었다. 2기(B.C.13세기~8세기, 단군조선 후기) 만발발자의 드넓은 소도제천지에는 3층원단·방대의 국부에 주·부 제천사 2좌가 들어서 있었을 뿐이었다. 1기에 자리 잡힌 소도제천문화의 기본 틀이 유지되고 있었던 것으로 바라보게 된다. 3기(B.C.8세기~B.C.3세기, 단군조선 말기)가 되자 소도제천문화가 크게 형식화되고 번잡해졌으며, 이전에 보이지 않던 위계성까지 생겨났다. 단군조선 말기 맥족사회의 분열·와해 국면 속에서 선도제천문화도 세속화되고 있었던 것이다. 4기(B.C.3세기~3세기, 고구려 개창기)가 되자 종래 번속화 방향으로 흘렀던 소도제천문화는 재차 간결화되면서 새로운 안정 국면을 맞았다. 고구려의 개창으로 맥족사회가 안정을 찾아가는 시대분위기와 맞물린 변화였다. 5기(3세기~5세기, 고구려 중기)에는 제천시설의 중첩 및 소규모화 현상, 또 제천공간의 축소 현상이 두드러졌다. 고구려 중기 선도제천문화의 위상이 서서히 약화되어 가는 추세를 보여주었다. This paper is a supplementary study that sheds light on the changes of ‘Wanfabozi萬發撥子 relic’ according to the periods by adding 『Tonghua Wanfabozi Site Archaeological Excavation Report』 to my previous study on Wanfabozi relic. During the early 1st period of Wanfabozi(4000B.C.∼3500B.C., early Baedalkook倍達國), the huge scale stone mound altar·tomb, i.e., ‘the three-layered circular altar with attached square altar(3層圓壇·方臺)’ that captured the symbolism of Samwon三元(Cheon天·Ji地·In人, Won圓·Bang方·Gak角), a key element of Sundo仙道 ideas, was built. Its owner was King Ung-nyeo熊女君, a competent good leader who transformed ‘Totem Ung熊 people’ society into ‘Heavenly Maek貊 people(Hwanung桓雄 people + Ung people)’ society by accepting the advanced Sundo culture brought by Hwanung people in early Baedalkook. During the 1st period of Wanfabozi(4000B.C.∼3000 B.C., early and middle Baedalkook), in contrast to the huge scale of ‘the three-layered circular altar with attached square altar’, the traces of concise and plain ritual procedure showed the starting point of the Sundo Heaven Ritual culture, which is faithful to the basics and the essence of the Sundo without any unnecessity. In the 2nd period of Wanfabozi(the 13th century B.C.∼the 8th century B.C., late Dangun Josun檀君朝鮮), there were only two main and secondary temples for Heaven Ritual on a part of ‘the three-layered circular altar with attached square altar’. The framework of the Sundo Heaven Ritual culture, which was established in the 1st period, was maintained. In the 3rd period of Wanfabozi(the 8rd century B.C.∼the 3rd century B.C., late Dangun Josun), the Sundo Heaven Ritual culture was formalized and complicated, and even the hierarchical tendency that had never existed before was formed. In the midst of the division and disintegration of the Maek貊 society in late Dangun Josun, the Sundo Heaven Ritual culture was also being secularized. In the 4th period of Wanfabozi(the 3rd century B.C.∼the 3rd century, early Goguryeo高句麗), the Sundo Heaven Ritual culture, which had been flowing in the direction of secularization, had been arranged in order again and had taken a new phase of stability. These changes were coincided with the mood of the times that the founding of Goguryeo brought a new stability to the Maek society. During the 5th period of Wanfabozi(the 3rd century∼the 5th century, middle Goguryeo), the noticeable point of change in Wanfabozi were just the miniaturization of the Heaven Ritual facilities and the reduction of ritual space. These points show that the status of the Sundo Heaven Ritual culture in the Maek society was gradually weakening from this time on.

백두산 서편의 제천유적과 B.C.4000년~A.D.600년경 요동 · 요서 · 한반도의 ‘환호를 두른 구릉성 제천시설’에 나타난 맥족의 선도제천문화권

정경희(Jung Kyung-Hee) 고조선단군학회 2019 고조선단군학 Vol.40 No.-

1990년대 중국측은 ‘요하문명론-장백산문화론’에 따라 백두산 일대에서 홍산문화(선상문화 · 예제문화)의 요소를 찾아내고자 하였고 일차적으로 백두산 서편 통화지역의 적석 단 · 총에 주목하였다. 통화 일대의 고제단 연구는 1989년 여명 제단의 발견에서 시작되었는데, 중국 당국의 주목을 받아 1990년대 10여년간 만발발자 제단 및 여명 제단을 위시하여 무려 40여기에 이르는 고제단군이 발굴조사 되었다. 발굴 결과를 종합해보면, 백두산 서편 제천유적의 기본 성격은 B.C.4000년~A.D.600년경 환호를 두른 구릉성 제천시설(3층원단 · 선돌 · 적석단 · 제천사류)로 정리된다. 이는 요서 우하량 상층적석총 단계(B.C.3500년~B.C.3000년경)의 환호를 두른 구릉성 제천시설(3층원단류), 청동기~초기철기시대 한반도 남부의 환호를 두른 구릉성 제천시설(적석단 · 나무솟대 · 제천사 · 선돌류)로 계승되었다. 필자는 이상의 ① B.C.4000년~A.D.600년경 요동 백두산 서편지역의 환호를 두른 구릉성 제천시설(3층원단 · 선돌 · 적석단 · 제천사류), ② B.C.3500년~B.C.3000년경 요서 우하량지역의 환호를 두른 구릉성 제천시설(3층원단류), ③ 청동기~초기철기시대 한반도 남부지역의 환호를 두른 구릉성 제천시설(적석단 · 나무솟대 · 제천사 · 선돌류)을 동일 계통 유적으로 보고, ‘B.C.4000년~A.D.600년경 요동 · 요서 · 한반도의 환호를 두른 구릉성 제천시설(3층원단 · 적석단 · 나무솟대 · 제천사 · 선돌류)로 총칭해보았다. 중국측이 ‘요하문명론-장백산문화론’을 추진해간 결과 아이러니하게도 B.C.4000년~A.D.600년경 요동 · 요서 · 한반도지역을 관통하던 ‘맥족계 선도제천문화권’의 존재가 드러난 것이다.